I agree with you 100% on not buying new and taking the inevitable knock on price. I disagree, however, on being a "non enthusiast" and buying a Citi.
The original Golf, and then the Citi were always aimed at enthusiasts, and I can personally have as much fun in a Citi today, as I did when I was rallying Golf Gti's "back in the day". NOTHING has changed about the dynamics of the car which remains eminently "chuckable" on the road, and capable of keeping up with many newer cars if driven by somebody who knows what he/she's doing. Something that CAN NOT be said about driving a Chana, Chery or Atoz.....
Now please allow the Citi to retire with some dignity...rather than compare it with cars that are only just keeping up with it, that were designed 30 years later.