If WAR was only released now instead of being rushed. I think it would have killed WoW now.
Nah. In it's current state, it's probably worse than back in the days of 1.0.6. 3.1 horribly unbalanced the game (aoe damage is completely out of whack) and whatever changes they made to the engine actually
slowed it down more. It's still full of bugs, and Tier 4 is still crap and boring. WAR is going to need a lot more time and a lot more love from the developers before it comes close to being able to topple WoW. And yeah, this is coming from someone who, as people here can probably attest, was once a total WAR fanboy.
EvE is enjoying a surge in popularity because of timing, straight and simple. They launched Apocrypha and started putting boxes on shelves at
exactly the time WoW raiders are experiencing a content burnout and a lack of new challenges. Suddenly we're all looking around trying to find something that offers a real challenge, a real depth and a real, worthwhile investment. EvE offers all these things. It's not trying to be a nice, friendly family game, and that's what a lot of WoW vets who've cut their teeth on the hardest content WoW has to offer and are left wanting much, much more, are now looking for.
I think EvE is going to see a lot of interest, but much of it won't be able to vault that learning curve. It's not even that EvE is all that hard. It's just radically
different and requires a complete rethink and relearn process. Most people are looking for WoW 2.0 and they won't find it in EvE. But those who're willing to put slug it out will probably find an incredibly vast and rich universe to explore.