The mind is made up...It will be the C30. We've had two VW Polo's (1.6 Comfortline & 1.6 Comfortline).....good car, good build quality, but it could be better. For example. We bought both cars new. The second one had chips in the paint, skew panel fitments inside and a skew door. We took delivery and drove it straight back to the dealer who drove it straight to the panel beater...So, We've got nothing against VW, but we compared the build quality of the C30 to the Golf VI and there is little between them. Anyways, the GTi we'll leave to the average Joe....there are enough buyers for that car.....plus its a very boring car tbh.
Loose value....when has a car ever been an asset? You'll have to buy a Ferrari or Lambo for that to be applicable. O yes, and a Toyota Corolla or Hilux....all cars lose value. That little book the dealers have is the biggest con you get in the second-hand motor industry. You'll have a dealer offering peanuts for a well looked after Renault and sell it at an amazing profit. I've seen this with my own eyes....when selling, the dealer tells you about the expensive parts, poor backup service....when you buy the car, they tell you that the brand has made a big turn around, etc, etc. So, VW, Toyota is for the average guy/girl out there....She wants a car for her and the C30 is the most stunning car in her eyes than any other. I also did not like it in the beginning, but having spent a weekend with it and finding all the comforts and gadgets on the car was awesome....it won me over quite convincingly.
As I've mentioned, the dealer gave us a C30 T5 for a weekend and its an amazing car. When we drove the 2.0 last week, the wife drove it for a while and immediately said that the car lacks power. Its not slow, but having experienced the T5 it was hard to accept the powerloss.
Its simply between all the options you can add to the 2.0 for the same price as a demo T5 pre-facelift....
and yes, the C30 is a very refined car....the T5 has got more of a low-down torque-grunt character. The car surges ahead as opposed to rocket away....I don't know how to describe it, but it gets from 80 to 180km/h very, very quickly....