80mbps VDSL ?

Rouxenator said:
I wonder if they will ever give 80mbps as an option on VDSL?
Click to expand...

Why aim so low, how about 100 down 10 up ?

Code: 
       VDSL Port Details       Upstream         Downstream
               Line Rate:      3.129 Mbps       45.147 Mbps
    Actual Net Data Rate:      3.072 Mbps       45.055 Mbps
          Trellis Coding:         ON                ON
              SNR Margin:       19.6 dB           25.8 dB
            Actual Delay:          4 ms              8 ms
          Transmit Power:      -24.2 dBm          14.5 dBm
           Receive Power:      -39.5 dBm           2.3 dBm
              Actual INP:        2.0 symbols       3.0 symbols
       Total Attenuation:        0.0 dB          15.1 dB
Attainable Net Data Rate:      9.654 Mbps      125.127 Mbps

I don't think it's because Telkom doesn't care, the real issue is benefits vs. additional problems or support effort.

For example, operators in some other countries offer e.g. 76Mbps VDSL2 products, for example BT Infinity, however Only 1 percent of “up to 76Mbps“ customers actually get 76Mbps from UK ISPs, and that is with a much higher population density.

Nevertheless, I am asking the question ...
 
133 Mbps !!!

55964744.jpg
 
Rouxenator said:
I'm quite happy on 40bmps - it's just that more is always better. Been on 40mbps since April last year with not issues at all. Only now that I have a fancy new router can I see my line is, in theory, capable of higher speeds.

I stay about 600m from the exchange.
View attachment 400371
Click to expand...

I don't even have 40mb/s yet, and you want faster speeds, what on earth would you do on faster speeds and what do you need it for.

Can you only get fiber if they lay fiber to your SDC from the exchange or MSAN and then get them to lay fiber from SDC to DP in the air or dig up ground from SDC into your home?
 
KOPITE said:
Just got bumped up to 40mb/s
My snr has increased from 14 to 22.9

View attachment 401045
Click to expand...

After 2 days or so you will be pushed to 45 147k.... Your SNR went up because VDSL handles the line much better and you can not estimate VDSL line stats or speeds while syncing on ADSL2+ because it's misleading.
 
cavedog said:
After 2 days or so you will be pushed to 45 147k.... Your SNR went up because VDSL handles the line much better and you can not estimate VDSL line stats or speeds while syncing on ADSL2+ because it's misleading.
Click to expand...

So is that whole 700M max for VDSL a sham?
 
Rickster said:
So is that whole 700M max for VDSL a sham?
Click to expand...

700m yes. I'm @ 1.2km and sync 22.5Mbps VDSL with a SNR of 23dB...... Max I could sync at was 38Mbps with SNR 6dB so I decided to keep with 20Mbps.
 
The main thing people are getting wrong when looking at line stats are the line stats in relation to the technology.

FOR EXAMPLE.

20Mbps adsl2+ sync Attenuation 10dB SNR 15dB

If one had line stats like that you would assume the stats would look similar in VDSL that is where people are wrong because the max of ADSL2+ is 24Mbps the distance you have to be from the dslam/exchnage is just under 1KM give or take.

Now VDSL max is 100Mbps down and 50Mbps up so one have to consider that 24Mbps is max adsl2+ so the stats would not look the same on VDSL2 which has a max of 100Mbps this a 20Mbps VDSL2 service will have much better line stats at the same distance compared to a adsl2+ service at the same speed.

I think if you want to have a better estimate you have to look at line stats of a 8Mbps or 10Mbps adsl2+ if you want to move to 20Mbps VDSL2
 
cavedog said:
The main thing people are getting wrong when looking at line stats are the line stats in relation to the technology.

FOR EXAMPLE.

20Mbps adsl2+ sync Attenuation 10dB SNR 15dB

If one had line stats like that you would assume the stats would look similar in VDSL that is where people are wrong because the max of ADSL2+ is 24Mbps the distance you have to be from the dslam/exchnage is just under 1KM give or take.

