You're more than welcome to read some letters here http://www.orange-papers.org/ ... just scroll to the bottom
I think there's close to 3,000+ there ... they all follow the same theme. Alternativly there is Google - but this is a pointless debate. If it worked for them, great.
I've read the orange papers before, addiction and rehabilitation is a long time interest of mine and I did a lot of research when my ex-heroin addict friend first asked me for help (I paid for her rehab at the time).
The orange-papers is one mans analysis of Alcoholics Anonymous and like any large organization AA is open to abuse by people.
The experiences of people who wrote in to that site is not the same as the experiences of people I know in SA who go to AA/NA.
There is nothing cult-like about it, in my experience .
That some people abuse the program to fulfill their own power hungry agenda is sad, and I'm unhappy that AA/NA is considered the 'standard' form of treatment as I personally think harm reduction strategies are more effective
than than the 'total abstinence or die' philosophy of AA/NA.