PS3 and Xbox questions

goofball

Expert Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2007
Messages
1,574
Reaction score
0
Hey guys and girls.

I am buying either a PS3 or a xbox this week and need some info on the PS3 as I dont really know much about it.

Xbox live was great but you pay for that which is less than ideal.

How does PSN compare? Is it fast enough for locals? Would a 384k line work well on PSN? Do you play mostly with local gamers? Is it easy to find a MP game to join?

EDIT: Is the PS3 wifi the same or better than the xbox built in wifi?

Any info would be appreciated.
 
Last edited:
I got a PS3 about a month ago. From someone who was a hardcore PC gamer, it was definitely one of the best decisions I've ever made.
 
In had a similar thread on here a couple of months ago. I'll spare you the long discussions and give you the summary:

1. Buy what your friends have because you'll be playing online with them
2. If above not applicable, by the one that you can play your favourite game on. (to me that was GT5 so I bought the PS3 and I love it).

As far as connectivity is concerned: can't really help because I've only ever owned a PS3. It doubles as a VERY good media center.
 
My PS3's wifi is decent, but streaming some videos from my PC is a bit problematic.
 
Hey guys and girls.

I am buying either a PS3 or a xbox this week and need some info on the PS3 as I dont really know much about it.

Xbox live was great but you pay for that which is less than ideal.

How does PSN compare? Is it fast enough for locals? Would a 384k line work well on PSN? Do you play mostly with local gamers? Is it easy to find a MP game to join?

EDIT: Is the PS3 wifi the same or better than the xbox built in wifi?

Any info would be appreciated.

What games do you enjoy?

I've just finished both Uncharteds and they are amazing games. Everyone should play them. Tomorrow I'll be pre-ordering Uncharted 3.
 
Hey guys and girls.

I am buying either a PS3 or a xbox this week and need some info on the PS3 as I dont really know much about it.

Xbox live was great but you pay for that which is less than ideal.

How does PSN compare? Is it fast enough for locals? Would a 384k line work well on PSN? Do you play mostly with local gamers? Is it easy to find a MP game to join?

EDIT: Is the PS3 wifi the same or better than the xbox built in wifi?

Any info would be appreciated.

If your primary concern is online gaming and you do not already have a whole bunch of friends on psn i would recommend the xbox, you get what you pay for and live is a far better service than psn. If you need a good gaming machine and a media solution ps3 will do the job, either way you should have both or else you will be missing out on some awesome games :D. Also if there is a whole backlog of multiplats you want to catch up on they are almost always gonna be better on xbox... this is only starting to come right now, ps3 exclusives are awesome though, everyone should own the system even if its just for the uncharted series.
 
Last edited:
My PS3's wifi is decent, but streaming some videos from my PC is a bit problematic.

How far is your router from the ps3? i used to have issues as well but i found a nice central spot in my house and made sure my ps3 was not near a wall... result = 100% signal strength. Usually stream my hd episodes to my bedroom with no problems.
 
I own both consoles and spend 99% of my time on the Xbox.

Get the Xbox.
 
Same here. I own both consoles. If u play online alot buy an Xbox. Otherwise invest in a ps3. It's more then just a gaming machine. Its amazing as a media centre as well.
 
How is the new Xbox Live South Africa? Not talking about what is available on it. Just speed wise.
Is it faster than the PSN?
 
source: http://www.whichbetter.net/comparison/xbox-360-vs-ps3-which-is-better/

Xbox 360 vs PS 3 – 2011 Update :

I’ve decided to make this update, as one of the guys who posted a comment, had a clean and good review, thanks “The Third Party” your comment was absolutely great :

“Graphics PS3 > XBOX 360

The PS3 has a Blu-Ray player not found in the XBOX 360, thus PS3 games are released on Blu-Ray disc, and being that Blu-Ray is the most modern form of compact disc (CD), you dont even need personal opinion to decide the better console. Though through my own personal experience, the PS3 is better.

