MTN. "Taking from the poor, ......"?

AlexFl

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
391
We're laymen and not too proficient regarding technical issues.

A pensioned family member moved from a Telkom ADSL line, to pre-paid mobile broadband data, to a 24 month data contract through MTN Hyde Park (in November '14, using an existing Huawei 3G WiFi dongle).

Previous average data consumption was said to be well under 1GB/month but, due to an ill family member and ultimately bereavement just prior to entering into the MTN contract (foreseen increase in Skype), the additional 1GB proposed by MTN to a total R99pm was quickly agreed to. However, no Skype calls were undertaken during the period from inception and the first invoice. MTN's data contract was entered into for 24 * 2GB @ R99/month. The subject of a data 'cap' wasn't raised.

1st monthly bill: R1,022.79! When queried with...
store staff and management, ...
the MTN call centre, and ultimately, ...
after a drive to MTN's head office...
all that MTN could tender to substantiate this was a meaningless list of hundreds/thousands of URL's visited and more disclaimers. This after an email from MTN stating that out of bundle charges amounted to over 3GB @ 25c/MB!

Options available at that juncture: (a) continue with MTN and receive a R300ish goodwill credit, OR (b) pay a penalty to exit contract.

Without any further reasonable guidance, and on the worst case assumption that 3GB plus of OS / Office / anti-virus updates must have been required (on an ever-auto-updated 6 month old MS laptop), the former option was conceded to during Jan'15. I.e. the MTN contract continues - but on the AGREED PROVISOS that a. the debit order be removed in lieu of EFTs on presentation of invoices, and b. a data cap be affected if 2GB limit was reached.

2nd monthly bill: R150.30! Deducted by debit order when already paid by EFT! (There was an extended Skype call during the deceased's memorial gathering).

Said 'bill' is only a one page statement with even more disclaimers received my email, prompting one to register on a website for billing details. The website doesn't work so the details aren't available.

All of the foregoing is accurately recorded with MTN references (logged calls, etc.).

Does one just has to go through the same cycle of complaining and reporting - to no avail whilst your (pensioner) bank balance reduces and MTNs' earnings sky rocket? :mad:

What recourse is available please? Does the CPA cover this person? :confused:
 

Rickster

EVGA Fanatic
Joined
Jul 31, 2012
Messages
20,429
Ok whats the maximum amount they can afford for internet.
 

AlexFl

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
391
R99 was comfortable as opposed to the previous entire Telkom land line, ADSL premium & their cheapest ISP bundle. Telkom ADSL line and ISP cancelled a while back and land line may also go imminently. No qualms about MTN offering of R99 for 2GB. Just that it's not user friendly at all and nobody giving straight answers = no comfort in going forward. First 2 of 24 months have been a debacle, costing nearly the full value of 24 months service...
 

AlexFl

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
391
We're talking about people that barely know how to email here! Not people that are on YouTube at every opportunity. It's conceivable that certain s/w may have needed updates, but to the tune of 3GB? The machine is stock with Win8, MS Office (version unknown), Avast and is used for correspondence, limited Skype and those silly card games that Windows used to come with - Solitaire, etc.
 

whatwhat

Executive Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2009
Messages
6,353
They are better off getting an Afrihost sim, and when it runs out to buy more data.

With the OOB rates on MTN, and people that have no computer savvy you end up with a dangerous cocktail.
 

AlexFl

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
391
Excuse my ignorance but I'm only aware of sim cards from the big mobile telephony co's. How would an Afrihost sim work? And I can get pricing on their www?
 

whatwhat

Executive Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2009
Messages
6,353
Excuse my ignorance but I'm only aware of sim cards from the big mobile telephony co's. How would an Afrihost sim work? And I can get pricing on their www?

Yeah, just go to the Afrihost site or the Axxess site and look at their mobile offering.
They send you a sim, when the data is depleted you need to top up. There isn't any out of bundle, and it isn't on contract you just pay month to month and cancel when you dont need it anymore. It works on the MTN network like a MTN sim would.

2GB of data at the moment costs R79 a month, but that is due to the double data promotion on Axxess.
 

AlexFl

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
391
@whatwhat, Thanks! Now, how to get them out of the 22 remaining months of 24?
 

AlexFl

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
391
Isn't there an MTN rep on MyBB that can confirm data consumption and advise on options to resolve amicably?
 

whatwhat

Executive Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2009
Messages
6,353
@whatwhat, Thanks! Now, how to get them out of the 22 remaining months of 24?

Just cancel it. There is no device fee, and MTN will charge you one month's subscription as a penalty so you're looking at just under R200 to get out of it.
 

AlexFl

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
391
Just cancel it. There is no device fee, and MTN will charge you one month's subscription as a penalty so you're looking at just under R200 to get out of it.

Thanks. Will ask them to pursue that. When they threatened to cancel the 24 month contract during January (after the R1k Pls bill), they were advised of a substantially higher punitive penalty.

If the penalty is R200, they'll get more than that in savings through Afrihost being R10 cheaper/month.
 
Top