TopTV makes porn channel application

Why do they need permission from ICASA - porn is not illegal ?

Do they have to get permission for televangelists as well ?
 
Pretty sure they'll say no... wonder if that will be the end of TopTV? I unsubscribed recently, the content/channels were just not worth it! DSTV has a strangehold on the competition that won't easily be broken!
 
Still split minded on this matter... while the 'protection' measures they are proposing (separate subscription, PIN protection on the channels) address my previous concerns. But I still think I'll cancel my subscription if this comes in... this is just a case of it being the last straw... R249 for access to the baby channel is already hard enough to justify to myself every month.
 
Cue the sanctimonious Christian Crusaders to come tell us all how to live. Round 2. Reason vs Religion. Christians, dont forget to used the time honoured lame pseudo-excuse of, "SAVE THE CHILDREN!".

Im glad TopTV are taking up this battle. Its our Larry Flint case. I am a TopTV subscriber, and while I dont use it for.... the baby channel. I do watch MSNBC a lot. Love TopTV.
 
Last edited:
Its as simple as you watch what you want to watch. Just because the channels are available does not mean it has to be watched. if you only have SABC and E. I am sure that if something is on that you do not want to watch you simply change the channel. so if its part of the package and it offends you dont watch. They should be granted their application, im sure there is a portion of their clients that will appreciate the additional channels of fun.
 
Cue the sanctimonious Christian Crusaders to come tell us all how to live. Round 2. Reason vs Religion. Christians, dont forget to used the time honoured lame pseudo-excuse of, "SAVE THE CHILDREN!".

Im glad TopTV are taking up this battle. Its our Larry Flint case. I am a TopTV subscriber, and while I dont use it for.... the baby channel. I do watch MSNBC a lot. Love TopTV.

Strangle... 8 replies to this thread, and no has brought up religion or parenting... Everyone so far is talking about they personal preference/option and the value they get from TopTV... Yet you deemed it necessary to bring up the topics... Its almost as if you're trying to troll.
 
Last edited:
Strangle... 8 replies to this thread, and no has brought up religion or parenting... Everyone so far is talking about they personal preference and the value they get from TopTV... Yet you deemed it necessary to bring up the topics... Its almost as if you're trying to troll.

Dude, dont be intentionally naive. It was a full on Christian crusade that ran the last protests. Under the guise of "Save the children". I saw the Facebook groups in the last protests, I got the emails. This is where the protests stem from, to say otherwise is a bald faced lie. Or have you already forgotten the Christian threats to boycott TopTV?
Its almost as if you are trying to hide the reality of what really happened.

You are are all uppity about this as per your previous post. Are you religious? :)

(*Disclaimer : my comments are not aimed at all Christians. Just the stuck up prudes trying to tell the rest of us how to live our lives. Most Christians are more reasonable than this lot)
 
Last edited:
Dude, dont be intentionally naive. It was a full on Christian crusade that ran the last protests. Under the guise of "Save the children". I saw the Facebook groups in the last protests, I got the emails. This is where the protests stem from, to say otherwise is a bald faced lie. Or have you already forgotten the Christian threats to boycott TopTV?

Its almost as if you are trying to hide the reality of what really happened.

You are are all uppity about this as per your previous post. Bet you are religious. 1+1=2

So your preemptively bashing all the people that are yet to comment and do not share your view. Try to at less 'act' mature... BTW I said I do see value in continuing my subscription... that is MY preference. I did not preach to you what your preference should be... do what ever the hell you want... just stay off my grass!!!
 
So your preemptively bashing all the people that are yet to comment and do not share your view.
No, Im giving out my opinion which you dont like. So in an Oscar worthy performance you are playing the poor bashed upon matyr.


Try to at less 'act' mature...
:wtf:

BTW I said I do see value in continuing my subscription... that is MY preference. I did not preach to you what your preference should be... do what ever the hell you want... just stay off my grass!!!
I dont give a **** if you continue your subscription. I dont think the science channels and political shows would be of any value you to you anyways. If you do leave then I would recommend DSTV for the sports. No one is telling you to subscribe or not subscribe. Another Oscar worth performance from you.
 
