Review: Nokia N8

Had too many Nokia to remember the alphabet soup of models. More than happy with my current E72. The HTC I had to use for 2 months when working in the Middle East was a piece of cr@p
 
How does this differ from the voice prompts my (Vodacom) Blackberry sat nav gives me?

For some reason we've been struggling to get our Bold 9700 and Torch 9800 to talk to us when navigating. Which model have you got?

But fair enough, I'll make the review more accurate :-).

Symbian is dying though... the issue with Symbian in the past was the clunky dev environment, hence not that many apps appearing of late. Android is the real killer for developers so we are going to see a surge in Android - more apps makes happier phone owners, especially if there are so many free ones.

Nokia have tried to rectify this with Qt. From my experience with Qt on PC it could declunkify development quite a bit. Don't know if it's too little too late, though.

Nokias REAL issue, however, is the price of their handsets. WAY overpriced, period! I recall a time when HTC was expensive for what you got... seems the tables have turned.

The N8 was supposed to be very competitively priced. Some pre-orders ran at around R4800 or so, but I saw an MTN ad today where the N8 was priced only R10 cheaper (per month) than a BlackBerry Torch.
 
Last edited:
For some reason we've been struggling to get our Bold 9700 and Torch 9800 to talk to us when navigating. Whice model have you got?
It's an older Bold 9000 using Vodafone Sat Nav.
 
What the hell i wrong with them using Android... It gets better every day and they refuse to use it??? Anyway it is time for a new OS guys.

Nokia have discussed this issue and I tend to agree with them. Android is a temporary reprieve from the constant competition in the market. They have Maemo and MeeGo and both of them look pretty darn good, not to mention that more competition is good as it drives other platforms to adapt and innovate more to stay ahead of the curb.

That does leave some doubt about the reviewers abilities.

You would notice that he said it "...feels like...", not that it is laggy. Personally, I don't like that it only responds after the swipe gesture, and while side scrolling widgets is a nifty idea, it seems like they're compensating for only having 1x4 widgets that can't scroll up and down.

I liked Symbian back in the day on my N-Gage, but the recent developments for touch devices don't impress me. I'll stick to my Droid for now, thanks...
 
That does leave some doubt about the reviewers abilities.

Reviewers will have different opinions about the design choices made in Symbian^3.

I for one felt that executing the swipe command after the gesture is completed rather than during makes the phone feel laggy even if it isn't.

EDIT: Heh, Hawkies beat me to it :P
 
Had too many Nokia to remember the alphabet soup of models. More than happy with my current E72. The HTC I had to use for 2 months when working in the Middle East was a piece of cr@p

Most probably a HTC Wildfire.

I still have a Nokia Navigator that I use for voice prompted navigation - and it's brilliant - but my SE P990i made me realize that Symbian was not made for touch screen phones. You really needed to "thumb" the screen hard to get any reaction from the Symbian OS.

Agree with what someone said earlier, Nokia phones are/were always WAY overpriced.
 
i honestly feel for the people working at Nokia. their hardegat bosses are going to cost them their jobs.
i believe competition is good yes, but be bold Nokia. Bring out one phone that some techies can easily get Android 2.2 up and running. make a viral, nobody will know you planned it
see how good it sells.

android went from < 3% to > 25% market share in a year (mybroadband.co.za).
you can't deny it.

the only way i'll ever buy a nokia again, is if i can get android on it, and this thus means that i will never buy a nokia again.
 
I personally think Nokia shot themselves in the foot when they decided to start locking all they're smart phones. The reason I always chose Nokia was because of it's customization features. But that's just not the case anymore. I've got a Nokia 5230 and I can't do anything with it. The only apps that run on it is Mxit & Opera Mini. No free apps work, I'm afraid to purchase apps because they probably won't work so in my opinion this phone is absolutely useless, and it's not just the 5230 all S60v5 phones are like this.

This is complete nonsense. Free apps work and I run my own code on my 5800 all the time with no problems. It's very easy to customize it and Symbian allows your code to run directly on hardware with no pesky JVM in the way unlike BlackBerry OS and Android.

Symbian FTW
 
Last edited:
That does leave some doubt about the reviewers abilities.
As I said in the other thread, just because it was designed that way, doesn't make it right. The right thing to do would be to offer the option to choose which type of scrolling is preferred, with a note that real-time scrolling will affect side-scrolling widgets.

Not everybody uses side-scrolling widgets, yet everybody is lumped into the same boat to compensate for it.
 
I got my N8 last thurs and to be honest I love it.
Not sure why people complain about Symbian but maybe they like more "Oooh Shiny" UI's.
On my N8 havn't found a free app that hasnt worked althought I have had apps crash on me.

In my opinion having had the phone for a few days the main drawback which wasnt spoken about (Could be wrong) was the home-key which is in a terrible spot and is akward to push when holding the phone in one hand.

Edit: Browser is terrible but use Opera any way
 
Last edited:
Those that support Symbian seem to be a similar type of user to those that still buy Toyota's because of their reliability. Symbian, due to its design and lack of development (read other manufacturers bailing) is only suitable for non smartphones and I think in that environment it still flourishes. However, the likes of Anrdroid and iOS have firmly relegated Symbian to the bottom of the pile from which it will not recover.
 
i honestly feel for the people working at Nokia. their hardegat bosses are going to cost them their jobs.
i believe competition is good yes, but be bold Nokia. Bring out one phone that some techies can easily get Android 2.2 up and running. make a viral, nobody will know you planned it
see how good it sells.

android went from < 3% to > 25% market share in a year (mybroadband.co.za).
you can't deny it.

the only way i'll ever buy a nokia again, is if i can get android on it, and this thus means that i will never buy a nokia again.

+1
It seems as if this is just a good camera with a phone and a crappy software
It is amazing that Nokia is not manufacturing a lot of android based phones, if any
For god sake they are one of the oldest cellphone manufacturing company and yet their share of the market is getting smaller.
Almost everyone in this forum probably owned a Nokia at some point in their lives. And if nothing drastic happens, they will wake up one day and all it will be gone...forever.
Its going to be another General Motors
 
+1
It seems as if this is just a good camera with a phone and a crappy software
It is amazing that Nokia is not manufacturing a lot of android based phones, if any
For god sake they are one of the oldest cellphone manufacturing company and yet their share of the market is getting smaller.
Almost everyone in this forum probably owned a Nokia at some point in their lives. And if nothing drastic happens, they will wake up one day and all it will be gone...forever.
Its going to be another General Motors

+1000
 
The wining formula in cellphones sales is the operating system
Gone are the days where clunky OS was the order of the day

People want OS that is fluid-like and works all the time. An interface where one press less buttons to execute the same thing

ARE WE CURRENTLY WITNESSING THE DEATH OF NOKIA and SYMBIAN
I ll be the first to say rest in peace
 
There also doesn't seem to be a way to disconnect from a Wi-Fi network once connected to one.

You can disconnect throught the widget on the homescreen or in the Connectivity Settings
 
You can disconnect throught the widget on the homescreen or in the Connectivity Settings

Or just press the wi-fi connection status (the antenna picture above the date) on any of the home screens. That will let you get to connectivity settings where you can disable it.

No need to add a connectivity settings widget.
 
Having used Symbian on a 5800XM, I find it very clunky and inconsistent. For example in some menus and lists you can scroll by swiping, others not, they have scrollbars. Why does Nokia want to make everything so hard to learn?
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X