Official Super Rugby 2016 Thread

Penalty's are given for transgressions all the time for hands and feet accidently in the wrong place.

Yet with a penalty try it seems a yellow card must go with it (or some disciplinary action), even if the try was prevented by a transgression done by accident.

That is just wrong in my book.

Would it have been a try without boot hitting ball: Most likely - award the try.
On Purpose deserving yellow card: Absolutely not - by the look of it anyway.
 
Last edited:
Don't see why there needs to be intent for it to be a foul or not. For me its foul whether intentionally or not. I was perfectly happy with the decision made on saturday.
 
Hougaard commits to Worcester

Springbok scrumhalf Francois Hougaard has become the latest player to leave the country after agreeing to a long-term deal with Worcester Warriors.

The 27-year old utility back was given permission by Saru to join the Warriors on an eight-week stint, but has made such an impression on the club that they have agreed to a long term deal.

Hougaard will still head back to South Africa to fulfill his contractual obligations with the Springbok Sevens team, but after the Rio Olympics in August will head back to Worcester again to resume playing for the club.

He becomes the latest player in the growing exodus out of South Africa due to the massive amounts paid by overseas clubs for local stars here.

In the last 24 hours it has been confirmed that the Lions' flyhalf Marnitz Boshoff has signed for Irish club Connacht while Stormers prop Vincent Koch is said to be heading to Saracens for the next European season.

Last month both Marcel Coetzee - who signed for Ulster - and Marcel van der Merwe - who is heading to Toulon - became the latest high-profile Springboks to commit to European clubs as well.
 
Don't see why there needs to be intent for it to be a foul or not. For me its foul whether intentionally or not. I was perfectly happy with the decision made on saturday.

Because if there is intent then a yellow card could be justified.
If it was by accident then just a penalty for hands/feet in wrong place at wrong time is all that is needed.

Penalty try should have been enough as far as I'm concerned.
But it would seem the law requires more than that when it comes to a try which is wrong.
 
The Sunwolves are marketing it hard...

CdpWG8tW8AEqsST.jpg

They are really hoping to win the Rebels which are the most unpredictable team in Super Rugby. Yamada being the new Japanese golden boy, since Goromaru has teamed up with the Reds benchwarmers, noting that Yamada will soon be called up into the Japanese sevens squad to be replaced by Lolohea. They will still only have 2 wingers in the squad…

Hammett is probably still pissed over his team losing to the Cheetahs, he is very silent in the media.
 
I hope the sunwolves can win this game at home. Think it will be great for exposure in Japan as well.
 
http://www.superxv.com/sunwolves-make-three-changes-rebels/

Japanese Super Rugby franchise the Sunwolves have named a side with three changes for this weekend’s match against the Rebels in Tokyo.

In the back line Mifiposeti Paea replaces Yasutaka Sasakura in the starting line with the latter dropping to the bench.

Yoshiya Hosoda comes in to wear the No.6 jersey replacing Liaki Moli who drops out of the 23.

Takuma Asahara comes into the second row and his place on the bench from last week is taken up by Shinnosuke Kakinaga.

Viliami Lolohea is still absent in the starting line-up. They did replace their lightning quick centre with Paea which is a strong Tongan player well known in the Top League with a good history. I would had played Paea against the Lions… I have never seen Paea play rugby, but he is born in Japan and brought up through their schooling system so he might be a good ball mover as opposed to being stingy (and undisciplined).

In my opinion, the above move may give more cohesion between the centre pairs and Pisi. Sasakuru is a great player in my opinion, but they need to move him to the wing leaving their squad with at least three active wingers than only centres.

Hosoda comes in on 6, a Japanese Player, so Fanie will be happy to see one less ‘Australasian’ in the team.

I also see that Hammett is testing his props, since they really lack depth there in the scrummage and mauls which in my opinion was the reason they had succumbed to the Cheetahs. Hammett being a hooker I think that he is punishing these guys through the week to get it right this time around against the Rebels.

Now the replacements being made is mainly due to medical reasons.

Interesting to note that Horie and Inagaki played at the Rebels so they might read into the scrums. The Rebels also have their captain, Stirzaker, and regular loosie, Fuglistaller, back in the starting line-up.

Big game in Japan.
 
Argh, more bad reffing ...... how do you avert thine eyes for such a bad offside :wtf:
 
Eish I thought I was way off my margin pick, now right in the money...
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X