Last edited:
No, Im giving out my opinion which you dont like. So in an Oscar worthy performance you are playing the poor bashed upon matyr.



:wtf:


I dont give a **** if you continue your subscription. I dont think the science channels and political shows would be of any value you to you anyways. If you do leave then I would recommend DSTV for the sports. No one is telling you to subscribe or not subscribe. Another Oscar worth performance from you.

Strange a person that does not want to be preached to by 'religious' people and being told what he should be able to watch... yet himself preaches what someone else should watch.... I'm sure there's a word for that...
 
Strange a person that does not want to be preached to by 'religious' people and being told what he should be able to watch... yet himself preaches what someone else should watch.... I'm sure there's a word for that...
No. I said nothing about been preached to. You are welcome to an opinion just like I am (this is why you dont see me calling for an end to brainwashing Christian channels). There is a word for people who misrepresent someone elses position. Liars or something like that...
 
No. I said nothing about been preached to. You are welcome to an opinion just like I am (this is why you dont see me calling for an end to brainwashing Christian channels). There is a word for people who misrepresent someone elses position. Liars or something like that...

I'll be honest with you... I am looking to follow a intellectual thread on the matter (like the go ol day's when the internet was populated by intellectuals) I gave my option... which was with out judgement on anyone else, and then for some reason you made a comment on the religion and parenting. The two topics that usually degrade all threads relating to TopTV and the porn channels and at the some time for some reason you make reference to my initial comment, why?
 
I'll be honest with you... I am looking to follow a intellectual thread on the matter (like the go ol day's when the internet was populated by intellectuals) I gave my option... which was with out judgement on anyone else, and then for some reason you made a comment on the religion and parenting.
Ive been online since 92 :) These days everyone is online :D


The two topics that usually degrade all threads relating to TopTV and the porn channels and at the some time for some reason you make reference to my initial comment, why?

I thought your initial post was hilarious. It reminded me of little kid who says that because he is not getting his own way, he is going to quit and take his toys with him.
 
ICASA press statement about TopTV porn channels

The Independent Communications Authority of South Africa hereby notifies all interested stakeholders about Top TV’s application for three additional video channels that seek to carry adult content. This application was lodged in terms of the regulations governing Subscription Broadcasting Services in South Africa.

The Council of ICASA has taken a decision to subject the application to public consultation; thereby inviting interested stakeholders to lodge written submissions in relation to the application. The Authority has since been receiving submissions pursuant to the publication of the application in the government gazette on 19 December 2012.

1. However, The Authority has noted that the received written submissions do not follow the process as outlined in the published government gazette. The required process for submissions to the Top TV application is as follows: All written submissions, responses and other correspondences must be directed to Ms Ndondo Dube by email on [email protected] or by fax on (011) 566 3200 or hand-delivered to the Authority’s Head Office in Sandton
2. Persons who lodge the representations or make submissions, shall at the same time of lodgement, furnish proof to the satisfaction of the Authority that a copy of the same representation has been sent to the CEO of Top TV Mr KE Mbalo by email on [email protected] or by fax on (011) 582 8308 or hand delivered at 28 Saddle Drive, Woodmead Office Park, Woodmead, 2191 or registered post to Private Bag X019, Rivonia 2128.
3. TopTV is entitled to respond in writing to written representations made by interested parties on the application; and such responses are to be lodged with the Authority within a particular time period. TopTV is also required to furnish a copy of the same response to the relevant person that has made such written representation.

Interested parties have until 21 January 2013 to make written submissions in relation to TopTV’s application; subsequent to which the Authority will determine how to proceed with the application.
 
Hmmmm... where's my popcon...


Ah... here we... you 2 may continue... :D
 
If they can lock it out by means of a PIN code or some other authentication I don't see how it can be blocked at a legal level.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X