Tablets vs laptops: is the PC dead?

rpm

Admin
Staff member
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
66,805
Reaction score
5,057
Location
Johannesburg
Opinion piece by Anton Vukic, Channel Director at Phoenix Distribution

When Steve Jobs launched the iPad in 2012, a new era in computer was ushered in. Even though tablet PCs have been around for years, the iPad was the first device to use the form factor successfully in the consumer market, and established the foundation for today’s proliferation of the devices.

As tablet prices have continued to decline, their capability has steadily increased, and analyst firm IDC recently revised its forecast for the number of tablets that will be sold this year up from 172.4m to 190.9m - suggesting that it thinks tablets will outsell laptops. Its long-term forecast reckons that by 2017 total tablet shipments will hit nearly 353m. That means that in just seven years from the release of Apple's iPad, the tablet will be challenging the PC as the most-sold computing device - if one discounts the smartphone, which has outsold PCs since the fourth quarter of 2010.

Gartner’s predictions mirror this, forecasting a decline of 7.6 percent in 2013 of the traditional PC market of notebooks and desk-based units. This is not a temporary trend induced by a more austere economic environment; it is a reflection of a long-term change in user behaviour, according to Gartner.

As more and more things become available 24/7, our lifestyles are also evolving. We want entertainment here and now. And with our increasingly hectic and erratic working hours, we try to squeeze the most out of our time. Tablets have provided an ideal solution to help us fit everything in, and to make us more efficient.

So the question for many people today isn't which tablet they should buy, but whether to buy a tablet or a laptop. However, while tablets are capable of many tasks that were previously only possible with a laptop or PC, this doesn’t necessarily mean laptops are obsolete.

There are still limitations to what you can do with a tablet. Entertainment aside, tablets are great tools to jot down ideas, and they allow the user to share almost anything instantly without reproducing the text, photo or picture. In terms of organisational capabilities, tablets make it easier for you to manage your life: your finances, schedules, reviews, etc. However, you still can’t beat the laptop for content creation.

The obvious difference is that all laptops have a physical keyboard. Typing long documents is easier and more comfortable on real keys, rather than tapping away at a screen for extended periods. While it's possible to buy keyboards for tablets, too, tablets can't compete with laptops on storage, either. Most laptops have hard disks with capacities around ten times larger than a tablet's memory. With a tablet, you'll have to be choosy about which photos, videos, music and documents you store locally. The rest has to be stored online, or on a PC or laptop.

Sometimes, tablets can be tripped up by small things such as drop-down boxes or other controls on web pages which are fiddly to use with a touch-sensitive display. Printing documents is easier on a laptop too, as it’s closely tied to the operating system and works with a wider range of software. Printing is still possible from a tablet, but it isn’t as easy or versatile.

Of course, few laptops can match the portability and long battery life that most tablets offer. Ultimately, laptops and tablets are complementary devices: it's not a case of one or the other. Tablets are not going to replace all other forms of computing devices. Each has its strengths and weaknesses and is suitable for different tasks. Carrying a tablet, PC and smartphone doesn't make a whole lot of sense, though, so convergence will eventually have to happen.
 
I would much rather use a tablet on the go than a laptop. Serious work only occurs on my desktop PC. So for me, tablets have killed laptops.
 
I think, given time, that tablets will become increasingly feature rich and that more content will be designed for specific use on a tablet ie. websites with touch friendly controls. Printer support and other options should improve over time. PC's and laptops are where they are because of business requirements, and as tablets start filtering into your work life you can expect to have all those features added and improved.

It's still early days for tablet computing.
 
I can't see myself typing a 300 page report on a touchscreen tablet keyboard, it doesn't have enough storage and cannot burn audio cds for my car...and the display is too small for proper Starcraft II gaming. So I'll stick with my Core i3 notebook. :p

Waiting for the Samsung Galaxy Note 3 in September to do duty as my "tablet". Guy at work reckons his tablet is gathering dust since he got himself a Galaxy Note 2.
 
I can't see myself typing a 300 page report on a touchscreen tablet keyboard, it doesn't have enough storage and cannot burn audio cds for my car...and the display is too small for proper Starcraft II gaming. So I'll stick with my Core i3 notebook. :p

Waiting for the Samsung Galaxy Note 3 in September to do duty as my "tablet". Guy at work reckons his tablet is gathering dust since he got himself a Galaxy Note 2.

Oh mate... Either your mirror is broken or your eyesight is deteriorating badly. But why would you want to watch yourself type anyway? :confused:

Seriously though, I agree. Each has it's place. For work I will also pick a laptop/notebook.
 
I've got a Tablet and I've used it like twice in the last month or so.

I use my pc for a few hours each day. I use my work pc the whole day.

If I had a laptop and my tablet next to it, I would most probably use the laptop too. I guess if my Tab could connect to the internet, which it can't at my home it would be a different story. Then I'd lie in bed and browse mybb. So that's a huge deciding factor which I haven't taken into account.

