Carte Blanche on Eskom

Noting really new being exposed by Carte Blanche with the exception of concrete numbers on the exports.

Eskom and government have been contradicting themselves and each other the last 2 weeks when asked about exports so it was obvious that they had stopped nothing and were continuing the supply to our neighbors despite our industry being crippled by power cuts.
Realistically speaking though, is it even a viable option to stop supply?
Botswana gets I think 75% of their power from SA, if we shut them off completely we would only compound the crisis for the region as a whole. Tough decisions indeed.

As for the coal issue, the numbers quoted were for transporting coal, not the coal price as such iirc.
The main point it seems is that the power stations are producing less electricity than they did last year, or the year before that. There is no excuse for this other than bad management.

The transportation of coal was outsourced to a number of BEE contractors, some with little or no experience of this type of operation. The one was an interior designer or something.
Add the bad state of roads to and from the power stations taking their toll on the reliability of the trucks and their maintainance costs, the amount Eskom was paying these contractors did not amount to a number that was even remotely possible for a business to continue.

Coal stock piles at the power plants are apparently at an all time low, in the past being enough on site for 30-45 days. We have some of the cheapest coal in the world and plenty of it, but we, for some or other reason, are incapable of getting this coal to the power stations.

The rain has always been around and the coal has always been exposed to the elements the experts say so this is no excuse.
Eskom, when pressed by D Watts would not provide any information on coal availability at the power stations. I wonder why ;)

When will Eskom and the government stop lying to the public though, thats what I want to know.


Another aspect that was not looked at was the location on Majuba power station.... It was built next to a coal seam.... and only to find out after the power station was built that there WAS NO COAL at the location.

10+ years ago when I was working on the project there were rumours that the land Majuba stands currently was 'organised' and the surveyor was paid for a 'favourable' report.

I was a lowly contractor then and had no-way to substantiate the claims.
:D
 
It is incredible that half a million South Africans stand to lose their jobs but we are still exporting power. Still wondering when people will be getting fired because of this.
Yep, they've just renewed a 5 year contract with BPC (Botswana) starting from 5th Jan 2008.

They also supply Nampower (Namibia). When asked how much SA supplies, they answered "there is no fixed figure".
 
Yep, they've just renewed a 5 year contract with BPC (Botswana) starting from 5th Jan 2008.

They also supply Nampower (Namibia). When asked how much SA supplies, they answered "there is no fixed figure".

Meaning: Increasing all the time
 
meaning - we supply to them what they need. if they need more than what we have spare, we loadshed. We're the good guy on the block.
Jeepers! Cant APLA or AZANIA, BWB or COSATU, or some _other_ abbreviation DO something to them pylons exporting the life blood of our own economy?
 
This is the power export distribution diagram (from Eskom's intranet).
showphoto.php
 
Skeptic - all we need is the full video clip now! ;-) *hint hint*
/me got ftp space .....
 
Last edited:
I'm sure Harmony's CEO will be phoning Eskom's CEO tomorrow, after finding out that Eskom ordered our mines to shut down, while happily supplying electricity to our neighbors, and say : U owe us R120 million for the two days so far...u want to pay cash or with credit card? LOL
 
Derek Watts didn't pick up when the guy said (he has lied in other interviews) that contractually to most neighbouring countries electricity is not exported when capacity is not available . That means some countries/contracts perhaps Moz's aluminium smelter could have contracts stating that Eskom must supply electricity at all time or they get financially penalized. Hence they aren't loadshed like us. Someone must get the exact details and get this liar to eat his words.

Despite SA being a so-called net importer and reselling that imported electricity to neighbouring countries it's surely unconstitutional to loadshed electricity to South Africans but at the same time provide electricity to neighbouring countries/projects because their contracts aren't best effort like electricity supply is to South Africans.

Who cares about the contracts at this stage, pay the penalties and get out of them. Pathetic.

When Steve is being cornered about the huge bonuses, he says "One has to look at awards that Eskom has received" What f****n Awards? What a shocking statement!

