Smart light switches

[BadBoyGP]

Pulled neutrals to all my funny switches.


I counted 10 of them. Although 2 switches in flatlet and one should just be blanked/switched off.

So really 7.

Now to see if Jerry Smart switches fit.

PS electricians assistants managed to disconnect neutrals to ALL switches in my bedroom. But he'll come fix it tomorrow morning.

Luckily rest of house unaffected and only light switches, not the power plugs in main bedroom!

Why didn't you use sonoff?

 

[Sensorei]

Any update? How did it go?

I've been using a Sonoff inching switch for my garage and driveway motor for a few years now. Very easy to install. Only the the driveway gate motor one died after about 2.5 years. The garage one is still going strong. I use Alexa to open/close them. Very convenient.

 

[Saba'a]

Why didn't you use sonoff?

I prefer the Tuya Smart Life switches as I am in the ecosystem for smart automations.

Shellys were my preference and I may still go that route as I prefer licensed/certified switches.

Will try out the 4 switches for now. The funny switches look terrible and a mish mash of styles.

 

[BadBoyGP]

I prefer the Tuya Smart Life switches as I am in the ecosystem for smart automations.

Shellys were my preference and I may still go that route as I prefer licensed/certified switches.

Will try out the 4 switches for now. The funny switches look terrible and a mish mash of styles.

Ewelink with HA?

 

[Saba'a]

Ewelink with HA?

HA too complex for me.

I'll check it out eventually once Rpi prices improved.


Downloaded the software to create a VM on an old notebook. Just haven't gotten around to it.

BUT Sonoff would not be my choice. Rather Shelly as Sonoffs not certified for SA.

I try to stick to certified where possible. Problem is for toilet I have a Tuya motion detector so then automation would not work UNLESS I use HA, if I use Shelly.

So for now, Jerry Smart switches.

 

[Heisenborg]

HA too complex for me.

I'll check it out eventually once Rpi prices improved.


Downloaded the software to create a VM on an old notebook. Just haven't gotten around to it.

BUT Sonoff would not be my choice. Rather Shelly as Sonoffs not certified for SA.

I try to stick to certified where possible. Problem is for toilet I have a Tuya motion detector so then automation would not work UNLESS I use HA, if I use Shelly.

So for now, Jerry Smart switches.

Honest question. Why are you so obsessed with certified devices.

The mechanical crap i took out to replace with TreatLife definitely dont strike me as anything which was certified in any way.

Put in what you want

 

[Dolby]

Honest question. Why are you so obsessed with certified devices

Peace of mind, I guess

You're connecting devices direct to your mains and good to know that if something fails or burns, you'd be covered by insurance

 

[Saba'a]

Honest question. Why are you so obsessed with certified devices.

The mechanical crap i took out to replace with TreatLife definitely dont strike me as anything which was certified in any way.

Put in what you want

Insurance. So the Treatlife 3 way switch because only 3 way switch (edit 3 way smart switch) I could find.

Funny switches. Once HA up I can use Shellys but for now only option is the Jerry Smart switches. No Tuya options that I can find equivalent to Sonoffs or Shellys.

That would be my preference. Tuya devices I could insert into these old switches.

Once HA up - but doubt anytime soon, I'll then opt for Shellys.

Edit:

Thinking about it. I think I'll go for the Shellys and simply replace the door motion sensor with a Shelly.

Requested cancellation of order. Hope it can be cancelled

 

[Saba'a]

@Dolby

Which Shellys would you recommend for light switches?

I don't need power monitoring and they need to fit into a small space. Neutrals present.

@Tinuva

I remember advised on how to use/connect one (or was it a sonoff) for 3 way switches with neutral.

@Enzo Matrix thanks for reminding about importance of certified devices. Thought of shiny consistent looking switches made me forget about/ignore insurance risk issue.

