Friendly Debate: Is modern gaming really that good?

DarkWater

Expert Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2005
Messages
2,768
Reaction score
146
Let's forget about all the Wii/Natal/Motion tech stuff for a minute as the thread is focused more on standard controller titles.

Here's my little debate. I'm been gaming since NES/DOS days and yeah, gaming has come a far way since then. The past couple of months I've been playing Fallout 3, Grand Theft Auto 4, Fable 2, etc. Basically all the A grade titles on the market that interests me. The games were fun so I was satisfied ...or so I thought.

A few days ago I discovered a site where you can download Xbox games demos. Since I'm on 3G at home I never had the luxury of doing so on Xbox Live and since this site is HTTP based I could download some at work which is upcapped. Yeah, I played the Red Faction demo, the RE4 demo and some others but the shock came in when I started playing Castle Crashers, Sonic 3, Gunstar Heroes and some other HD titles such as Omega 5.

Now for those who aren't familiar with these titles they are in a nutshell ... 2D platforms. Basic simple platform brawling. The scary part is I'm only playing these demos. Actually to be honest, I'm enjoying the extremely short Castle Crashers demo more than the actual GTA 4 which is just lying here on my desk. I'm just having so MUCH more fun playing these titles. There's no steep learning curve, million button configurations or confusing navigation problems. I now remember what gaming was like a few years ago.

I'm probably in the minority here but I personally think titles got to complicated and technical over the years. I'll rather come home from work and just bash away and have fun than replaying a very, strategic, 40 minute, confusing mission over and over.

Well, maybe that's just me. I miss the old games but I don't want to retro. I want to play these type of games on current generation machines and that's why I'm glad about the new Epic game and the new turtles remake.
 
Last edited:
+1

the old games were FUN.
but.......I do like Racedriver:Grid above all those old racers though....

I think it boils down to how much "arcadey" you are. some people like 40 minute complicated missions, and if you can say that's COD 4 then yes, i too am part of that crowd.

It's a good idea to change your type of game every now and again - too much of one will get boring and the others will suddenly feel awesome again.
 
Ditto

Let's forget about all the Wii/Natal/Motion tech stuff for a minute as the thread is focused more on standard controller titles.

Here's my little debate. I'm been gaming since NES/DOS days and yeah, gaming has come a far way since then. The past couple of months I've been playing Fallout 2, Grand Theft Auto 4, Fable 2, etc. Basically all the A grade titles on the market that interests me. The games were fun so I was satisfied ...or so I thought.

A few days ago I discovered a site where you can download Xbox games demos. Since I'm on 3G at home I never had the luxury of doing so on Xbox Live and since this site is HTTP based I could download some at work which is upcapped. Yeah, I played the Red Faction demo, the RE4 demo and some others but the shock came in when I started playing Castle Crashers, Sonic 3, Gunstar Heroes and some other HD titles such as Omega 5.

Now for those who aren't familiar with these titles they are in a nutshell ... 2D platforms. Basic simple platform brawling. The scary part is I'm only playing these demos. Actually to be honest, I'm enjoying the extremely short Castle Crashers demo more than the actual GTA 4 which is just lying here on my desk. I'm just having so MUCH more fun playing these titles. There's no steep learning curve, million button configurations or confusing navigation problems. I now remember what gaming was like a few years ago.

I'm probably in the minority here but I personally think titles got to complicated and technical over the years. I'll rather come home from work and just bash away and have fun than replaying a very, strategic, 40 minute, confusing mission over and over.

Well, maybe that's just me. I miss the old games but I don't want to retro. I want to play these type of games on current generation machines and that's why I'm glad about the new Epic game and the new turtles remake.

Man,i feel the same.
Went down to a local fish and chips shop and enjoyed an ancient game of street fighter 2 on a beat up old arcade machine.
I felt like a awkward and pimpled teen all over again.
The raw enjoyment of hearing Ryu shout 'HADOOOKEN' gave me such a thrill.
AH the good ol days....
I still love modern games but have to refect on the old games to fully appreciate the new ones.
Enjoying Mame32 RIGHT NOW.
 
Let's forget about all the Wii/Natal/Motion tech stuff for a minute as the thread is focused more on standard controller titles.

Here's my little debate. I'm been gaming since NES/DOS days and yeah, gaming has come a far way since then. The past couple of months I've been playing Fallout 2, Grand Theft Auto 4, Fable 2, etc. Basically all the A grade titles on the market that interests me. The games were fun so I was satisfied ...or so I thought.

A few days ago I discovered a site where you can download Xbox games demos. Since I'm on 3G at home I never had the luxury of doing so on Xbox Live and since this site is HTTP based I could download some at work which is upcapped. Yeah, I played the Red Faction demo, the RE4 demo and some others but the shock came in when I started playing Castle Crashers, Sonic 3, Gunstar Heroes and some other HD titles such as Omega 5.

Now for those who aren't familiar with these titles they are in a nutshell ... 2D platforms. Basic simple platform brawling. The scary part is I'm only playing these demos. Actually to be honest, I'm enjoying the extremely short Castle Crashers demo more than the actual GTA 4 which is just lying here on my desk. I'm just having so MUCH more fun playing these titles. There's no steep learning curve, million button configurations or confusing navigation problems. I now remember what gaming was like a few years ago.

I'm probably in the minority here but I personally think titles got to complicated and technical over the years. I'll rather come home from work and just bash away and have fun than replaying a very, strategic, 40 minute, confusing mission over and over.