Maybe they print themselves awards on the office printer? :D I don't fscking know anymore tbh, the arrogance is almost more scary than anything else, they just don't care.


See for yourself dude. I can post more if you want a closer look ..:D:D
Here are some stills from Carte Blanche.

This is Eskom's Tutuka Power Station coal storage facility.
http://mybroadband.co.za/photos/data/500/tutuka.JPG

and Majuba
http://mybroadband.co.za/photos/data/500/majuba.JPG

[from a similar thread]

Absolutely shocking, can't believe its gotten this bad this quickly.

Yep, they've just renewed a 5 year contract with BPC (Botswana) starting from 5th Jan 2008.

They also supply Nampower (Namibia). When asked how much SA supplies, they answered "there is no fixed figure".

So they get what they need while we get loadshedded. :rolleyes:
 
When Steve is being cornered about the huge bonuses, he says "One has to look at awards that Eskom has received" What f****n Awards? What a shocking statement!

They did win a number of awards a long time ago, and you know what, it rained back then as well.
They excelled in things like "mean time between trips", "no unplanned load loss or reduction",.......

The rain story is just another load of BS.
 
It is incredible that half a million South Africans stand to lose their jobs but we are still exporting power. Still wondering when people will be getting fired because of this.

People will be fired soon.
Mostly mine workers and factory workers - who's companies will need to downsize.

/joke - mostly
 
If you think about it, it all boils down to money. How to squeeze every cent out of everyone (SA and neighbours included) and how to stockpile as much of it as they can. What I want to know is WTF happened to all that profit made in 2006, why we're being squeezed for a 14% (or whatever) increase in electricity costs and why should we pay that when it seems they're more interested in supplying our neighbours than ensuring SA has enough to keep the economy growing. Seems they don't care about the billions the economy is losing daily, so long as their pockets are lined and the bank vault is full.
 
It is incredible that half a million South Africans stand to lose their jobs but we are still exporting power. Still wondering when people will be getting fired because of this.

this is Africa dude, nobody will get fired, it seems in Africa the person who gets the most TV coverage becomes popular in government ie. Jacob Zuma, Moonto Manto.
Who knows if he keeps it up maybe Jacob Maroga could be our next president.
 
just had a bit of a thought. if they keep this up to line their pockets at the expense of the economy, and we head the direction of zim where everything shuts down, then the currency will become worthless so their wealth will mean sweet blow all anyway so they only shafting themselves as far as i can see.
 
just had a bit of a thought. if they keep this up to line their pockets at the expense of the economy, and we head the direction of zim where everything shuts down, then the currency will become worthless so their wealth will mean sweet blow all anyway so they only shafting themselves as far as i can see.


Go check out how madbob and cronies are making millions on the blackmarket vs. official Z$ exchange rate.
 
just had a bit of a thought. if they keep this up to line their pockets at the expense of the economy, and we head the direction of zim where everything shuts down, then the currency will become worthless so their wealth will mean sweet blow all anyway so they only shafting themselves as far as i can see.

as mcsack said - that is when the REALLY make money.
 
I have the clip on dvd from my hdd recorder. Anyone in Stellenbosch can come and fetch it and convert to avi. I don't know how and don't have time.
 
Derek: "Your CEO said on Monday that you are no longer exporting to our neighbours. But now you say that you have been all along?"

Steve: "I am saying that Eskom is a net importer of electricity."

Derek: "That is not my question. The question is: are you supplying because your CEO says that you are not? I think Solidarity is right that you keep on giving different answers."

Steve: "Well, that is not right if you contextualise what our CEO actually said and actually listen to what he said. He spoke very specifically about the fact that we are not exporting to our neighbouring states when we are unable to meet the demands of electricity in South Africa."

Derek: "He didn't qualify it. He just said that we are no longer exporting."

Steve: "I think that is subject to interpretation."


FFS. "interpretation"....
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X