Wait, you compared it to a GTi5 ?
I'm not the one that needs to get 20 questions
1. Looks of a car is in the eye of the beholder. G5 in my opinion is crap ugly.
2. Pure V8 Power, NA, and the sound of those cars makes you feel like you are driving a real Power horse (Because you are)
3. Back wheel drive, nothing comes close to having 428 bhp on the rear wheels
4. It's a looker, people will stop and stair at your car for hours (I highly doubt you will get the same from your G5 unless you add some Durban spice to it.)
It's all about class. Some cars have it, some makes their owners believe that they have it. I dare you to go take a ride in a classic muscle car, you will never ever look at any other car the same. The power of the car you can feel in the steering wheel, no driving aid, just you and the engine.
Seriously, you VW drivers know nothing about cars