iPhone 4 Review: All the upgrades, shortcomings and other details

It's nearly senseless to try and compare the iPhone with other Smartphones, although it will not stop this forum from engaging in exactly this!

You either buy into the "Apple Way", surrender any pretense you might have of any vestige of control, accept iTunes as your mono-theistic center of focus and actually end up having a pretty good and fulfilling life with the Apple Eco-system and its products which truly seems to "just work",

OR

you fiercely defend your democratic right to choose your own destiny and products, even if it means you spend an inordinate amount of time trying to actually get them to work (and to work together) while those darn Apple fanboyz have an actual social life outside of geekdom.

And that is the real choice. It's not about batteries and camera pixels or whatever. Technically, these phones are very much on par.

It's all about accepting a specific lifestyle. You either accept technology as an appliance and just use it, just like you use a TV or a microwave, or you see it as a lifestyle of tinkering with stuff.

As a hardcore techno-geek, I'm clearly in the latter camp (as is Mr. Vermeulen, it seems), but there's no denying the pity the followers of the Gospel according to Steve feels towards us is valid at some level.
 
you could jailbreak it and boot droid. its like *nix on a macbook. love the hardware. hate the software, or rather, as jannie said, hate the strings attached to their software.
 
Last edited:
Have to say, from someone who considers Android superior on a personal level, this review was very fair and spot on.

I happen to love the iPhone, but I hate Apple fanboys (or Android fanboys for that matter). It's as Jannie said, a personal (lifestyle) choice.

It's the same with PC's really. I'm in philosophy a Linux fan, but as I don't have the time or inclination to tinker with my PC software hardware these days, I run Windows as my primary OS (although Ubuntu is getting closer with every release).
 
Haha @above, pretty much nothing comes in the pack - not even a fully fledged instruction manual.

Just earphones, charger, micro sim too (little metal thing), and the actual phone. oh and a quick start guide.
 
I used to love the Iphone now i hate that thing more than Steve jobs and his mob, personally i prefer My new found love The Samsung Galaxy S over the Iphone 4, reasons Being the Iphone is too damn controlled.
As a developer this piece of crap still can't even run flash, not even ideal for tedering.
 
you fiercely defend your democratic right to choose your own destiny and products, even if it means you spend an inordinate amount of time trying to actually get them to work (and to work together) while those darn Apple fanboyz have an actual social life outside of geekdom.

Lets see...

Other smart phones: Put in sim card, turn on, enjoy.
iPhone: Put in cim card, find a pc, download and install itunes, sign up for itune, update iphone, sync phone to itunes, enjoy.

From here, it actually looks easier for non-apple phones.
 
Tittle is misleading, this was not a review.

Headline is spot on. Why didn't the writer go into details about the shortcomings.
TIA, if your going to call this a thorough review of a device.
nice review.
crikey, those are big downloads. surely itunes comes in pack?
How often do you get updates on iOS devices, it's not like its every week

As a developer this piece of crap still can't even run flash, not even ideal for tedering.
I think your over-exaggerating there about being a developer, because serious developers are making a lot of money out there, and they are sure that their applications will run perfectly across all iOS devices. Peolpe are still complaining about the lag of flash?

Is this what African Technology Reviews have come up to be?
A typical review from PhoneArena involves
  1. Introduction
  2. Design
  3. Interface
  4. Messaging
  5. Connectivity
  6. Camera
  7. Multimedia
  8. Software
  9. Performance
  10. Conclusion

By all accounts this was a terrible review, there is zero mention of battery life, some of the features that Steve tried to sell at the iPhone Launch, like FaceTime and HDR photography were not reviewed. Did I mention that there is no single original pictures of the iPhone for this review, since the author was talking about other phones, it would have been nice to have side by side photo of them together in 1 frame. Sample HD videos from Galaxy S & iPhone 4, sample pictures, a video would have been nice.

What was more disappointing is that the author talked about a proprietary USB connector that is used by Apple. The cable comes with the phone, you don't have to go out and buy it, secondly there are more iPhone accessories than any other phone, proprietary or not, different manufactures are still making accessories for the bashed phone.

Here is a conclusion from Phone Arena about iPhone4, this is an objective conclusions. The least myBB could have done is to match this level of standard.
Another year, another iPhone right? It's only natural to see an abundance of consumers get giddy knowing that Apple is launching their latest iPhone every summer – from what we've been experiencing so far. The iPhone 4 received the biggest makeover to date with its packed internal hardware, updated looks, and premium materials. Tallying in at a mere 0.37” in thickness makes it one of the slimmest smartphones ever crafted (probably the slimmest) – and it truly embodies the essence that Apple naturally radiates in the design of their products. We definitely adore how it manages to combine a nostalgic and modern approach to its design which is only supplemented with the finest of materials to make it stand out among the crop. Pretty much everything under the hood received a major overhaul – we especially love the detailed Retina Display.

