Comments (Zach) on Engadget about the N97:
I've had this phone for a month and I first want to echo the most common
comments: Needs to be snappier (=faster processor) needs more RAM, needs
a more responsive touch screen.
Before I add anything else in this comment the most important thing
about the phone is this:
** The Nokia N97 has probably more features and a better spec sheet than
almost any other device out there. It can multitask and DO more things
at one time than probably any other device. The problem? Its not FUN
to actually use any of this functionality, it's FRUSTRATING!**
Heres why:
1) As you go about your routine of installing apps and bits of
functionality to the device you will inevitably use up some of the
(TINY!) main onboard memory. Thats right, the box says 32GB and it has
a 32GB memory device inside, but its also got this tiny ~100MB memory
device for the OS and lots of critical applications. If this tiny main
memory gets to less than, say, 10MB then the overall device performance
slows down to a crawl and the device becomes unusable.
This is unfortunate as things like NGage, Nokia Maps, the Ovi Store etc.
all must be installed on this tiny main memory, leading it to quickly
dwindle to an unsafe range
2) Responsiveness (even with 10MB + on the main disk) Occasionally I'll
do something, like say hang up at the end of a phone conversation and the device will
just sit there for 3 or 4 seconds. I'll push buttons and nothing will
happen. Then, when the phone feels like it, it'll snap back together
all at once replaying all the haptic feedback that should've happened 4
seconds ago and I end up accidentally opening like 4 applications and
the headache starts all over again!
3) It crashes. The web browser is pretty horrendously unstable and
difficult to use. On Wifi its not so bad but on 3G the overall
experience is pretty lame. I'll echo the 'the menu on the side often
takes up FAR too much real estate' sentiment here.
Also, those crashes where the device locks up and I have to take out
the battery? Not cool. This happens once a week at minimum.
4) The homescreen 'Widgets' that Nokia pushed so hard for are ultimately
a giant fail. None of the internet connected widgets can stay on the
hoemscreen because inevitably one of them will decide they want the
internet connection to be active all day and my battery will be dead by
lunchtime. Theres the option to disable internet connectivity for
widgets but then whats the point of having internet connected widgets if
I have to manually tell them when they can and cannot use the internet
every time? They should connect once, get the data they need and
connect again an hour later to refresh etc.
5) The Camera application still takes way too long to startup, I've
missed countless photo ops because of this, very frustrating.
6) Enabling 'theme effects' (AKA bring the UI out of the 90s and into
the ~2003 Era of UI bells and whistles) uses so much memory and makes
the phone so unstable that i had to turn it back off.
7) EVERYTHING should use kenetic scrolling, i do NOT want to use my
fingers to grab those tiny scrollbars. EVER!
8) Symbian needs threaded SMS. Nokia's "Conversation" application which
did this for S60v3 had not yet been ported to S60v5 and messaging is
rather lame without it. This app should ship built in with every
symbian s60 device -- third party unintegrated solutions just don't cut
it with their level of integration into the native messaging system.
9) Notifications. In the era of the Palm Pre and Android with superb
notification systems, Nokia's tiny little icons need work. As it is I
had to install a third party app to actually show me the incomming txt
when its recieved ontop of my currently running application. But then
to get rid of the 'new message' icon in the corner I still have to open
the normal messaging application and 'read' the message!
I could go on... but I think I've made my point. The UI is outdated and
unfun and Nokia has failed to innovate and failed to pick up on
the innovations of the smartphone os ecosystem as a whole. I do not
recommend people buy this device -- get yourself a pre, an android or an
iphone if you care at all about ever *wanting* to use your phone, I
always dread taking mine out of my pocket.