The obligatory PC vs. XBOX thread...

did you just say gosh darnit?

I would buy an xbox if it wasnt a complete waste of money for me. I know that its a media center and gaming console, but my pc already does that better. I understand why someone who doesn't have a proper pc would buy one, i also understand why someone with too much money would buy one. Unfortunately i don't fall in either of those cathegories.
 
Last edited:
did you just say gosh darnit?
I did indeed. I don't swear, so I try to find alternatives... :p

(plus it adds a dripping of sarcasm to the concluding sentence...)

Unfortunately i don't fall in either of those cathegories.
Well, me and many other people do. We find it more viable to buy an XBOX than upgrading our PCs. Plus, many people these days don't have desktop PCs, but rather laptops. As a PC "fanboi", you'd know that laptops aren't the most gaming-friendly machines, let alone upgradeable...
 
Last edited:
I did indeed. I don't swear, so I try to find alternatives... :p

(plus it adds a dripping of sarcasm to the concluding sentence...)


Well, me and many other people do. We find it more viable to buy an XBOX than upgrading our PCs. Plus, many people these days don't have desktop PCs, but rather laptops. As a PC "fanboi", you'd know that laptops aren't the most gaming-friendly machines, let alone upgradeable...

I need a proper pc because i render architectural walkthroughs, the fact that the requirements also makes it the best thing for gaming is not something i`m going to complain about.

The thread is whether or not PC is better for gaming and imo it is

pro's
1: Genres not available on xbox
2: Cheaper games
3: Freeware
4: Lan parties
5: MMO's
6: A catalogue dating back to 1980
7: Better hardware

cons
1: expensive if you have to have the best
2: cant sit on a couch while playing(you can if you set it up like that but most of us don't)
3: 2 player games on 1 keyboard really suck
4: the problems that come with a pc if you don't know what you are doing
 
I need a proper pc because i render architectural walkthroughs, the fact that the requirements also makes it the best thing for gaming is not something i`m going to complain about.

The thread is whether or not PC is better for gaming and imo it is

pro's
1: Genres not available on xbox (which?)
2: Cheaper games (true but can rent xbox games ;))
3: Freeware (XBLA)
4: Lan parties (ditto)
5: MMO's (just not yet)
6: A catalogue dating back to 1980 (had a bit of a headstart .. and who wants to even play those carp 80s' games :D)
7: Better hardware (given)

cons
1: expensive if you have to have the best
2: cant sit on a couch while playing(you can if you set it up like that but most of us don't)
3: 2 player games on 1 keyboard really suck
4: the problems that come with a pc if you don't know what you are doing

:D
 
I can just as easily spout arguments like "The PC can't make you bacon and eggs for breakfast!" in your direction.

sorry i'm a bit late for a reply - but the reason i said that was
MH answered that guy "as if the xbox can do everything he said" - including "surfing the web"

i wasn't "spouting BS", i was simply correcting MH.
 
Last edited:
Anyway - lets look at it this way.

PC = Any game possible
XBOX = Limited in Game Genres.
 
M_H - you cant be serious... classics are classics, sorry, but youre not right on that one. would like a 360 just for fighting games though - me loves em :) but pes is the only game i have to have so im not worried about it...
 
M_H - you cant be serious... classics are classics, sorry, but youre not right on that one. would like a 360 just for fighting games though - me loves em :) but pes is the only game i have to have so im not worried about it...

:sick: ........ I don't think there is one game pre 2000 that I would even look at in the shop, let alone buy and play again.
 
Well like i said there is no Star Craft II, Diablo 3, Crysis, WoW, S.T.A.L.K.E.R. - All AAA Games!
No DotA, No CSS = FAILS Multiplayer Scene.

frankly, If you are still playing skateboard games you are scraping the bottom of the barrel.
 
do you have 4x strategy games? don`t know thats why i`m asking...
don't mention sid meier's revolution - that stupid sorry excuse for a civ game doesnt count. grrrr :(
 
Well like i said there is no Star Craft II, Diablo 3, Crysis, WoW, S.T.A.L.K.E.R. - All AAA Games!
No DotA, No CSS = FAILS Multiplayer Scene.

frankly, If you are still playing skateboard games you are scraping the bottom of the barrel.

bru, you're lucky you mentioned Stalker, Crysis and D3 because DotA and CSS is a very lame thing to cry win over.
 
Well like i said there is no Star Craft II, Diablo 3, Crysis, WoW, S.T.A.L.K.E.R. - All AAA Games!
No DotA, No CSS = FAILS Multiplayer Scene.

frankly, If you are still playing skateboard games you are scraping the bottom of the barrel.
What's wrong? Not a fan of sports? Shame.

World of Warcraft? Keep it...I have a life.
 
Well like i said there is no Star Craft II, Diablo 3, Crysis, WoW, S.T.A.L.K.E.R. - All AAA Games!
No DotA, No CSS = FAILS Multiplayer Scene.

frankly, If you are still playing skateboard games you are scraping the bottom of the barrel.

No no no. You original post was:

Keeper said:
XBOX = Limited in Game Genres.

So, what Game Genres is the XBOX lacking in? I'm only asking - if there are more unexplored game genres, then please enlighten me.

The reason I mention Skate, was because EA did something very innovative with the controls, which would, quite frankly, be impossible on a keyboard/mouse combo. Sure, you could get hold of a gamepad and play it on a PC, but how many PC gamers actually DO have gamepads? EA knew this and decided to keep Skate a "console exclusive".

Sarcastic Farlig said:
No Forza, No PGR = FAILS Racing Scene.

Nuff said. :p
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X