@Roxi
Am I right in say, its not just physical, but also things like confidence and game that you look for?
I mean, lets say a guy was drop dead gorgeous, but he was shy and insecure, would you go for him?
Its difficult to say, it depends on the situation. In some cases confidence can be a real turn-on, but in the case you just mentioned it could be that I don't care about that, because then I know he doesn't care about the way he looks, so he may be a sincere guy.