On my pc I've got music playing and the forum open in Chrome about the most times. Either that, or I'm doing some form of work. Leisure, I'm watching a movie or series etc., which is mostly on weekends though. I don't do that on the Tab ever though, even if I can, I don't.

The Tab is currently a very large alarm clock :p ;) :D
 
My notebook is burning cds, got DSTV Drifta open in the top right corner while I'm surfing and downloading stuff with Chrome....not sure how a tablet can replace that.

I hate reading with a tablet or mobile phone, prefer a real book, so really don't know what I should be using it for.

Maybe someone can find a real use for a tablet one day.
 
PCs are dinosaurs - where you still need a fixed device (e.g. kiosks, POS) nettops make far more sense. Tablets and laptops are converging rapidly - the only difference will be whether they are docked - the Tablets vs Laptop debate will be completely moot within a few years anyway.
 
PCs are dinosaurs - where you still need a fixed device (e.g. kiosks, POS) nettops make far more sense. Tablets and laptops are converging rapidly - the only difference will be whether they are docked - the Tablets vs Laptop debate will be completely moot within a few years anyway.

I beg to differ....most fun I ever had with a pc was my desktop with 24'' LED display and playing Starcraft II at 1080p. :love:

There is a place for all of them & no reason to do away with any of them.
 
Opinion piece by Anton Vukic, Channel Director at Phoenix Distribution

When Steve Jobs launched the iPad in 2012, <snip>

Fail.

B!tch, please. PC's are not dead, check my sig. I use one. My friends all use one. And you're trying to suggest it's dead? What's with these misleading titles and rhetorical questions?
 
Last edited:
Imo laptops will eventually close the gap between itself and a desktop. Right now I use my desktop not as much as my laptop and use my smartphone even more than the laptop and desktop combined.

@kingrob I agree with all of your statements that people should be able to juggle using all the various computer variants and one device compliments the other in different usage scenarios. A desktop will currently still be my preferred device for editing and conversion of video files. :p
 
I've got a Tablet and I've used it like twice in the last month or so.

I use my pc for a few hours each day. I use my work pc the whole day.

If I had a laptop and my tablet next to it, I would most probably use the laptop too. I guess if my Tab could connect to the internet, which it can't at my home it would be a different story. Then I'd lie in bed and browse mybb. So that's a huge deciding factor which I haven't taken into account.

On my pc I've got music playing and the forum open in Chrome about the most times. Either that, or I'm doing some form of work. Leisure, I'm watching a movie or series etc., which is mostly on weekends though. I don't do that on the Tab ever though, even if I can, I don't.

The Tab is currently a very large alarm clock :p ;) :D

Why don't you just get a wifi router for your house?
 
Why don't you just get a wifi router for your house?

I don't have the money and I don't pay for the internet connection (3G/hsdpa), which is a normal dongle, the work does. So I can't really use it for personal gain.
 
I beg to differ....most fun I ever had with a pc was my desktop with 24'' LED display and playing Starcraft II at 1080p. :love:

There is a place for all of them & no reason to do away with any of them.

Displays and other peripherals have nothing to do with the PC market, if that's your concern. Most people I know with laptops plug them into much better screens at home or at their workplace anyway. Ultimately, laptops and tablets will converge into one device with multiple roles depending on whether they're docked / plugged into external displays and keyboards. There are plenty of laptops now with high end gpu's for gaming.

Nobody's going to "do away with" PC's, anyway - the market will do that naturally over a long period. The gaming and hobbyist markets will ultimately not be big enough to sustain the traditional form factor PC industry.
 
Displays and other peripherals have nothing to do with the PC market, if that's your concern. Most people I know with laptops plug them into much better screens at home or at their workplace anyway. Ultimately, laptops and tablets will converge into one device with multiple roles depending on whether they're docked / plugged into external displays and keyboards. There are plenty of laptops now with high end gpu's for gaming.

Nobody's going to "do away with" PC's, anyway - the market will do that naturally over a long period. The gaming and hobbyist markets will ultimately not be big enough to sustain the traditional form factor PC industry.

I think his point was more of the strain gaming takes on hardware, and running starcraft II at 1080p isnt as easy as it sounds.
 
Last edited:
There is no chance of PCs dying off anytime soon. But sales are going into a long term decline because people are choosing to buy a new tablet rather than a new PC, and just holding onto their aging core2s on Win7 or whatever. The margins and the growth that were there are no longer there and may never recover to their former level. Even before the iPad came along, it was clear with the first iPhone that there was a serious threat to the PC, because if you can have a full browser in your pocket that's immediately challenged a large chunk of your PC usage.

But I pity the man who tries to replace his PC with an iPad.
 
PC(s) at home for doing stuff. Laptop for work and also doing stuff. Tablet for collecting dust. When I plug a decent monitor and wireless keyboard + mouse into my laptop I have a decent 'desktop' anyway. Tablet was a complete waste of money and everything it can do my current phone can do now anyway.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X