Dimensions of replacement switch that I had wanted to fit in:

1.08 inches = 2,743 centimetres depth
4.13 inches = 10,49 cm height length
1.42 inches = 3,607 centimetres width

3.80 inches = 9,652 centimetres between holes

 

[Saba'a]

Shelly 1 - Shelly SA

Shelly 1 The smallest, smartest and most powerful Wi-Fi relay switch that provides the best home automation solution that can […]

shellysa.co.za

Seems like Shelly 1 fine for the job?

 

[Tinuva]

Shelly 1 - Shelly SA

Shelly 1 The smallest, smartest and most powerful Wi-Fi relay switch that provides the best home automation solution that can […]

shellysa.co.za

Seems like Shelly 1 fine for the job?

Try to have a select few dimmers.

For us, lounge plus 2 bed rooms have dimmers as a must. It is nice in kitchen since it is open plan. Braai room also have for the projector. Rest of house is normal light switches.

 

[Saba'a]

Controlling Smart Lights Using Dumb Switches with Shelly and Home Assistant

As I progressively make my house smarter and smarter [https://www.troyhunt.com/iot-unravelled-part-1-its-a-mess-but-then-theres-home-assistant/] , I find I keep butting against the intersection of where smart stuff meets dumb stuff. Take light globes, for example, the simplest circuit you can...

www.troyhunt.com

Pondering using the shelly switches with current Qualitel smart life/Tuya bulbs.

 

[Saba'a]

Shellys are:
1. Certified for SA use
2. Local control without tasmotizing or any flashing or soldering.

Surely thus better option?

 

[Dolby]

Shelly 1 - Shelly SA

Shelly 1 The smallest, smartest and most powerful Wi-Fi relay switch that provides the best home automation solution that can […]

shellysa.co.za

Seems like Shelly 1 fine for the job?

Shelly 1 is perfect for a single relay .

I really enjoy using my old switch and having a tactile button though, and the fact that I can use any switch I want

 

[Saba'a]

Anybody know where I can get switch covers for below:

Car remote for size comparison.

 

[Saba'a]

Looking for the cover.

 

[Saba'a]

Option overseas maybe. Will pop in by Voltex

Narrow Wall Switch Plate Options - Solutions for Tight Spots

Find narrow wall switch plate options for an electrical box in tight spot near tiles, trim, cabinets. Buy 400+ cover sizes - Kyle Switch Plates.

www.kyleswitchplates.com

 

[Saba'a]

Thanks - got 2 local options

Edit

CRABTREE CLASSIC 6540/101 COVER PLATE | LITE-GLO

CRABTREE CLASSIC 6540/101 COVER PLATE at your No.1 Electrical Suppliers - Best Prices and Fast, Reliable Delivery. Shop Online and Save Now!

www.liteglo.co.za

CRABTREE CLASSIC 1 LEVER ARCHITRAVE COVERPLATE STEEL

Classic Coverplate PRODUCT FEATURES Steel TECHNICAL SPECS Colour: White Height: 30mm Width: 25mm

dynamicdistributors.co.za

 

[Saba'a]

Anybody able to recommend fastest motion detector? To link to light.

Preferably Smartlife Tuya one. I have a Connex but too long a lag/delay for me.

 

[Heisenborg]

Anybody able to recommend fastest motion detector? To link to light.

Preferably Smartlife Tuya one. I have a Connex but too long a lag/delay for me.

Ive only tried 2 diff ones. Both had around 3s delay. Tuya stuff

WIFI Control Smart Life Tuya Wireless PIR Motion Sensor

WIFI Control Smart Life Tuya Wireless PIR Motion Sensor | bobshop.co.za

Buy WIFI Control Smart Life Tuya Wireless PIR Motion Sensor for R249.00

www.bidorbuy.co.za

Smart PIR Motion Sensor | Indoor, standalone and Small | Tuya Smart Home

This Smart PIR Motion Sensor will notify you if there is any movement happening inside your home while you are at work or on vacation.

tuya-smarthome.co.za