Software wise, iOS 4 has refreshed the handset and continues to showcase Apple's stance in offering an intuitive platform that can easily be adopted by a broad range of customers. Simple and straightforward is the game when it comes to navigating across the platform as anyone will have an easy time with its short learning curve. However, it still has a lot to go in truly embodying the aura of perfection. Personalization is still lax, even after Apple's fourth iPhone, but they've only begun to break the mold – so hopefully things down the pipeline may address its shortcomings.

The Apple iPhone 4 is not the perfect phone. It suffers from certain problems with its signal reception (at least some units do), call quality is not excellent, photos taken with the 5MP camera are pretty good, but we've seen better, FaceTime is only available via Wi-Fi for the moment, multitasking is yet to be utilized by developers... We can always find a bunch of drawbacks to exploit. However, over the years we've come to believe that it is fairly easy to point out the exact disadvantages of the iPhone. And, in a way, we believe this is because everything else found under the hood works like a dream. From dialing a contact, through web browsing, to playing a 3D game - there's hardly a phone on the market that does all that in an easier and more seamless way.

It all comes down to personal preference. The Apple iPhone 4 has a display of better quality, but smaller size, when compared, for example, to the HTC EVO 4G, Motorola DROID X or Samsung Galaxy S – some of the best Android phones out there. The iPhone 4 lacks the 4G connectivity (which, as a matter of fact, you might never get), but its App Store sports about 4 times more apps, with each being about 5 times better in value. Its iOS 4.0 does not feature active homescreen widgets to show you what the weather is like on the outside, like Android does, but it would never freeze, crash or lag. As we said, it's all a matter of personal taste.

So our advice is... simply decide for yourself what you want from your smartphone, and how you want it.
 
Last edited:
I think your over-exaggerating there about being a developer, because serious developers are making a lot of money out there, and they are sure that their applications will run perfectly across all iOS devices.

Well, that's if you can find something to make. The apple store is over saturated with developers and it's coming to a point of diminishing returns. It's hard to catch up to those veteran ios devs, and there are a very few new ideas (that would make money) that haven't been explored. Even then, single devs are being replaced with teams of devs. The ios is changing quickly to a point where it's no longer a quick buck for devs, but an investment platform for small companies.

The time if devs making a lot of money from ios is coming to an end (sadly).
 
I expected to read about battery life, sound quality, dimensions and weight... are these not part of an "in-depth" review?
 
I expected to read about battery life, sound quality, dimensions and weight... are these not part of an "in-depth" review?

Go to GSMArena for that.

I personally liked this review - it's a good read for an average user, any user, wanting to make the change or not.

As mentioned above, I too feel this was a good overall review even though Jan is biased towards Android, the sentiment was not over-bearing in the review and it was factual and easy to read.
Job well done IMO.
 
my next upgrade will probably be the iPhone 4 this December. I'm ready to give it a shot.
 
I guess my feelings echo very much what Jannie said.

I don't agree with locking customers in, but hell, almost everything I could ever want to do, theres an app for that. I've JB'd my 3gs for a few extra functions : 5 icon dock, 5icon springboard and SBSettings. Thats all. The rest is stock standard istore apps.

The overall user experience on an iPhone is what blows any other phone/os out of the water.

Some points about other operating systems
1) Android might be great and wonderful, but it is too fragmented. developing for android is a huge pain in the ass. you need to write different code for almost every model phone.
2) So what if the iPhone doesn't run flash? The phones that do run flash fall over and break all the time. There isn't one platform (hardware + software) that runs flash without draining the battery and being slow/jerky/crashing. There are hundreds of thousands of iPhone apps that do everything you can imagine, and not one of them use flash.
3) The iPhone hardware specs aren't amazing. There are other phones that beat it in the specs department hands down. Can you name one of them off the top of your head? Probably not - Because they haven't made the impact that the iPhone has

love it or hate it, iPhone is here for the foreseeable future.

We keep hearing about the next iPhone killer, but I have yet to see one
 
Got an Android phone, it is quite average. No where near as responsive and functional as the iphone. Going to be moving back to iPhone in a month or so.

All your problems are not a problem for me. My android can't be updated unless I root thing and it is quite a mission. I rather just download 600 megs (in about 20 mins) and have a fully updated phone.
 
The one explanation I find lacking, is the one on Multitasking. People often say it is lacking, but do not clarify why? I have the 3gs and the Galaxy S, and while I fully understand that the Galaxy is offering “true” multitasking, the performance and battery life are degraded when too many apps are open. For the end user, the average Joe, I do not see any difference though in Features. The iPhone works fine, and switches between apps, and completes tasks in the background and so on.

What I want is an honest review telling me how the Multitasking on the iPhone is not complete for the average everyday man on the street. Preferably not a review written by a Fanboy or a hater, but an unbiased individual.
 
If you wanna read a proper review of the iphone 4 i would suggest Anandtech.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X