The Official EPL 2010/11 Thread

G

GRBoy

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2010
Messages
630
What pathetic refereeing Mike Dean. Is he just inconsistent or is it because it was MUFC? MU should have had 4 players red carded.

Hernandez should have been booked twice, first time for kicking the ball away. Not done. He could also have been red carded for the tackle where he received a yellow only (compare that tackle to the one for which Wiltshire rcvd a red). Nani should have been booked for deliberate handball (he keeps on getting away with these) would have been his 2nd. Brown should have been given a red (compare with Koscielny last week same referee). Vidic should have been given a 2nd yellow for going to the crowd - like Mike Dean did with Ashley Young. Once more MU have 12 players on the pitch.
 
RanzB

RanzB

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 4, 2007
Messages
29,562
GRBoy said:
What pathetic refereeing Mike Dean. Is he just inconsistent or is it because it was MUFC? MU should have had 4 players red carded.

Hernandez should have been booked twice, first time for kicking the ball away. Not done. He could also have been red carded for the tackle where he received a yellow only (compare that tackle to the one for which Wiltshire rcvd a red). Nani should have been booked for deliberate handball (he keeps on getting away with these) would have been his 2nd. Brown should have been given a red (compare with Koscielny last week same referee). Vidic should have been given a 2nd yellow for going to the crowd - like Mike Dean did with Ashley Young. Once more MU have 12 players on the pitch.
Click to expand...

Oh boohoohoo. A couple of Villa players could've been sent off as well. And let's not mention that if we did have a 12th man on the pitch, he wouldn't have awarded a penalty against us :rolleyes:

Brown should never have been given a red card, it was a collision in the box where he wasn't last man. Penalty yes, red card - no.
 
MickeyD

MickeyD

RIP
Joined
Oct 4, 2010
Messages
139,117
Barclays Premier League (13 November) Results

Villa Park (40 073)
Aston Villa - 2 (72 A Young (pen), 76 M Albrighton)
Man Utd - 2 (81 F Macheda, 85 N Vidic)

City of Manchester Stadium (44 321)
Man City - 0
Birmingham - 0

St James' Park (44 686)
Newcastle - 0
Fulham - 0

White Hart Lane (35 700)
Tottenham - 4 (16 G Bale, 42 R Pavlyuchenk, 69 P Crouch, 75 G Bale)
Blackburn - 2 (80 R Nelsen, 90 G Givet)

Upton Park (31 194)
West Ham - 0
Blackpool - 0

The DW Stadium (16 085)
Wigan - 1 (V Moses)
West Brom - 0

Molineux Stadium (27 508)
Wolverhampton - 2 (69 K Foley, 78 S Fletcher)
Bolton - 3 (1 R Stearman (og), 62 J Elmander, 67 S Holden)

Britannia Stadium (27 286)
Stoke - 2 (56 R Fuller, 91 K Jones)
Liverpool - 0
 
Last edited:
G

GRBoy

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 27, 2010
Messages
630
Randhir said:
Oh boohoohoo. A couple of Villa players could've been sent off as well. And let's not mention that if we did have a 12th man on the pitch, he wouldn't have awarded a penalty against us :rolleyes:

Brown should never have been given a red card, it was a collision in the box where he wasn't last man. Penalty yes, red card - no.
Click to expand...

Once again you reveal your ignorance of the laws of football. The law says if a player denies a clear goal scoring opportunity he should receive a red card. Nothing about last man. Dean could only not give a red card if he deemed that the other defender had a good chance of preventing the goal scoring opportunity. Seeing that he decidided last week that Koscielny denied the Newcastle player an obvious goal scoring opportunity 40m out, it is very difficult to see how he could argue differently this time.

But we can even concede that one. It still leaves 3 mu players who should very obviously have been given red cards. You say nothing about these?

As an MU supporter it is understandably impossible for you to recognise the bias towards your team - for most other fans it is very clear.
 
RanzB

RanzB

Honorary Master
Joined
Jul 4, 2007
Messages
29,562
smokey said:
Now now you two... either play nice or find a room.
Click to expand...

Hush you, I wanna know where else this dude thinks I messed up. He's becoming more and more like Cantera everyday, throwing out BS statements.
 
Helghast

Helghast

GoldenFinger
Joined
Jan 9, 2010
Messages
48,413
LOL Liverpool supporters thought things were looking up... then Stoke arrived... then Lucas left ;)
 
MickeyD

MickeyD

RIP
Joined
Oct 4, 2010
Messages
139,117
Barclays Premier League (14 November) Results

Goodison Park (36 279)
Everton - 1 (89 T Cahill)
Arsenal - 2 (36 B Sagna, 48 F Fabregas)

Stamford Bridge (41 072)
Chelsea - 0
Sunderland - 3 (45 N Onuoha, 52 A Gyan, 87 M Wellbeck)
 
S

smokey

Honorary Master
Joined
Dec 12, 2007
Messages
13,465
Anyway... two things that were positive from this weekend.

1. Onuoha's goal. Amazing

2. Torres is injured again. Good. Slimy git.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top