LCD and Plasma Bargains and Discussions thread

Roman4604

Executive Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2005
Messages
5,554
The motion handling is an issue for me as I like to game
Not quite the same thing. The E550 seems to battle with low/irregular frame rates which isn't exactly the same case with gaming i.e. the console/PC will be sending 60 fps progressive.

I honestly haven't done enough playing/investigation on the E550 to see if this type of input will be susceptible to motion anomalies. Theoretically there is a chance during complex scenes in games where the GPU is not able to render 60 full frames per sec, but I'm not sure if this would translate into visible judder?

PS: Some anecdotal experiences here with similar Samsung plasma ... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6T3Wx5l7zU ... watch vertical edges moving horizontally.
 
Last edited:

BlackWasp

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2006
Messages
654

The_Mad_Hatter

New Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2012
Messages
4
I mailed them now to find out how come the item is no longer on their site.

The response they just moved hosting servers, and in the process the bach-up restored was from three weeks ago by the new hosting company. I have been there :crying:

Well, the salesperson, or whoever responded, told me that they actually do have stock and they only list products that are in-stock.
All stock from Samsung South Africa, with full warranties from Samsung directly and brand new, for R 6 299-00 and only R 150-00 to deliver. They even told me to contact Samsung, LG, Sony or any other supplier that they sell for to confirm that the company is legit.

This is the cheapest i have found so far.
 

MR.C

Expert Member
Joined
Mar 7, 2008
Messages
4,988

iceman23

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2007
Messages
954
The ES6200 with its brighter, semi-matt panel would be more ideal.

cant comment on the E550 but the ES6200 is quiet reflective of artificial light to be honest. I find myself moving my head to find a position where I dont see the reflection.

It's a lot different when the light is off though :D
 

Roman4604

Executive Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2005
Messages
5,554
cant comment on the E550 but the ES6200 is quiet reflective of artificial light to be honest. I find myself moving my head to find a position where I dont see the reflection.
How would you compare it to your plasma?

My D6000 has the full gloss panel (UltraClear as Samsung refer to it). The reflections are as well formed (focused) as the E550 but a tad less intense (bright).
 

Roman4604

Executive Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2005
Messages
5,554
Finally got all my HDMI extender kit, but thought before installation I'd accurately compare my 46D6000 LED (left) vs 51E550 plasma (right) side by side off a HDMI splitter.

In ideal dimly light conditions with both sets properly calibrated off the same high quality source (DSTV 1080i HD) their PQ is equally as great ...

D6000vsE550_1.JPG


When you add some additional ambient light the E550's colours start washing out a bit, though the difference is not as exaggerated as my iPhone4's camera makes out ...

D6000vsE550_2.JPG


But then again like all LEDs if you watch the D6000 at more than ~40 degrees off centre axis, the contrast also suffers.

Reflectivity is pretty similar with the E550's reflection brightness being more intense. Also the E550's panel is a light grey compared to the D6000's jet black leading to blacks becoming grey in brighter ambient light ...

D6000vsE550_3.JPG


PQ is not really a differentiator, even with SD upscaled on an HDPVR its near identical.

The real difference as mentioned before is the motion handling superiority of the D6000's 100Hz engine (& backlight scanning system). With Motion Plus set to Clear & LED Motion Plus On the D6000 smoothens out all low/irregular frame rate content. The E550 exhibits quite serious judder on the same scenes depending on how bad the content is, especially in sideways pans.

They are both great mid-range TV, but ultimately I'd still choose the LED's motion handling even though I'd have to sacrifice a few inches in screen size and pay ~ R1K more.
 
Last edited:

Spizz

Goat Botherer
Joined
Jan 19, 2009
Messages
31,550
cant comment on the E550 but the ES6200 is quiet reflective of artificial light to be honest. I find myself moving my head to find a position where I dont see the reflection.

It's a lot different when the light is off though :D

Don't you think that is a problem for tv's in general though? Reflections have been a scourge on any kind of tv since time John Logie Baird told his wife to draw the curtains...
 

iceman23

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2007
Messages
954
How would you compare it to your plasma?

My D6000 has the full gloss panel (UltraClear as Samsung refer to it). The reflections are as well formed (focused) as the E550 but a tad less intense (bright).

Well the plasma has quite a good anti reflective coat so dont really notice reflection too much. It is quite a bit better than the LED at that.

Re: your question about the motion handling. My plasma is 100 / 120 Hz with quite a nice picture engine so also no issues there. There is something called cinema smooth for the picture engine.