Online PS3 > XBOX 360

The speed online between XBOX 360 and PS3 is relatively unnoticeable, and when it does come for free, ‘relatively unnoticeable is very good. However, if you want the absolute best and are not concerned about price, the XBOX might be a better choice. Unfortunately, due to the XBOX’s low price, it has a large majority of players on its servers who are rabble (low skill, loud mouth, low intelligence, and usually around 12, you can even guess this would be the case in the XBOX 360′s childish looking menu and avatars)

Controller PS3 > XBOX 360

I am 6’2, my hand is about 7-8 inches long from wrist to the end of my middle finger, so when I hold an XBOX controller, I have a hard time finding space for my support fingers (fingers not used to press buttons or triggers) while the PS3′s controllers is wider, and the bridge (area containing the Start, Select, and Home buttons) is dramatically thinner and more compact. This allows you to place your fingers in a variety of ways and positions, a crucial element for anyone who has adult sized hands and is going to play for several hours. Also, it’s lighter, the battery pack is internal and totally hidden, while the XBOX controller is about 1.5-2 times the weight, is so clunky it barely has handles, and has a very large external battery pack sitting right where I’d like to rest my fingers. The XBOX controller is modeled almost exactly after the PS controller, in that it has the same amount of buttons, in the same exact places (excluding the directional pad which trades places with the left analog stick) further proof PS controllers are better is that the original XBOX had only ‘bumpers’ and no triggers, the triggers that would be found on PS controllers were replaced by ‘Black’ and ‘White’ buttons found on the face of the controller, but these buttons were then replaced with triggers taken from the PS controllers design when the console moved into the Seventh Generation along with the PS3 and Wii. The last bit of reasoning, some players like to play using an alternative hand position, such as myself. On my right right hand, I use my middle finger to operate the triggers, while my index finger can rest on the Square/X button for smoother operation of the controller. This is easily accomplished with PS controllers due to its thin wide shape that has served as the base of controller design since the realease of Playstation One, though it is practically impossible on an XBOX controller due to its ‘fat’ and narrow design.

Games Library PS3 < XBOX

The XBOX takes the cake easily on this one, even diehard PS3 fans should be able to see this. Very few games are PS3 Exclusive, and they’re usually not very popular. However, a multitude of games can only be found on the XBOX 360, and a huge pool have expansion packs or add-ons that can only be found on the XBOX 360, such as Oblivion. While the Shivering Isles and Knights of the Nine can be found on PS3, Horse Armour, Mehrunes Razor and several other tasty add-ons are simply not available on PS3. For a Game Lover this spells disaster, and many people will switch (and have switched) to XBOX 360 in the pursuit of more in-game content. Another example are Halo, Gears of War, and Fable, which are only found on XBOX 360. The PS3 does have its own exclusives, but they cant pull it up to be worthy of beating te XBOX 360′s game library.

Community Size PS3 XBOX 360

The PS3 is a better All-Round choice for most people. A simple evidence is that the Playstation 2 was released in 2000, while the XBOX was released in 2001. Normally, this would mean the PS2 would become obsolete sooner, but it didnt. In any GameStop or EB Games you will find PS3 games, XBOX 360 games, Wii games, GameCube games, and PS2 games. Of Nintendo, Sony, and Microsoft, Microsoft is the only company with a single console being represented. Of the three, Microsoft is the only company with no portable games (such as the PSP or Gameboy). And of the three, Sony is the only company with TWO consoles still active with new releases and decent sized communities (the PS2 is not yet considered obsolete by game providers and is the ONLY Sixth Generation Console with an active community and new release games).
However, it’s not that simple. Everyone is different, you have people who fancy Simple Structuring, which the XBOX provides, and people who appreciate a Complex System, such as the PS3, some people are more oriented towards offline and RPG games, which the XBOX delivers well, and some are more oriented toward competitive online and FPS (First Person Shooter) which is where the PS3 can deliver a more satisfying product. The bottom line is, no one syste is king, which is why they’ve been struggling for power for the last decade. I would personally recommend buying both if you can afford it, they are both excellent consoles and each have their Pros and Cons. I own both and like them both alot, and as ong as there are PS3 fans, XBOX will make better games, as long as there are XBOX fans, PS3 will make better games. Competition is the Mainstay inside video games, and its what makes Video Games great, and new, and different. So if you want to play Fable but love Playstation, buy an XBOX as well, because thats going to drive PS3 to greater heights in an effort to compete, and vice-versa. You want good video games in the future? Buy the games you want no matter the system, or you can pledge DieHard devotion, and pray for the competitions downfall, but you’ll only be destroying the market.”


edit: xbox has wireless N vs ps3 which has wireless b/g. however ps3 does have gigabit lan which is an advantage for wired connections.
 
