The PC Build Thread

animehero

Expert Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2015
Messages
1,965
Seems that way, like this dual RGB fan Hyper 212 is only R629:

That looks like a good option for me, max fan speed is only 1600rpm so should be pretty quiet but I can't find the TDP spec anywhere even on the Coolmaster website. Without that how do you workout if a cooler will be sufficient, is there other metrics for working that out, like the CFM?

When I get home later I'll check what's all in the box and get back to you. Perhaps you could use that and I'll post a different PIF on carb if you are interested.
 

Barbarian Conan

Executive Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2017
Messages
5,075
All else being the same what differentiates a fan like yours at around R500 to the Noctura ones that go for around R1500?

Noctua has a reputation for being very quiet, and as such provides better cooling at the same noise level than most others.
It's relatively easy to provide great cooling, the trick comes in when you want to do it without a lot of noise.

Edit: it is of course also about name, and as always the law of diminishing returns. 3 x higher price almost never equals even double the performance.
 

Lupus

Honorary Master
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
50,976
Seems that way, like this dual RGB fan Hyper 212 is only R629:

That looks like a good option for me, max fan speed is only 1600rpm so should be pretty quiet but I can't find the TDP spec anywhere even on the Coolmaster website. Without that how do you workout if a cooler will be sufficient, is there other metrics for working that out, like the CFM?
Oooh nice, if I'd seen that :)
But here is a snippet of testing my CPU to 100%, the fan curve is set that at 50 degrees it ramps to 69% and from there slowly up to 100% at 65 degrees, but it stopped at 56 degrees and fan speed was at 80ish%

1639216205916.png

I remember reading for the hyper 212 it was also roughly 150w tdp. Though also be wary I know Takealot is advertising the "ARGB" Hyper 212 but it's not actually ARGB, also I do prefer the clips for the fans on the Coolermaster, the others are primitive and mine has already shifted slightly off.

Now at idle
1639216444040.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yuu

airborne

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
18,069

When I get home later I'll check what's all in the box and get back to you. Perhaps you could use that and I'll post a different PIF on carb if you are interested.
That might work but how would I install it without a backplate or does it have the AM4 backplate?
 

airborne

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
18,069
I torture tested the 3950x just now and it will hold all 16 cores at 4.2mhz under 100% Cpu load for 15mins before temps start getting a little toasty and it gets throttled to 3500mhz. The liquid cooler keeps it at around 50 degrees for 10mins before it starts to climb to 80 and then down to 60 once its throttled and then the cpu mhz climb again, it seems to go in a loop like that.

I was hoping getting the coolant nice and hot may help with the noise which is apparently an air bubble stuck somewhere but it doesn't appear to have done anything thus far.
 

airborne

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
18,069
I just worked out why my liquid cooler may be inherently noisy, the pump is in the radiator not the CPU block like most are, so that's why most of the noise is coming from the radiator which had me stumped. If only I had know that when I was tearing my hair out trying to fix it thinking the pump was in the CPU block like all the troubleshooting videos mention. Fk it!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yuu

j4ck455

Executive Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2006
Messages
7,502
I just worked out why my liquid cooler may be inherently noisy, the pump is in the radiator not the CPU block like most are, so that's why most of the noise is coming from the radiator which had me stumped. If only I had know that when I was tearing my hair out trying to fix it thinking the pump was in the CPU block like all the troubleshooting videos mention. Fk it!
What make and model liquid cooler is that?

Maybe this will help:
 

airborne

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
18,069
What make and model liquid cooler is that?

Maybe this will help:
I watched that, its an Antec Neptune 240, the pump is definitely in the radiator, all those video's carry on as if liquid coolers only have the pump on the cpu block and hence go on and on about the cpu block needing to be below the highest point of the radiator.

Fortunately I found an Amazon review that mentioned it was in the radiator and lo and behold the power cable on mine goes into the radiator, finally that explains why the radiator is so noisy and the cpu block near dead quiet.
 

j4ck455

Executive Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2006
Messages
7,502
I watched that, its an Antec Neptune 240, the pump is definitely in the radiator, all those video's carry on as if liquid coolers only have the pump on the cpu block and hence go on and on about the cpu block needing to be below the highest point of the radiator.

