Unfortunately Telkom has other management issues as well (not just Top managent). Personal experience:
Got ADSL on 2 November - was syncing well and working well up until a week ago, when I decided to "move" it myself closer to the door (away from Kitchen - microwave - TV, plugs etc). Was having attainable = 4500 Kbps max. So cutting the cable and moving the box got met 10 000 Kbps attainable :-D . But it was dropping every 5 to 15 minutes and then taking 10 tries to dial out again.
So call Telkom to come and replace the cable from the pole to just inside the house (a 1 hour "jobbie" by a line technician). Great works for about 1 hour - 4 Mbps connected - 10 Mbps attainable. Then DEAD - syncs but cannot connect.
Next day: Same technie - 5 hours on site. His "supervisor" says no it must be my modem - we try his modem - nothing, phone guys at exchange and after 30mins of techie pleading etc (white guy at exchange very condescending with this black techie....) they divert the port or something. Works for 2 minutes (just enough to do 1 speedtest - 3.6 Mbps). Then the line dies again. Telkom laptop can dial, but drops in 5 seconds - error 743 - PPP link dropped. "supervisor / call centre" says - uninstall USB modem, replace modem cable, bla bla bla.
Keep on telling them - change my port at the exchange - I can see on Mikrotik there is NO PPPoE on the line - cannot even access
www.telkom.co.za (you should be able to do this WITHOUT and ISP account). Best "comment" of the day - no your Mweb "data" is finished - I am on Mweb UNCAPPED!!!
So. Day 3: Techie comes again (Friday). Line does not even want to sync. Finally they MOVE it on the Exchange - Yah.. working!
Syncs at 4096 (speedtest / line running constantly on 3.6 Mbps). No disconnects anymore. Attainable between 8000 and 10 000 Kbps.
Must say the following:
1) I fee for the Line / ADSL techies - both were very professional and tried their BEST to help on site
2) Call Centre for Telkom also very friendly (even when I started complaining after 4th visit to my home in 3 weeks - 2nd day in a row). They also say sorry for experiencing problems (it does count something) - and the system with updating you with SMS and email works WELL.
3) "Supervisors" and "middle" management - from MY Experience - are condescending with both clients and line technicians. I could hear over the cellphone how BOTH the white and black person on the other side was talking down the technician and also did not believe me as customer to what the problem can be (they can also see the Signal to Noise - SNR - etc on their side - so the line "should" be working).
So overall:
1) Telkom has a dept of knowledgable employees that "can" be their saving grace
2) But there are definitely lots of "dead wood" that will need to be let go
3) And unfortunately I know many Bright EX Telkom employees that left, to the detriment of Telkom's future
PS - I don't even want to give an opinion on Government and its "role" within Telkom....
PS2 - Finally typing this on a stable, working ADSL connection (touch wood)!