Galaxy S2 (and maybe android) cons - actual users only

Status
Not open for further replies.
Has anyone successfully flashed another ROM onto their s2? I've tried and googled the usual steps but allows end up with a signature verification error. Seems a common problem...anyone managed ?
 
Wow there are some hardcore iPhans here, didn't the title say users only?

Anyways... I bought one for my GF and here are my concerns with the device.

Before I start listing, I just want to mention the plastic build... The plastic actually makes it lighter more durable, this is not a "cheap" decision from samsung or they would not have included Gorilla glass technology unlike apple, they chose not to take the more durable technology that can only be explained by wanting to save money, i.e. cheap. This results in a device that is extremely fragile even with a bumper. Don't get me wrong, an iPhone looks like a premium device but that's about it. The solid, heavy and compact build make it shatter when it bumps anything too hard. It's been known to shatter from knee height with a bumper.

Problems with the SGS2, I will list everything I can think of although in most cases many people will not really be phased. I don't see any of these as deal breakers.

-No LED notification (Although it does make a noise when it's fully charged which I prefer, overcharging batteries is the best way to make them not last)
-No scrollwheel / infrared sensor? (not sure what it's called but my Desire has one and if I use any phone without one I miss it but that's a personal thing)
-Battery isn't that good but it's comparable to any other smartphone with a large screen, in most cases performs better, remember, the more charge cycles you go through the longer your battery will last.
-Slight Deathgrip, while holding the phone in a certain way I found that the signal drops but I don't think many people will even notice it because it doesn't cut off reception completely
-Comes with Samsung crappy TouchWiz, yes they crapped all over android with their own customisation but this is a personal thing and can be fixed with a root.
-Looks like an iPhone but bigger of course, when the SGS1 came out I didn't even consider it and chose the desire, the SGS2 has a way bigger screen than the iPhone so it's much more distinguishable.
You will get arrogant iPhans blindly bitching at you, I dono maybe they're jealous but they swear blindly that that their iCrap don't stink.

I'm not an Android phanboy, I prefer Android but I can still rationalise, I've played with the iPad 2 and I really like it, it's very pleasing to use. I can see advantages of both operating systems, I don't just blindly defend my purchase.

Android and Apple have taken 2 very different approaches when it come to marketing and Apple chose an awesomely intriguing approach.

Android took a technical approach

Apple took an evolutionary approach, they know people are stupid, they make devices for idiots, and this is win for them. They've made something very user friendly that can still do advanced tasks and has semi advanced hardware.

So, if you feel you are a slightly more advanced user, Android is for you.
 
Last edited:
Android/SGS2 Pro's

Just to name a few:
  • Samba, Share your phone as if its a PC on your WiFi network.
  • PPPOE, can connect to your ADSL directly from your phone.
  • Hardware, Can connect HDMI + WII and use it as a game console on your TV with full emulator support.
  • Customization, Can change the look of your phone to fit your needs from widgets to full launcher changers and dont forget Swipe.
  • Data Management, from Alerts and monitors to Per app firewalls and more, you get to decide what data your phone can or can not use and when.
  • Flash, You can decide to turn flash on or off, not someone else.
  • Navigation, can use Free turn by turn voice navigation. I know Android/iPhone both have access to commercial applications but I never need to get one as Google nav is good enough.
  • Market access, no need to use fake/false details to buy vouchers to get games or other applications.
  • Security Software Applications like WifiKill, Anti and Faceniff that you will never find in the iPhone world.


Just one thing to add about Jailbreak comments:
In order to use Jailbreak you have to stay on Old versions of iOS, if you do go for the latest you can only use this tethered, that means you have to be close to a PC when your phone reboots else your stuffed. Some applications have problems when you stay on old version of the OS and refuse to work.

So if you Jailbreak, Pray your phone dont reboot when you leave your house, and YES it did happen to me.

Awesome? I didn't know about the PPPOE
I agree, the free Google Nav is awesome, my 2 year old Desire has replaced my Garmin GPS, the Garmin is old and outdated and Google Nav always seems to be up to date

Let me add a few more Pros?

  • Has a back button
  • Best value for money smartphone at R6000 for an extremely high spec device.
  • Has Widgets
  • Super AMOLED Plus is currently the best screen technology for a mobile device
  • 3 x faster internet than iPhone 4
  • Micro SD
  • You can use as a mass storage device
  • Has a radio
  • Very thin
  • Very light
  • Extremely durable with Gorilla Glass
  • Big Screen
  • 1GB ram
  • Fast browser
  • Dual Core 1.2 GHz (iPhone 4 0.8GHz iPhone 4s Dual Core 0.8GHz)
  • Completely customisable thanks to the openness of Android
  • You can install custom roms



I've found MIUI to be so smooth and responsive, something that Apple has had over Android to be honest.

Did you find the SPB Shell of similar responsiveness? think I'm on MIUI 111180

Contemplating dropping the the 100+ bucks for SPB Shell

Oh cool looks like my MIUI is downloading an OTA
 
Last edited:
Why do all these threads have to turn into "mine is bigger than yours" fight?

Another going nowhere apple vs. android thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X