May as well hijack the thread since it's up for grabs:
How do you feel about having your husband's birthday "party" at home, inviting 35 guests and saying "if you don't want to bring a gift, he's going to watch the rugby in Netherlands next year so money is welcome"?
Also BYOB.
I think it's despicable and I paid R500 to sit in a plastic garden chair, no music because it's a complex - R500!!!!
Now she's planning her own birthday party for September and because it's family I feel morally obligated to go.
For me, host/ hostess should pay for the food, even if it's hotdogs or pizza. BYOB is fine and gift is at the guests' discretion.