Now VDSL max is 100Mbps down and 50Mbps up so one have to consider that 24Mbps is max adsl2+ so the stats would not look the same on VDSL2 which has a max of 100Mbps this a 20Mbps VDSL2 service will have much better line stats at the same distance compared to a adsl2+ service at the same speed.

I think if you want to have a better estimate you have to look at line stats of a 8Mbps or 10Mbps adsl2+ if you want to move to 20Mbps VDSL2
Click to expand...

So why dont they scrap ADSL and have 2/4/8/10meg VDSL?
 
Here are some examples....

New line installed still on 10Mbps ADSL2+
adsl_10mbps_newline.png



Same line moved to 20Mbps but still on ADSL2+ Slight difference in attenuation but it's because of a different router I guess.
20Mbps_adsl2plus.png



Same line moved to 20Mbps VDSL2 profile. Higher attenuation once VDSL change over but also higher SNR with more speed same distance.
vdsl_line_stats2.png



Same line moved to 40Mbps VDSL2 profile
vdsl_upto_40_stats.png
 
cavedog said:
The main thing people are getting wrong when looking at line stats are the line stats in relation to the technology.

FOR EXAMPLE.

20Mbps adsl2+ sync Attenuation 10dB SNR 15dB

If one had line stats like that you would assume the stats would look similar in VDSL that is where people are wrong because the max of ADSL2+ is 24Mbps the distance you have to be from the dslam/exchnage is just under 1KM give or take.

Now VDSL max is 100Mbps down and 50Mbps up so one have to consider that 24Mbps is max adsl2+ so the stats would not look the same on VDSL2 which has a max of 100Mbps this a 20Mbps VDSL2 service will have much better line stats at the same distance compared to a adsl2+ service at the same speed.

I think if you want to have a better estimate you have to look at line stats of a 8Mbps or 10Mbps adsl2+ if you want to move to 20Mbps VDSL2
Click to expand...

Yes, up to a point (between 1.6km and 2km, 23 to 26dB on ADSL2+) according to:
dsl-speed-comparisons.jpg

Wikipedia NL diagram says that VDSL2 is always slightly better (everyone else says near no to no difference past ~1.8km)
VDSL2_Snelheid.gif

EDIT: netherlands one could be VDSL2 long reach 2, it is soon to be released.
long_reach_vdsl2_fttc_performance_prediction.gif
http://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2016/04/bt-openreach-prep-trial-long-reach-vdsl-broadband.html
 
Last edited:
Rickster said:
So why dont they scrap ADSL and have 2/4/8/10meg VDSL?
Click to expand...

Good question. I don't think the older dslams and IMAX supports VDSL. Even if they did Telkom pushed adsl for so long if they force VDSL then it could cause massive headache.

I don't see why they just don't offer VDSL to people connected to an ISAM because it eliminate so many issues with line stability.
 
Johnatan56 said:
Yes, up to a point (between 1.6km and 2km, 23 to 26dB on ADSL2+) according to:
View attachment 401071

Wikipedia NL diagram says that VDSL2 is always slightly better (everyone else says near no to no difference past ~1.8km)
View attachment 401075

EDIT: netherlands one could be VDSL2 long reach 2, it is soon to be released.
View attachment 401077
http://www.ispreview.co.uk/index.php/2016/04/bt-openreach-prep-trial-long-reach-vdsl-broadband.html
Click to expand...



100% correct to a point. Now since we have a 20Mbps option that allows both ADSL2+ and VDSL2 on this specific package and lower speeds too it would almost always be a better option to switch to VDSL2 compared to ADSL2+ since 20Mbps is close to maxing ADSL2+ but only getting started on VDSL2 so yeah that is why I say most cases not all.
 
Last edited:
cavedog said:
After 2 days or so you will be pushed to 45 147k.... Your SNR went up because VDSL handles the line much better and you can not estimate VDSL line stats or speeds while syncing on ADSL2+ because it's misleading.
Click to expand...

Ok cool man
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X