Structural engineers sign off a requirement?

It would still apply to all the owners, as the complex money is from the fees paid, plus no structural engineer would just do one place and sign off a complex. As there could be other factors that might affect the roof. Plus of course the structural engineer wants money :-).
How can the oke charge R20k to climb into the attic with a torch?
 
Oh the houses will still stand, that part was rock solid, but it's things like plastic under the tiles, how many screws/nails in the ceiling, the slopes of the roofs, the distance between gutters and fascia. Things you don't really think of, but apparently have been changed or modified.
Like asbestos ceilings, people freak out over that, but it's like well as long as you're not grinding the ceiling or cutting it everyday, you won't have issues.
This attic is huge, can fit a whole extra floor in there.
 
How can the oke charge R20k to climb into the attic with a torch?
No idea, but it's the same as the guy who comes to "draw" up the new plans for a place. Bureaucracy allows high fees for things, just look at all the fees the government wants for things that don't make sense.
 
How can the oke charge R20k to climb into the attic with a torch?
The inspector charged my R5000.00 for the inspection, report, and certificate (which will only be issued upon having the required reinforcements done), whilst the reinforcements will cost me between R15 000 and R20 000.
So cant have the "Required" certificate without paying to have the reinforcements done. Reinforcements which i believe are not necessary.

I am pretty sure that the company that did the roof repairs would have mentioned that I will have to have the internal structure repaired or something, if there was any problems with it.
 
Getting it structurally assessed sounds reasonable to me. See if you can find someone more affordable to do it.
Have already paid the engineer the R5000.00
It is the reinforcements that are needed that i find to be unreasonable.
i am by no means an engineer, but if people weighing more than 60kg can walk and stay on the roof for long periods of time without any damage, then it should be able to easily handle 6 panels.
 
Have already paid the engineer the R5000.00
It is the reinforcements that are needed that i find to be unreasonable.
i am by no means an engineer, but if people weighing more than 60kg can walk and stay on the roof for long periods of time without any damage, then it should be able to easily handle 6 panels.
Well it is clear that you are more knowledgeable than the structural engineer. Grab the relevant SANS (10400?) code, get the information of your roof structure, truss type , truss bottom and top chord sizes, point loads, bearing on the walls. Compare it to the SANS code and show the engineer that you know more than him and that he needs to give you the certificate. I would also report him to the engineering council as he misleaded you and wanted to do you financial harm.
 
What makes you more knowledgeable than an engineer? Because someone temporary walked on your roof you are suddenly an expert?
Because numerous people (more than one) for extended periods of time (hours and hours) stood and walked on the roof.
If any of them felt, or saw any problems with the structure, they would have mentioned it.
 
Because numerous people (more than one) for extended periods of time (hours and hours) stood and walked on the roof.
If any of them felt, or saw any problems with the structure, they would have mentioned it.
it doesn't matter, you're in a complex you need to follow their rules, that they do need to provide to you. If this requires strengthening then it is needed.
 
Well it is clear that you are more knowledgeable than the structural engineer. Grab the relevant SANS (10400?) code, get the information of your roof structure, truss type , truss bottom and top chord sizes, point loads, bearing on the walls. Compare it to the SANS code and show the engineer that you know more than him and that he needs to give you the certificate. I would also report him to the engineering council as he misleaded you and wanted to do you financial harm.
Will do, thanks for some sound advice. I am off to get my measuring tape and ladder.

And how is he wanting to cause me financial harm?
 
it doesn't matter, you're in a complex you need to follow their rules, that they do need to provide to you. If this requires strengthening then it is needed.
I have requested the rules from them to confirm that they are stipulated.
If not then ill ask them why it is needed, like for insurance purpose etc.
 
I have requested the rules from them to confirm that they are stipulated.
If not then ill ask them why it is needed, like for insurance purpose etc.
That is it, you can moan as much as you want sadly, but you live there and need to follow what they want or need.
If you want it changed you'll need to bring it up with other owners.
 
What does this mean ?
When you sell a house and you've made modifications, you need an engineer to come draw up the new plans for the city to have on record.
This can be 20 to 50k.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X