Apple Mac virus free claims raise consumer ire

Yep, unfortunately Apple can no longer use that particular claim.
 
what a douche

If I advertise "The tastiest pancakes in South Africa" at my hypothetical pancake stand, who is to say they aren't, and that I should remove it because someone else doesn't agree?

Apple's Products are practically virus free, and it is something I would list on the pro/con sheet between a mac and a PC.



(not that I like mac's, they suck)
 
must've been a ms fanboi haha

Just because he pointed out a case of false advertising makes him a fanboi?

what a douche

Why all the hate? The man did the right thing IMO. Let's not forget the vast difference in tech knowledge between the average MyBB forumite and the average SA computer buyer. Almost all of them would fall for a claim like that, they rely on advertising to decide what to buy instead of specifications/reviews/forums etc. They can't protect themselves from marketing hype as well as the average MyBBer.

Think about it, lots of people by phones because they have "Facebook", "Google", "Mxit" etc. listed as features. Potential iSheep are highly susceptible to marketing BS. Less marketing BS ==> Less iSheep, which can only be a good thing.

If I advertise "The tastiest pancakes in South Africa" at my hypothetical pancake stand, who is to say they aren't, and that I should remove it because someone else doesn't agree?

I could say your pancakes are schit, but Billy could say that they rock, both opinions are equally valid. What tastes nice is subjective, whether or not viruses exist for an operating system is not subjective, either they do or they don't. Viruses exist for Mac OSX, therefore it is not virus free.

Apple's Products are practically virus free, and it is something I would list on the pro/con sheet between a mac and a PC.

Practically virus free != virus free though, and it should be made clear. BTW don't you mean Mac and Windows? A Mac is a PC, and so is my computer that's running Ubuntu. Another example of Apple marketing BS, they convince people that Macs aren't PCs.

(not that I like mac's, they suck)

Damn right.
 
Last edited:
Just because he pointed out a case of false advertising makes him a fanboi?



Why all the hate? The man did the right thing IMO. Let's not forget the vast difference in tech knowledge between the average MyBB forumite and the average SA computer buyer. Almost all of them would fall for a claim like that, they rely on advertising to decide what to buy instead of specifications/reviews/forums etc. They can't protect themselves from marketing hype as well as the average MyBBer.

Think about it, lots of people by phones because they have "Facebook", "Google", "Mxit" etc. listed as features. Potential iSheep are highly susceptible to marketing BS. Less marketing BS ==> Less iSheep, which can only be a good thing.



I could say your pancakes are schit, but Billy could say that they rock, both opinions are equally valid. What tastes nice is subjective, whether or not viruses exist for an operating system is not subjective, either they do or they don't. Viruses exist for Mac OSX, therefore it is not virus free.



Practically virus free != virus free though, and it should be made clear. BTW don't you mean Mac and Windows? A Mac is a PC, and so is my computer that's running Ubuntu. Another example of Apple marketing BS, they convince people that Macs aren't PCs.



Damn right.

ABSOLUTELY!!!

You said it all right there!
 
Practically virus free != virus free though, and it should be made clear.


Well I run a windows, which has like 20 000 new viruses each day.
I run no anti virus and have not been affected by a virus in the last 5-8 years or something

If I had run a Mac, which has 0.1 new viruses each day, there would be a VERY SLIM chance of one affecting me.
Sure, even if they have 1 virus you can't TECHNICALLY call it virus free, because there IS one....but, really now....it IS virus free in 99% of cases for mac users.




Everything is relative you know.... just because mweb might be down for 2 minutes a day doesn't mean it's NOT uncapped "always online internet"....just because it says "eat as much as you want" at the buffet does it mean you can take them to court because you are not allowed to stay after 12pm when they wanna close shop

if it's 99.9% true I say advertise it, otherwise nobody will be able to advertise anything due to 0.001% technicalities.

to be frank, IMHO I think anyone should be able to state anything they want on their adverts, as they are paying for it.
- If I want to state my product is virus free, then I should damn well be able to, even if there is a slight 0.01% chance of getting one and it's not "technically" virus free.
- If I want to say my chicken take away rocks and Nando's sucks, then I should damn well be allowed. free speech and all. (I seriously don't get why one company can't TRULY talk bad about another)
 
Well I run a windows, which has like 20 000 new viruses each day.
I run no anti virus and have not been affected by a virus in the last 5-8 years or something

How do you know you haven't been affected if you don't have an anti virus? Most viruses these days are subtle, collecting information about the user or adding the users' computer to a botnet, hardly anyone writes "ZOMG it's formating my hard drive" computer killers anymore. Modern viruses are hardly noticeable.

If I had run a Mac, which has 0.1 new viruses each day, there would be a VERY SLIM chance of one affecting me.
Sure, even if they have 1 virus you can't TECHNICALLY call it virus free, because there IS one....but, really now....it IS virus free in 99% of cases for mac users.

You don't see Ubuntu touting itself as a virus free OS do you? Even though 99.99999% of Linux installations aren't affected by viruses. False advertising is false advertising period. Find another selling point.

Everything is relative you know.... just because mweb might be down for 2 minutes a day doesn't mean it's NOT uncapped "always online internet"....just because it says "eat as much as you want" at the buffet does it mean you can take them to court because you are not allowed to stay after 12pm when they wanna close shop

No not everything is relative. Some things are just true or false. A person either has two eyes or they don't, my head is either turned to the left or it isn't.

