Why I Actually Prefer The BMW Z4 To The 2020 Toyota Supra
There’s no denying that both the 2020 Toyota GR Supra and the 2020 BMW Z4 M40i are the same car. But they are good cars. Their origins don’t in any way detract from the driving experiences they offer.
If anything, these two are up there among the most potent performance machines available for under $100,000 (please don’t make Corvette C8 jokes).
And the great thing is, they do feel different!
The Supra is definitely aimed at a younger, more driving-oriented buyer, and it does a fantastic job fulfilling that mission. If you haven’t driven recent BMW products, walk inside a Toyota dealer and ask to test drive a Supra, you’re not going to be disappointed. It’s one hell of a sports car, and you’ll be getting a lot of performance for your dollar.
But if you know your cars, if not just a tad, you know the differences between driving a Toyota and driving a BMW. This Supra doesn’t drive, sound, or even smell like a Toyota.
So in that sense, no, the 2020 Toyota Supra doesn’t compare to its predecessor because it’s not a true Japanese effort. It’s too different in too many ways. The fourth-generation car had been developed to, yes, satisfy enthusiasts, but also to showcase Toyota’s engineering know-how against the world, most notably the German carmakers.
Now, it’s the Germans that build the damn thing.
The Z4, on the other hand, arrived in the ring quiet and humble, overshadowed by the hype the Supra had created. It ended up being the car I enjoyed driving the most, either because it offers more as a car, but also because it feels like a genuine BMW effort.
If there’s a higher-level takeaway here, it might be that there should be an unwritten rule in the automotive industry: never outsource your halo car.
Those are the automobiles that attract people into your showroom, the “hey, look what we can do” vehicle that convinces buyers to buy that RAV4 because it shares components with the sports car.
That doesn’t really apply here. As much fun as the new Supra is, its greatness isn’t something Toyota can truly claim for itself.
Toyota says the 2020 Supra feels different to drive than its mechanical twin, the 2020 BMW Z4 M40i. Actually, since the start, both carmakers have been hammering about how distinguished each car is, telling us they went off their own separate ways once the shared architecture was laid out.
jalopnik.com