Fortunately I found an Amazon review that mentioned it was in the radiator and lo and behold the power cable on mine goes into the radiator, finally that explains why the radiator is so noisy and the cpu block near dead quiet.
That is unusual, Googled it:
it does state (and show) the pump attached to the radiator (some blurb about reducing vibration on the CPU block).
 

airborne

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
18,069
Really pathetic, I would return it and ask for my money back ;):p
Apparently the 5900X, I think it is, can boost all cores to 4.5ghz but I think overall the 3950x just beats it.

If I recall correctly the 3950x is the 49th most powerful production cpu ever made, that's including server chips, the 64 core brutes.

The 5900X or 3950X can be bought 2hnd for R8k, is it normal to be able to get high end server grade cpus that cheap?
 
Last edited:

_kabal_

Executive Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2005
Messages
5,923
I torture tested the 3950x just now and it will hold all 16 cores at 4.2mhz under 100% Cpu load for 15mins before temps start getting a little toasty and it gets throttled to 3500mhz. The liquid cooler keeps it at around 50 degrees for 10mins before it starts to climb to 80 and then down to 60 once its throttled and then the cpu mhz climb again, it seems to go in a loop like that.

I was hoping getting the coolant nice and hot may help with the noise which is apparently an air bubble stuck somewhere but it doesn't appear to have done anything thus far.
How did you execute and measure this?

Could do the same to my 5900x with 240mm fractal design AIO, in the name of science :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yuu

airborne

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
18,069
How did you execute and measure this?

Could do the same to my 5900x with 240mm fractal design AIO, in the name of science :D
Yes please give it a spin, I used Prime95 run on all cores and selected "Use hyperthreading", you can get it here:

Did you run an aircooler before you went water cooled?
How noisy is your AIO?

I checked now, the 5900X is exactly one position behind the 3950X in multicore, in single core it smashes it:

Now that I think about it the 5900X is better due to the higher clock speeds that will help with everyday computing, the extra 4 cores of the 3950X won't come into play too often for the majority of people. But that being said the difference between a 5900X vs 3950X even in day to day stuff will probably be marginal, import 100 RAW files, save 5sec.. Boosted 4.2 vs 4.5 all cores and 4.7 vs 4.8 single core
 

_kabal_

Executive Member
Joined
Oct 24, 2005
Messages
5,923
Yes please give it a spin, I used Prime95 run on all cores and selected "Use hyperthreading", you can get it here:

Did you run an aircooler before you went water cooled?
How noisy is your AIO?

I checked now, the 5900X is exactly one position behind the 3950X in multicore, in single core it smashes it:

Now that I think about it the 5900X is better due to the higher clock speeds that will help with everyday computing, the extra 4 cores of the 3950X won't come into play too often for the majority of people. But that being said the difference between a 5900X vs 3950X even in day to day stuff will probably be marginal, import 100 RAW files, save 5sec.. Boosted 4.2 vs 4.5 all cores and 4.7 vs 4.8 single core
Let me give it a bash. What did you use for temp monitoring/history, or is this part of prime95?

As far as before, no I bought a new system and specced it with the AIO from the start. It’s very quite though. I would say the “loudest” part of the system, during my normal day is the PSU - Super Flower 750W gold.
 

Lupus

Honorary Master
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
50,976
Let me give it a bash. What did you use for temp monitoring/history, or is this part of prime95?

As far as before, no I bought a new system and specced it with the AIO from the start. It’s very quite though. I would say the “loudest” part of the system, during my normal day is the PSU - Super Flower 750W gold.
You can download hwinfo to monitor temps.
 

airborne

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
18,069
Let me give it a bash. What did you use for temp monitoring/history, or is this part of prime95?

As far as before, no I bought a new system and specced it with the AIO from the start. It’s very quite though. I would say the “loudest” part of the system, during my normal day is the PSU - Super Flower 750W gold.
I used the msi mbb's temp monitoring app.
You can download hwinfo to monitor temps.
That would probably be a better idea.
 

airborne

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 13, 2007
Messages
18,069
What thermal paste is recommended?
Is the fancy stuff worth the premium or is the R50 Coolmaster stuff sufficient?
 

Lupus

Honorary Master
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
50,976
What thermal paste is recommended?
Is the fancy stuff worth the premium or is the R50 Coolmaster stuff sufficient?
I guess it depends, I got the R50 coolermaster stuff. Not sure if paying more would've made a difference.
 

Gtx Gaming

Gtx Gaming
Joined
Aug 25, 2008
Messages
25,509
These work for me, and it's decent amount of paste for R65
3b097673f7fba9979e867e86bc4f222d.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yuu
Top