I kept on beating myself about paying so much 3 years ago when I look at the price of tvs now. But then I realise that is the way the market goes as well as that the series 6 now is very different to the series 6 then
 

iceman23

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2007
Messages
954
Don't you think that is a problem for tv's in general though? Reflections have been a scourge on any kind of tv since time John Logie Baird told his wife to draw the curtains...

for sure. the more expensive tvs have nicer A/R coats but doesn't eradicate the problem totally. I think matt LCD's are pretty good with reflections though. Someone else might be able to confirm. (I had a sony lcd a while back but it never faced direct sunlight and i hardly ever watched it so cant be sure :) )
 

Roman4604

Executive Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2005
Messages
5,554
Well the plasma has quite a good anti reflective coat so dont really notice reflection too much.
Ya, unfortunately as indicated in the photo above the newer 5 series plasmas don't have any AR coating and produce quite bright reflective glare.

Re: your question about the motion handling. My plasma is 100 / 120 Hz with quite a nice picture engine so also no issues there. There is something called cinema smooth for the picture engine.
Don't think Cinema Smooth has anything to do with frame interpolation (100Hz+ engine), rather its the way the TV handles 24p input. The E550 has it but it doesn't seem to work (does nothing). The settings that usually indicate a Samsung TV does frame interpolation are called Motion Plus, hence my question about these settings. Would have thought your B650 would have them somewhere?

From what I've read Samsung stopped putting 100Hz+ engines into their Plasmas after the 2010 C series, supposedly not even the D/E8000 do frame interpolation (hence why their lower pricing compared to the high-end LEDs which go up to the equivalent of 800Hz or CMR).
 

iceman23

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2007
Messages
954
Ya, unfortunately as indicated in the photo above the newer 5 series plasmas don't have any AR coating and produce quite bright reflective glare.

Don't think Cinema Smooth has anything to do with frame interpolation (100Hz+ engine), rather its the way the TV handles 24p input. The E550 has it but it doesn't seem to work (does nothing). The settings that usually indicate a Samsung TV does frame interpolation are called Motion Plus, hence my question about these settings. Would have thought your B650 would have them somewhere?

From what I've read Samsung stopped putting 100Hz+ engines into their Plasmas after the 2010 C series, supposedly not even the D/E8000 do frame interpolation (hence why their lower pricing compared to the high-end LEDs which go up to the equivalent of 800Hz or CMR).

I do remember seeing motion plus somewhere. will have a look. yep correct about cinema smooth. there was some judder when this wasn't on, on 24p input or something like that. (was a long time ago so cant remember too well).

Didnt know about the 100Hz thing. quite interesting...
 

The_Mowgs

Honorary Master
Joined
Nov 23, 2009
Messages
17,910
What are your guys' thought on Philips and Panasonic Plasmas/LCD/"LED"? Reading international sites they always praise these 2 makes but I hardly see any advertising in SA for these brands. How are their prices looking at size and PQ?
 

PostmanPot

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 16, 2005
Messages
34,953
What are your guys' thought on Philips and Panasonic Plasmas/LCD/"LED"? Reading international sites they always praise these 2 makes but I hardly see any advertising in SA for these brands. How are their prices looking at size and PQ?

Prices are not as competitive as Samsung/LG AFAIK, at least with Panasonic, never seen Philips. Panasonic has one interesting model though which is unique - 42" FHD plasma, where the others are all HD Ready.
 

MegaTesla

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2007
Messages
441
Seems like there is a ps43e550 FHD (1080) out in Europe now!

http://bit.ly/Q4tWUq

If anyone sees one in SA please post it in this thread. My lounge is too small for anything larger and I would love a FHD samsung for the occasional plug-my-laptop-in.
 
Last edited:

PostmanPot

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 16, 2005
Messages
34,953
Edit: whoops! I see the E550 has been mentioned...

Seems like there is a ps43e550 FHD (1080) out in Europe now!

http://bit.ly/Q4tWUq

If anyone sees one in SA please post it in this thread. My lounge is too small for anything larger and I would love a FHD samsung for the occasional plug-my-laptop-in.

Very interesting, keeping an eye out...
 

PostmanPot

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 16, 2005
Messages
34,953
Not sure what the difference is between PS43E550 and PN43E550, but here is a short review of the PN43E550:

http://reviews.plasmatvbuyingguide.com/samsung-plasma-tv/samsung-pn43e550.html

As far as I can see it has been released this year, but isn't available anywhere online.

PN = North America
PS = Southern Hemisphere
PE = Europe

etc. Along those lines. Sometimes there are minor spec differences (which makes it very confusing!).

Samsung 42/43" plasmas have always been epic, would love to upgrade my HD Ready PS42C450 to a FHD version.

Would take a bit of sacrificing SD quality which is still important to me, mind you.
 

MegaTesla

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2007
Messages
441
In other threads they say we will never see the 43" FHD Samsung because of not enough interest in that size FHD plasmas. Even the FHD 42" Panasonic TC-P42UT50 (available overseas) has been discontinued after only a few months :(
 
Top