Last edited:
How is the new Xbox Live South Africa? Not talking about what is available on it. Just speed wise.
Is it faster than the PSN?
Well XBL is a billion times faster when PSN is down :p

In all honesty, I have an xbox, I pretty much only play online and its awesome, I have no issue paying.
But I think the best advice here is from Hamster, buy the console your friends have!!
 
source: http://www.whichbetter.net/comparison/xbox-360-vs-ps3-which-is-better/

Xbox 360 vs PS 3 – 2011 Update :

I’ve decided to make this update, as one of the guys who posted a comment, had a clean and good review, thanks “The Third Party” your comment was absolutely great :

“Graphics PS3 > XBOX 360

The PS3 has a Blu-Ray player not found in the XBOX 360, thus PS3 games are released on Blu-Ray disc, and being that Blu-Ray is the most modern form of compact disc (CD), you dont even need personal opinion to decide the better console. Though through my own personal experience, the PS3 is better.

Online PS3 > XBOX 360

The speed online between XBOX 360 and PS3 is relatively unnoticeable, and when it does come for free, ‘relatively unnoticeable is very good. However, if you want the absolute best and are not concerned about price, the XBOX might be a better choice. Unfortunately, due to the XBOX’s low price, it has a large majority of players on its servers who are rabble (low skill, loud mouth, low intelligence, and usually around 12, you can even guess this would be the case in the XBOX 360′s childish looking menu and avatars)

Controller PS3 > XBOX 360

I am 6’2, my hand is about 7-8 inches long from wrist to the end of my middle finger, so when I hold an XBOX controller, I have a hard time finding space for my support fingers (fingers not used to press buttons or triggers) while the PS3′s controllers is wider, and the bridge (area containing the Start, Select, and Home buttons) is dramatically thinner and more compact. This allows you to place your fingers in a variety of ways and positions, a crucial element for anyone who has adult sized hands and is going to play for several hours. Also, it’s lighter, the battery pack is internal and totally hidden, while the XBOX controller is about 1.5-2 times the weight, is so clunky it barely has handles, and has a very large external battery pack sitting right where I’d like to rest my fingers. The XBOX controller is modeled almost exactly after the PS controller, in that it has the same amount of buttons, in the same exact places (excluding the directional pad which trades places with the left analog stick) further proof PS controllers are better is that the original XBOX had only ‘bumpers’ and no triggers, the triggers that would be found on PS controllers were replaced by ‘Black’ and ‘White’ buttons found on the face of the controller, but these buttons were then replaced with triggers taken from the PS controllers design when the console moved into the Seventh Generation along with the PS3 and Wii. The last bit of reasoning, some players like to play using an alternative hand position, such as myself. On my right right hand, I use my middle finger to operate the triggers, while my index finger can rest on the Square/X button for smoother operation of the controller. This is easily accomplished with PS controllers due to its thin wide shape that has served as the base of controller design since the realease of Playstation One, though it is practically impossible on an XBOX controller due to its ‘fat’ and narrow design.

Games Library PS3 < XBOX

The XBOX takes the cake easily on this one, even diehard PS3 fans should be able to see this. Very few games are PS3 Exclusive, and they’re usually not very popular. However, a multitude of games can only be found on the XBOX 360, and a huge pool have expansion packs or add-ons that can only be found on the XBOX 360, such as Oblivion. While the Shivering Isles and Knights of the Nine can be found on PS3, Horse Armour, Mehrunes Razor and several other tasty add-ons are simply not available on PS3. For a Game Lover this spells disaster, and many people will switch (and have switched) to XBOX 360 in the pursuit of more in-game content. Another example are Halo, Gears of War, and Fable, which are only found on XBOX 360. The PS3 does have its own exclusives, but they cant pull it up to be worthy of beating te XBOX 360′s game library.

