Reputation system: Yes or no?

[wily me]

Vote up Vote down system is the most effective IMHO...

That also failed on MyBB apparently!

 

[sand_man]

That also failed on MyBB apparently!

Don't ever recall this being implemented.

It's possibly the quickest way to filter credible posts from the arb one's..

 

[froot]

i voted yes but it doesnt really matter to me

You're only about a month late

 

[profeet]

Hi folks

We have run the reputation system for a few weeks, and it is time for you to tell us whether we should keep it or not.

Can you please vote in the poll in this thread.

Here we go. The first death of the shining ones.

LOL.

 

[Icemanbrfc]

i vote bloody keep it, until i get a few green blocks

 

[LaraC]

i vote bloody keep it, until i get a few green blocks

Don't think the votes count anymore. This is a very old thread necro.

 

[LaraC]

Could this also explain why people have ratings already?

 

[profeet]

Could this also explain why people have ratings already?

Starting out with set amount?
Previous round was never removed?
People circle rep each other?

I'll take no2 and bit of no3

 

[Icemanbrfc]

Don't think the votes count anymore. This is a very old thread necro.

 

[biometrics]

Starting out with set amount?
Previous round was never removed?
People circle rep each other?

I'll take no2 and bit of no3

I'll rep you tomorrow for almost never making sense.

 

[Mortymoose]

No.... Irritating.... Got three notifications in the last three hours.....

 

[profeet]

I'll rep you tomorrow for almost never making sense.

I'm more interested in how we got the actual rep number instead of seeing the blocks. I do remember their being a trick; I mean you can swap around the submit values

// approves circle-repping

 

[biometrics]

No.... Irritating.... Got three notifications in the last three hours.....

Liar, your block is virgin gray.

 

[Mortymoose]

Liar, your block is virgin gray.

But!But!..........

 

[Polish]

Also voted no for as is.

A rep system in general, yes, but rules must be different.

 

[McGuywer]

Voted no.
I simply don't like it.

 

[thehuman]

Positive rep i like
Negative rep maybe not

 

[GrammatonCleric]

It seems out of place on MyBB. It looks like you're trying to introduce a Facebook "like" system that doesn't really fit a comment section in its current state

 

[marco79]

Yes. It would be interesting to know how this reputation is being compiled? 1 green bar = 1k posts, 1 green bar = 13k posts, 2 green bars = 34k posts, 2 green bars = 127k posts

 

[esvi]

Yes. It would be interesting to know how this reputation is being compiled? 1 green bar = 1k posts, 1 green bar = 13k posts, 2 green bars = 34k posts, 2 green bars = 127k posts

Yeah, what does it mean... and what is the point of typing a comment?