MTN Service degradation

ngericke

New Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2012
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Location
A, A
Where we stay we do not have access to any Telkom infrastructure, and were forced to make use of 3G products. We happily paid the over inflated 3G prices, seeing that the quality of service was quite acceptable. Last year October however our connectivity took a serious dip. At present we have no connectivity. We are paying almost R900/mo for an uncapped service that cannot open email or even a local news site.

We at first thought it must be our equipmeTNnt. We were using a Planet 3G router for almost 1 year then, and thought it might be time to replace it. We then opted for a very expensive Mikrotik solution. Still no improvement. We then purchased a booster aerial. Still no luck. R5k poorer and still nothing!

Our service has now gone from bad to worse and is impacting on our work, and we are forced to work longer hours. When the problem started, we found that from 7PM every evening we have little to no connectivity. Today, if we are able to establish a connection, the speed is much worse than a 56k dial-up. Our voice quality has also dropped significantly, and most of our calls are being dropped. Last week I had to call a customer back 9 times on a 3 minute call.

Most of the time it is a battle getting through to competent technical support staff, when you call the mobile operators. We have spent countless hours on the phone with clueless technicians.

After lodging two complaints on http://www.hellopeter.com we finally got a response. This is the final result:

We have done drive tests in the area, and found that the signal levels are very low, especially on 3G. As per attached correspondence , it does not look like we can improve coverage in this area.

Complaint #1 : http://www.hellopeter.com/autopage/complaints-to-compliments/non-existant-tec...
Complaint #2 : http://www.hellopeter.com/autopage/complaints/service-degradation-734813

Our reality is that we rely on connectivity to earn a living, and without no connectivity, there is no income.

We are not being unreasonable here: We did not go out and buy all this stuff to use in some area where there wasn't any signal and now supposedly sit with buyers remorse. No, we were actually happy customers until the MTN tower broke in Paarl. We know this, because a consultant from a company called Bytes, was hired by MTN to investigate the issue, and he told us there is a problem. We also have the Google Latitude logs to prove it.

Just to make matters much much worse, my family suffered a terrible personal loss because of this. Last week (and now if this was America I would have sued) Thursday, we were forced to drive out to our office after hours, due to the lack of internet once-again. We went home just after 5PM to check on our pets. Left about 15mins later. We came back 3 hours later to a heart-breaking sight. Our boston terrier, Pogo was bitten by a snake, and by the time we found him it was too late. We rushed him to the vet, but he sadly passed away in my arms on our way to the vet. Struggling to get a call through with 3 phones, all on a bad MTN signal - imagine the words I have for these people.
If we had the same connectivity as we did last year October, then we would have stayed home - because it was only emails we needed to respond to. And even if our dog found a snake in the garden, we might have been in a position to save his life.

I am slowly getting fed up with the poor technology service in this country. Large profit hungry foreign corporations bleed us dry, while they do not accept the responsibility for providing the service - which only they are licensed for.
With the privilege comes a responsibility. I have now seen first hand what happens when these careless operators are allowed to run wild without consequence.
 
Email from MTN - note where they say they cannot call us

From: Wayne Manuel [ MTN - Harrington Street ]
Sent: Monday, 20 February 2012 01:22 PM
To: David Mongezi Msiba [ MTNSP - Constantia Park ]; Haroun Mohamed [ MTN - Innovation Centre ]
Cc: Jerusha Naidu [ MTNSP - Innovation Centre ]
Subject: RE: FW: - Network Coverage Iusses [#4795263] problem ref# 0036879

Hi David

We have done drive tests in the area, and found that the signal levels are very low, especially on 3G. As per attached correspondence , it does not look like we can improve coverage in this area. I tried contacting Andre( contact person), but to date has not returned my calls.

Regards
Wayne
 
......, it does not look like we can improve coverage in this area.

If you were able to get decent coverage when you signed up until Oct.'11, and they're not prepared to improve it once again for you, you should be looking to get out of your existing contract, and at no cost to yourselves.
I'm no legal expert, but contact the CPA - also depends on when you signed up & when the CPA came into existence.

