PlayStation Move vs Microsoft Kinect

RazedInBlack

RazedInBlack
Joined
Sep 4, 2008
Messages
38,269
Reaction score
6,848
Location
<Cape Town>
Move:
The glowing orb on the end of the Move controller can be tracked within a millimeter of its position. Not just on a 2D plane but distance too – the larger that orb appears to the PS Eye camera the closer the PlayStation knows it is. And any time the camera can't see the orb, those sensors in its body effectively take over.

There's also no risk of the orb blending in with anything in the background – the PS3 will monitor your surroundings and prompt the orbs to glow any one of over a hundred different colours so that it contrasts suitably.

Although there's no way of knowing if another bright light source in the background could momentarily confuse the PS Eye until we test it thoroughly, its certain to be far more reliable that the Wii Remote's IR sensor (that top panel that sees the Sensor Bar on your TV), which is sensitive to everything from candles and lighters to Christmas lights and even sunlight. We had no issues using Move on a busy expo show floor.

Kinect
Kinect admittedly has the tougher task of tracking your entire body with no visual aids whatsoever - no pin-on lights and no handheld sensors. And we were somewhat disappointed to see that the difficulty of such a feat is evident in the device's occasional hiccups.

A Kinect racing game, Joy Ride, had us holding our fists in front of us and spinning them in circular motions as if we were clutching an invisible steering wheel. It works, most of the time, and is very impressive when you turn your first corner and realise how far videogames have come since the stiff joystick and single red button inputs of the Atari 2600.

But then you overshoot a bend and desire a steeper turn. Your instincts tell you to rotate that virtual wheel more aggressively, and that's where Kinect goes wrong. We found that if your fists pass the 90-degree turning angle the game gets confused and sometimes steers in the opposite direction.


More:

http://www.techradar.com/news/gaming/consoles/playstation-move-vs-microsoft-kinect-701596
 
IMO, Kinect will soon be "upgraded" with some type of wand or positioning device.
 
I didn't think I would be excited about this but I am for some reason. When are they expected to be in shops?
 
The move looks like a dildo and Kinect can't track all "body types".

Thankyoucomeagain

Whats your point. Got something against dildo's? Besides I cant see how it looks like some extinct bird.
LOL
 
Whats your point. Got something against dildo's? Besides I cant see how it looks like some extinct bird.
LOL

Nothing wrong with it looking like a dildo (different to a Dodo) but its really funny to see those Ps3 fans flapping around with a glowing pink dick... now that is entertainment.
 
Can't wait to see the titles start appearing considering the fun factor on Wii.
 
lulz @ the positive spin for the move while the kinect gets all the negative
 
But dildos give more body pleasure :)

........... and it really works, and works well apparently. No over hyped up BS like other "Eye" toys we read about.

Whatever happened to Milo, the "KEY" to project Nata???????
 
Last edited:

After the race started, only one of the running models seems to have been picked up by the system – leaving her opponent eating dust. There are however, a number of pretty valid reasons for the motion tracking to go screwy. Firstly, they’re standing too close together – something that may end up confusing the body tracking systems. The game tells them how to fix this, by asking one of the players to move away.

The second reason the whole thing falls apart is far less concerning. The system is probably getting very, very confused is the constant barrage of camera flashes. Remember, Kinect’s motion sensors rely on infra-red light, a fair amount of which is output by camera pre-flashes – so it shouldn’t affect you at all, unless you happen to have a giant strobe constantly pulsing away in your living room.

Still, I’m going to have to try Kinect in my living room first before I shell out R1999 for the privilege of looking like an idiot in my own home.



Read more: http://www.lazygamer.co.za/xbox-360/watch-kinect-fail-to-detect-skinny-asian-models/#ixzz0xnqPlrDJ

Hilarious!
 
Nothing wrong with it looking like a dildo (different to a Dodo) but its really funny to see those Ps3 fans flapping around with a glowing pink dick... now that is entertainment.

Better than seeing Xbox guys flapping around with their own dicks trying to achieve some effective results?
 
lulz @ the positive spin for the move while the kinect gets all the negative

Ye this thread was really meant as an unbiased approach to both systems.

The one negative thing I did get though was non-use of any device on the Xbox system.

To quote something from IAP's post "Still, I’m going to have to try Kinect in my living room first before I shell out R1999 for the privilege of looking like an idiot in my own home."
 
I'm kinda disappointed with both tbh. Instead of taking the next step in console evolution these morons are now rehashing what's already been done by Nintendo :<
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X