Businesses usually have disclaimers or terms and conditions about things like that. At the restaurant obviously I can eat all I can as long as they are open. As for Mweb there are several threads on MyBB of the view that Mweb is infact NOT uncapped.

if it's 99.9% true I say advertise it, otherwise nobody will be able to advertise anything due to 0.001% technicalities.

Just because my head is turned to the left 99.9% of the time does not mean that it is now, or that I can start selling tickets to the "head turned to the left guy" exibit. Advertising OSX as virus free is a blatant lie. "Less viruses than Windows", maybe or "Hardly any infections" but certainly not "Virus free". This is setting yourself up for disaster when the 1 in 10 000 Mac user does get a virus, it fscks with his businesses computer network because he's cool and his company only uses Macs, loses millions and sues. All because he trusted that his OS was virus free because the ad said so.

to be frank, IMHO I think anyone should be able to state anything they want on their adverts, as they are paying for it.

I'm selling an old beetle that'll do 1503 Km/h only R60 000. Hey it's my ad, I'm paying for it. Can you imagine the BS we'd have to deal with if people could do that.

If I want to state my product is virus free, then I should damn well be able to, even if there is a slight 0.01% chance of getting one and it's not "technically" virus free.

Why do you reduce inconvenient facts to technicalities? Facts are facts, no matter how insignificant. OSX isn't "technically" virus free, it isn't, period. There is a 0.000001% (thumb suck) chance that you'll get a flesh eating virus that'll eat your face, it doesn't mean that humanity is flesh eating virus free.

If I want to say my chicken take away rocks and Nando's sucks, then I should damn well be allowed. free speech and all. (I seriously don't get why one company can't TRULY talk bad about another)

Because then they'd spent every waking moment disproving their competitors claims. There would be lying and backstabbing all the time. Ethical business FTW.
 
Last edited:
Only reason why there are so many viruses on PC's is because we do not pay for our goodies....LOL
We install pirate copies
Mac users are rich so they pay for legal copies hahahaha

I'd rather have the odd virus and get all my stuff for free...
i must say i like the challenge of removing the buggers!
 
Only reason why there are so many viruses on PC's is because we do not pay for our goodies....LOL
We install pirate copies
Mac users are rich so they pay for legal copies hahahaha

I'd rather have the odd virus and get all my stuff for free...
i must say i like the challenge of removing the buggers!

Just to clear this up, by free you mean stealing. Rather pay for my hardware and my OS, Apple only charge 1/10 what microsoft are charging for their OS, its crazy.
 
Only reason why there are so many viruses on PC's is because we do not pay for our goodies....LOL
We install pirate copies
Mac users are rich so they pay for legal copies hahahaha

I'd rather have the odd virus and get all my stuff for free...
i must say i like the challenge of removing the buggers!

1,520 posts? All of this calibre? <shudder>

Linux is free and *generally* doesn't have viruses.

However, as you probably know, Clamav runs on Linux, doesn't it? So, using ASA logic, if there is antivirus software for Linux, obviously there must be viruses for Linux.
 
Just to be the devil's advocate. Core did say that their Macs are Virus Free and not Immune to Viruses. The first IS true, the latter can never be.
 
Did this guy actually know what a "VIRUS" is?

You're going to argue about technical jargon in an advertising claim? Good luck with that.

Evaluation of advertisments is based on the perceptions and beliefs of the general public, for whom 'virus' = 'malware'.
 
Ooh, ooh, ooh... An Apple thread with a negative slant that DIDN'T bring out the Windows/Linux fanboys.... Not this thread mind you, but one day there will be one just like that on MyBB.
I'm with Keeper here... what a douche. I'm prepared to bet the "consumer" doesn't even have a Mac but, like so many posters on MyBB, has an irrational hatred for what, in effect, is just another tech brand. Yes, there are viruses for Mac... Most of them affect users who dual boot (run Windows) on their machines and it's the Windows partitions that are affected. Mac OS has had it's share of malware but it requires a password to install anything on your HD so unless you're just installing random stuff you really, really have nothing to worry about and even then, the problem is more "downstream" ie. the Mac user, who won't really be affected, might pass the virus on to a Windows user by mail... I'm Googling it now to ref here but I remember reading somewhere that there are something like 26 out of 70 000 know viruses that affect Macs... That's 0,0003% of the viruses out there people.
I'm sure this number will grow as more Macs are sold but, unless I am mistaken, Mac OS applications don't share a common registry and use individual preference files so global configuration changes, you know, like those that enable Windows malware, simply aren't as feasible on a Mac.
Back to the ASA complaint 'tho... Semantics, semantics... Yes there is malware out there that affects Macs but how 'bout getting a poll going... All the Mac users on MyBB that have been affected by viruses or malware. You Windows boys would cry when you see the results. Also, I live in the real world, not Ricky Gervais' The Invention of Lying one... Every advertiser embellishes a little. I'm far too busy and my life is too full to worry about every advertising statement that is only 99,99% accurate, let alone bring it to the ASA. Takes a special kind of hatred for anything Apple to do that... Just saying.
 
What OSX virus is he referring to?

On June 23, Russian police arrested Pavel Vrublevsky, the co-founder of Russian online payment giant ChronoPay and a major player in the fake AV market.
http://www.macrumors.com/2011/08/04/raid-on-russian-firm-may-have-taken-down-macdefender-malware/

However, as you probably know, Clamav runs on Linux, doesn't it? So, using ASA logic, if there is antivirus software for Linux, obviously there must be viruses for Linux.
ClamAV is used to snoop out windows viruses on linux for windows sharing.
 
Last edited:
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X