Community Size PS3 XBOX 360

The PS3 is a better All-Round choice for most people. A simple evidence is that the Playstation 2 was released in 2000, while the XBOX was released in 2001. Normally, this would mean the PS2 would become obsolete sooner, but it didnt. In any GameStop or EB Games you will find PS3 games, XBOX 360 games, Wii games, GameCube games, and PS2 games. Of Nintendo, Sony, and Microsoft, Microsoft is the only company with a single console being represented. Of the three, Microsoft is the only company with no portable games (such as the PSP or Gameboy). And of the three, Sony is the only company with TWO consoles still active with new releases and decent sized communities (the PS2 is not yet considered obsolete by game providers and is the ONLY Sixth Generation Console with an active community and new release games).
However, it’s not that simple. Everyone is different, you have people who fancy Simple Structuring, which the XBOX provides, and people who appreciate a Complex System, such as the PS3, some people are more oriented towards offline and RPG games, which the XBOX delivers well, and some are more oriented toward competitive online and FPS (First Person Shooter) which is where the PS3 can deliver a more satisfying product. The bottom line is, no one syste is king, which is why they’ve been struggling for power for the last decade. I would personally recommend buying both if you can afford it, they are both excellent consoles and each have their Pros and Cons. I own both and like them both alot, and as ong as there are PS3 fans, XBOX will make better games, as long as there are XBOX fans, PS3 will make better games. Competition is the Mainstay inside video games, and its what makes Video Games great, and new, and different. So if you want to play Fable but love Playstation, buy an XBOX as well, because thats going to drive PS3 to greater heights in an effort to compete, and vice-versa. You want good video games in the future? Buy the games you want no matter the system, or you can pledge DieHard devotion, and pray for the competitions downfall, but you’ll only be destroying the market.”


edit: xbox has wireless N vs ps3 which has wireless b/g. however ps3 does have gigabit lan which is an advantage for wired connections.

lol

Ps3 AAA Exclusives :

Uncharted
Resistance
Killzone
God of War
Infamous
Rachet and Clank
Team Ico Games
Gran Turismo
Heavy Rain
Demon Souls
MGS4

Xbox AAA Exclusives :

Halo
Forza
Gears of war
Fable
 
I can't agree with auriga1000 on the controller. I too have large hands and find the XBOX 360 controller a lot more comfortable. But all this proves really is that like most things it is a matter of personal taste.

I have all three of the current generation consoles and rate them as 360>PS3>WII based solely on the amount of time I spend on each.
 
How far is your router from the ps3? i used to have issues as well but i found a nice central spot in my house and made sure my ps3 was not near a wall... result = 100% signal strength. Usually stream my hd episodes to my bedroom with no problems.

My router and PS3 is devided by a wall. I will check if I can move it around.
 
I've got very big hands, the Xbox controller is fine with me. Also Blu Ray has nothing to do with graphics. In fact, the slower seek times mean a lot of games on PS3 have mandatory installs, and still load slower than on the Xbox. Check out comparisons between the Xbox and PS3 - Xbox games almost always look better and load faster.

If you like racing games, get an Xbox. Forza 4 is better than GT5. Sorry, it just is.
 
How is the new Xbox Live South Africa? Not talking about what is available on it. Just speed wise.
Is it faster than the PSN?

Its much better than psn, miles better in fact both in functionality and performance. For example in international lobbies in COD i always get a yellow connection, this is very playable. On psn half the time i would be on an unplayable red bar for the same game if i wanted to play with internationals. Even games with dedicated servers on ps3 dont perform as well as their xbox counterparts in my experience. If online is your concern you will get the xbox.
 
Last edited:
I had ps3 and xbox.
Ps3 was much better imo




Sent from my GT-I9000 using Tapatalk
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X