Mike Hoxbig
Honorary Master
Tahir's had a better day. A new batsman at the crease creates more pressure than the same batsman seeing off 1 bowler at 3 RPO.It is not always wickets that win games, so if tahir takes 2 wickets but goes for 4 runs and botha takes no wickets and goes for 3 runs an over who had the better day?
Was it botha keeping it so tight that risks needed to taken on other bowlers than contributed to their demise? Can tahir knock 20 off 15? So many variables but botha can bowl well, field well, batting is decent until tahir shows me something similar i would pick botha plus i don't want to turn into an england type setup relying on people from other countries winning us games.
As for 20 off 15, Botha can do it, but he doesn't do it consistently. More often than not, it's likely to be 11 off 14 balls, and then out.