It would seem like MTN have done something to your detriment & others in your area, perhaps to save on their own costs ? - try checking with people who use MTN where you live/work.

At the same time, are you testing prepaid SIM cards for Vodacom, Cell C & 8ta ?
With a bit of luck, you might get even 1/2 decent coverage from one of them, though it does sound as though you live in the 'bundu'.
At least you don't need to spend a cent (other than the cost of the SIMs & 8ta's should be free) to test their network's.

Also, don't sign any more contracts for 3G/voice, as you'll then be stuck with another network for 2 years, and even if you get decent signals with them now, that can also change, as you've found out with MTN.

Try selling the equipment you bought to recover some of the R5k outlay.
 
If you were able to get decent coverage when you signed up until Oct.'11, and they're not prepared to improve it once again for you, you should be looking to get out of your existing contract, and at no cost to yourselves.
I'm no legal expert, but contact the CPA - also depends on when you signed up & when the CPA came into existence.

It would seem like MTN have done something to your detriment & others in your area, perhaps to save on their own costs ? - try checking with people who use MTN where you live/work.

At the same time, are you testing prepaid SIM cards for Vodacom, Cell C & 8ta ?
With a bit of luck, you might get even 1/2 decent coverage from one of them, though it does sound as though you live in the 'bundu'.
At least you don't need to spend a cent (other than the cost of the SIMs & 8ta's should be free) to test their network's.

Also, don't sign any more contracts for 3G/voice, as you'll then be stuck with another network for 2 years, and even if you get decent signals with them now, that can also change, as you've found out with MTN.

Try selling the equipment you bought to recover some of the R5k outlay.

They are USELESS !!! PERIOD !!!

I have friends in my area who are all on MTN and for the last 10 days have been having endless problems, they can't send as much as an email with just the word "yebo" in it.

I tried to help my one friend with her brand new MTN huawei modem, straight out of the box we had problems. It connected to the network but I could not ping or transmit any data whatsoever. She sat here at my place and phoned MTN's help line 7 TIMES and each time they just cut her off. I then called their support line from my land line and they kept me on hold for over 40 minutes after which I dropped the call as I refuse to be treated like a piece of ****. Their support line also does not have the decency to even tell you how far you are in the queue, all it does is play that ridiculous annoying MTN whistling tune that they use on their ads.

I have now advised all 3 of my my friends in this area to all log complaints directly with ICASA ([email protected]) and with the National Consumer Tribunal ([email protected] / [email protected])

I suggest you do the same, you're paying good money and being treated like dirt by a bunch of clowns. Forget trying to speak directly to MTN because they simply do not seem to care one iota about you so send your complaints to the institutions who are there to protect your rights as a consumer.
 
I have been an MTN customer for many years now with few problems but lately here in White River it is virtually impossible to get any form of signal in the Yaverland area for phones or modems. We have lodged a complaint as no MTN user on our Estate has any signal.
I supposedly have a MTN 3G connection but I am sending this via my Cell C card roaming on Vodacom on Edge as it is the only hope I have at the moment.:cry:
 
I stay in Killarney and I have also had major problems with the network .. the call quality is always poor with lots of dropped calls.
 
same thing happend in my area,i logged many calls with the coverage desk,i gave up,i don't understand how an area on decent coverage suddenly hardly gets enough signal to make a decent call
 
Everyone is having problems with MTN's 3g. For the past week I've had periods of up to an hour without any connection and yet if I change to my Vodacom sim it works perfectly.I've heard countless people complaining about the same thing.

MTN has some major problems and yet I have a feeling they will say their network is running perfectly.
 
problems in roodepoort, use to get 80KB/s spikes when loading pages, now average at less than 5KB/s when loading pages
 
Hi . Is there something wrong with MTN network ? Anybody here heard anything official.
On first connect i get 3G for about 5 mins then its EDGE all the way whole day. Vodacom and 8ta still goes full strength.
And I'm in Cape Town CBD.
 
Yip. Tried everything. But outside building I get H+ I see. I'll have to live with it I guess. Had to stay with VC on this one. Always got /get great coverage.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X