Polygraph testing only one employee

She is in a state and don't know what to do.
Is it even legal to only take her for the test?

Polygraph results have no more value than reading tea leaves or a witchdoctor throwing the bones.

Her being "in a state" will affect the results and damn her.

The daughter of a friend of mine was in the same position last year and lost her job with her former boss badmouthing her to prospective employers.

DON'T GO THE POLYGRAPH ROUTE

UCT have a legal aid/advice clinic
 
Yea this is not a nice thing to go through, if you are innocent. And if she is, then she has got nothing to worry about.
You should be worried about something that has a good chance of giving a false positive.

As for the legality, yes it is legal, but they need to have a reason for suspecting her... I work in the security industry and we often have to Polygraph employees due to the nature of the industry... It can be one guy on a site or the whole team. It depends on the circumstances...
Is that before or after you hold a séance? I hear you can also use a pendulum to see if someone is answering truthfully.

I hear polygraph tests are notoriously unreliable anyway. I dont think they would gain much from it.
Useless would be the best way to describe them. Dangerously so.

If she is innocent, do the test...
False positive.
 
Let her do the test, if she's innocent, she'll be found innocent.

Fighting it will only make her look guilty.

If she didn't do anything wrong, she has nothing to worry about.
 
Ok, as someone who has been in virtually the exact situation as your GF, call a lawyer and confirm that it is legal to refuse the test.

I worked at a store, someone was stealing (hell I wasn't even in the shop the first few times it happened). After a couple of months the thief became more brazen and started stealing on shifts I was on. I suggested ways for the manager to fix the problem, but she ignored me. Eventually they created a list of ten suspects. We were told a telephonic polygraph test was being scheduled. I wrote up a legal letter explaining that I am doing this under duress (coz if I was the only one who didn't do it, it would make me look guilty). A friend of mine advised that I don't do it, but I told him that I wasn't guilty, and even though I'm nervous I shouldn't have anything to worry about.

Guess what happpened?

Machine picks me up as lying. They ask me to tell me the truth, I tell them the truth that I didn't bloody steal anything from them, and if they only listened to me we wouldn't be in this bloody situation. After trying to grind me down, they "accept" that I am telling the truth, and they legally can't fire me, but boy, did they make my life hell afterwards. A large amount of the staff somehow found out and I was basically treated like a criminal even though I did nothing wrong. I eventually found a new job and cut my ties with the place.

I had done some research and knew the machines can produce false positives, but didn't think I would. Legally, they cannot fire her based solely upon the polygraph test. Usually the cops use the polygraph test to get people to confess, by saying the machine said you are lying.

If I was you, get on the phone to a lawyer NOW.

P.S. There was a guy who was their main suspect, and whose shifts matched the exact pattern of the person stealing. He passed the polygraph test with flying colours.
 
Last edited:
She has decided to go for the test and asked me to come along as she is terrified.
We unfortunately don't have money for Legal advice at this stage.

Look, tell your GF that even if the machine says she is lying, it doesn't mean squat. Good luck to both of you.
 
P.S. There was a guy who was their main suspect, and whose shifts matched the exact pattern of the person stealing. He passed the polygraph test with flying colours.

If you believe it. Then it's not a lie. So as long as he believed he was right in doing what he was doing, his results would've been clear.
 
Hey guys, sorry for not getting back. Its been really hard these last 2 days for both of us.
She did the test, they asked her the same questions over and over again. they repeated it about 6 times, kept on saying shes hiding something and not being honest.
They didn't want to give her the results, something about its between the polygraphist and the client (her boss).
They told her she can have the rest of the day off after the test, but she must just bring in her keys for the office.
She dropped of her keys and went home.

She went in to the office this morning
I'm still waiting for a reply from her and I think she is too.
Her boss is almost never at the office, but keeping this from her is killing her.

Shes now at the office where she doesn't know what is going to happen and she must now sit there and wait and people is treating her like a thief.
Will keep you guys updated.
 
Ccma time? This is constructive dismissal surely?
 
I wouldn't want to work for a place like that - I'd take it to the CCMA.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X