Well, maybe that's just me. I miss the old games but I don't want to retro. I want to play these type of games on current generation machines and that's why I'm glad about the new Epic game and the new turtles remake.

This is the very reason why I love Games like Diablo so much. Just * click click click* until your finger feels like breaking and then run away! :D Lol. Of course it can also get very complicated with the skill trees etc etc but my point is that a game that is simple can indeed be so much more fun than a game that seems to need you to take a course on it before you can play it sufficiently.
 
This is the very reason why I love Games like Diablo so much. Just * click click click* until your finger feels like breaking and then run away! :D Lol. Of course it can also get very complicated with the skill trees etc etc but my point is that a game that is simple can indeed be so much more fun than a game that seems to need you to take a course on it before you can play it sufficiently.

Yeah Diablo is another perfect example. Even though the game has depth it's still very easy to grasp and enjoy and like you mentioned, taking a course with every new game you purchase is simply just a chore.

Maybe going retro for a secondary option is not a bad idea. Just something you can enjoy on the sideline when you're not in the mood for technical gaming. I'm actually amazed that Blaze has recently re-released the Sega MegaDrive console (I'm not joking). It's the full blown Sega MegaDrive with the same controllers and everything ...brand new. Cartridges isn't really a problem since I can import like 20 of them from ebay for like R200 or cheaper.
 
I deffo agree with the OP. Games are just not that fun for me anymore. I mean OK... sports games are different because of the ever changing nature of sport itself...

The good ol' days:)
 
whoohooo! castle crashers is damn fun. i would definitely recommend the whole game.
 
Yeah Diablo is another perfect example. Even though the game has depth it's still very easy to grasp and enjoy and like you mentioned, taking a course with every new game you purchase is simply just a chore.

Maybe going retro for a secondary option is not a bad idea. Just something you can enjoy on the sideline when you're not in the mood for technical gaming. I'm actually amazed that Blaze has recently re-released the Sega MegaDrive console (I'm not joking). It's the full blown Sega MegaDrive with the same controllers and everything ...brand new. Cartridges isn't really a problem since I can import like 20 of them from ebay for like R200 or cheaper.

Sega megadrive back from the dead?
I see Checkers sell pirated playstation 1 looking sega megadrive consoles.
They even have 20 in 1 carts with a great variety of games for R85.
 
I find those old platform games repetitive and boring. Fine as a quick distraction.

This is the very reason why I love Games like Diablo so much. Just * click click click* until your finger feels like breaking and then run away! :D Lol.
Another game I found thoroughly boring.
 
A few days ago I discovered a site where you can download Xbox games demos. Since I'm on 3G at home I never had the luxury of doing so on Xbox Live and since this site is HTTP based I could download some at work which is upcapped. Yeah, I played the Red Faction demo, the RE4 demo and some others but the shock came in when I started playing Castle Crashers, Sonic 3, Gunstar Heroes and some other HD titles such as Omega 5.

Sounds good - please share the link
 
I do agree proportionately, but for me it's not so much the era of 32-bit games etc (though i do still enjoy them) but more just superb addictive games that you can't stop playing. Started playing Persona 4 the other day and man, what an awesome JRPG. It's the best JRPG i've played in the last couple of years by a mile, and better than any JRPG i've played on the next-gen systems so far.
 
DarkWater, you speak so much sense. I agree completely. I have some of the latest AAA titles as well, but I keep falling back to basic gaming. When I say basic gaming I don't mean Mario on the NES (which is still awesome), but rather games that still adhere to the old recipe.

Contra, Wolfenstein, DOOM, Worms, Bomberman, Street Fighter, Duke Nukem, Diablo II, etc...

Heck I still play Diablo II on USEast! Not just casually either, I started a clan there 2 years ago and is now the biggest and most visited legit Baalrunning channel in USEast. Diablo II has me so caught up that I created and still maintain our clan website. Go to "Op X.treme" and pop in some time.

Now I'm sorry, but when I finished games such as Mirror's Edge, Assassin's Creed, Half-Life, and BioShock, the games were "finished". Sold to the local games rental store here in Potchefstroom. But in the same breath, I absolutely refuse to sell games like Diablo II, Gears of War, Mortal Kombat, FIFA, NBA, Banjo Kazooie, Prince of Persia (the old 2D one), and Quake III. Why? They follow the recipe of the old days. Great gameplay enjoys preference over graphics. Enough Said!
 
Uhm, mebe its just because your not too good a the new games....? :p

i like a challenge and prefer the new modern games over the old ones
 
Uhm, mebe its just because your not too good a the new games....? :p

i like a challenge and prefer the new modern games over the old ones

This makes me wonder why I use MyBB forums. ROFL.
 
Uhm, mebe its just because your not too good a the new games....? :p

i like a challenge and prefer the new modern games over the old ones

LOL! You have no clue! :D

Old games were so much more challenging and difficult. Mega Man series, I'm looking at you! :)
 
LOL! You have no clue! :D

Old games were so much more challenging and difficult. Mega Man series, I'm looking at you! :)

+ 1 Million

Nevermind Contra, Mega Turrican, Double Dragon, Battletoads, etc.
 
Ghost n Goblins, still one of the most difficult games ever created :D

G 'n G was friggin hectic. Still also remember taking a bankie full of 20c to the local arcade to finish Double Dragon. :D

Solidus, how're you enjoying Dragon's Quest? If you're looking for another PS2 JRPG that is simply fantastic, get Persona 4. Trust me, you won't be disappointed. Also picked up Odin Sphere for R99, but will start that once i'm done with Persona 4.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X