Android smoothness vs iOS

When I had my SGS with eclair I was quite a bit disappointed, but with Darkies ROM, my friends iPhone4 seems actually a bit less responsive than my SGS. What I like about the iPhone though is it's simplicity, android can clutter quite a bit. I just want to be able to put things in folders when I press the menu button. The closes that I got is LP where I can hide the unnecessary stuff, but folders would work better.
 
my unrooted desire is a dream
now imagine if i rooted it. its bound to be a wet dream lol :p
no issues here what you on about
 
When I had my SGS with eclair I was quite a bit disappointed, but with Darkies ROM, my friends iPhone4 seems actually a bit less responsive than my SGS. What I like about the iPhone though is it's simplicity, android can clutter quite a bit. I just want to be able to put things in folders when I press the menu button. The closes that I got is LP where I can hide the unnecessary stuff, but folders would work better.
??? Folders? We've been having it! Maybe its just on the HTC Sense phones but my desire has folders
Thing with android is, if you want folders just install the app or mod there you go.
 
You brought it upon yourself :P But yeah I don't know, it might be your setup that has something wrong with it cause I can honestly say the ifone and my Desire are equally smooth in everything comparable. Whats your setup, droid version, ROM if any, radio, ect. are you running? Maybe that can help explain more

I am running Darky's v9.2 (I9000XXJPY) (Froyo 2.2.1) , Voodoo Kernel, JPY Modem, Alternate Wi-Fi Driver (options in the Darky's Configurator). Look my phone is generally pretty smooth but it does hook a little more often than I would like or feel it should do.
 
I dont know if Samsung's Touchwiz UI is hardware accelerated, but Sense is, so maybe thats why owners of HTC phones dont know what the fuss is all about.

It is. Samsung also have hardware acceleration in the web browser on the Galaxy S, think they added that in a Froyo firmware.

corp said:
Thanks. I now understand. Any idea when they going to give more GPU acceleration support in the mobile versions of Android? I only ask cause I know Honeycomb is for tablet only.
Probably in the version after Honeycomb where they make Android into a single OS that can adapt to both tablets and phones.

As some posts above pointed out, the Galaxy S with a custom ROM can put the iPhone to shame in terms of speed and smoothness. Even the latest official firmware is pretty damn fast now, probably from Samsung taking advantage of what the hackers have done.
 
Last edited:
Thanks. I now understand. Any idea when they going to give more GPU acceleration support in the mobile versions of Android? I only ask cause I know Honeycomb is for tablet only.

Check out launcher pro.

Makes SGS'es as smooth as it gets. <3
 
??? Folders? We've been having it! Maybe its just on the HTC Sense phones but my desire has folders
Thing with android is, if you want folders just install the app or mod there you go.

I haven't been having it. Will look for it. But I want it in my menu not on the desktop, because in the menu everything is just dumped there. Will check it out now. I know astro filemanager is there, but I don't want to put my files in folders, I want to put my icons in folders. But will search the market anyway.
 
Hmm, I have been looking at it on the market and I can't find anything that does what I want it to. I want to organize my app drawer, not have another app that I have to open to have something like it.
 
Running TripNRaVeR's CyanogeMOD Froyo 2.2.1 ROM on my X10 with MIUI and it runs beautifuly, silky smooth with no slowdowns, its equal to iPhone4, im very happy with it. :)
 
I haven't been having it. Will look for it. But I want it in my menu not on the desktop, because in the menu everything is just dumped there. Will check it out now. I know astro filemanager is there, but I don't want to put my files in folders, I want to put my icons in folders. But will search the market anyway.

Have a look at Go Launcher... AFAIK, it allows you to organize your apps into folders in the app drawer. I haven't used it myself (as I can't pull myself away from LP+ after getting used to the outstanding widgets), but my buddy used Go for quite a long time and I remember him mentioning something like that.
 
Have a look at Go Launcher... AFAIK, it allows you to organize your apps into folders in the app drawer. I haven't used it myself (as I can't pull myself away from LP+ after getting used to the outstanding widgets), but my buddy used Go for quite a long time and I remember him mentioning something like that.


Thanks will have a look at it.
 
I found you cannot blame Android for 'stuttering'.

I have a x10 Xperia (yea, pity me pls), but after installing the Cyanogen 6.1.3 ROM, my phone from went from ok to brilliant. Cyanogen transformed my x10 from the worst Android phone, to a decent one. Its snappy and fast now (faster than Galaxy S running 2.1) and battery life has also improved 10 fold.

Conclusion is that the phone manufacturers are probably to blame for slow running androids, but once you get rid of all the rubbish (uninstallable apps such as Timescape, Mediascape, Moxier), Android is absolutely awesome.
 
I found you cannot blame Android for 'stuttering'.

I have a x10 Xperia (yea, pity me pls), but after installing the Cyanogen 6.1.3 ROM, my phone from went from ok to brilliant. Cyanogen transformed my x10 from the worst Android phone, to a decent one. Its snappy and fast now (faster than Galaxy S running 2.1) and battery life has also improved 10 fold.

Conclusion is that the phone manufacturers are probably to blame for slow running androids, but once you get rid of all the rubbish (uninstallable apps such as Timescape, Mediascape, Moxier), Android is absolutely awesome.

I always thought the xperia X10 was a great phone according to all the reviews? You dont agree? :confused:

Im seriously thinking going the Xperia Arc when it get released... not?
 
No, I too got caught up in the reviews and thats why I bought one.

- It was the last phone out of all the next-gen Android phones to receive Android 2.1 and since the announcement of Arc, X10's are now EOL products, therefor will be stuck on 2.1.
- I believe that X10's sold in SA is still running Android 1.6?

- X10 has a hardware flaw with multi-touch. If you hack it you will find that MT does work but the horizontal and vertical of the 2 touch points cannot cross each other. Example if you moved 1 finger from right to left and the other left to right the 2 points will get 'stuck' as they cross the vertical axis.

- Timescape is great gimmick at first, but I found it of no use. It also uses resources up like mad; causing stuttering and very poor battery life . Another problem with it that it was embedded into other applications, so if you end-tasked it, contacts wouldn't work.
- Although, praised by some, Moxier was another useless app that wasted resources, even though i never even used it. It always has some process running in the background.
- SE's development team must be shocking, because X10 also constantly had "face recognition" tasks running in the background, even when the camera wasn't in use.
- Battery life 10 hrs if I used the phone to max of 20 hours on standby. I'd charge my phone at night and next day before lunch it would be at 60%.

Now these apps never went into idle state, hence very poor battery life. As soon as I unchecked 'background data' and auto-synchronizations, my phone could easily go uncharged for 4+days. However, by doing that, I might as well have bought an ordinary phone.

Now with Cyanogen mod (Android 2.2), I manage 2-3 days with Wifi, GPS and synchronizations turned on.

Although, its a good looking phone with a good camera and impressive specs, I was burnt by Sony's poor after-sales support and resource hungry software.

If I were you, I'd wait a month or two once the Arc goes on sale and then go prowl the XDA forums for any major issues. At the moment, I wouldn't trust Sony.
 
Last edited:
Not sure if anyone mentioned this but the issue could be a simple fix. At least it is with the DHD.

I had some stuttering issues initially but I went to
Settings- Application- development- USB debugging.

Its a fix for my DHD but I guess no harm in checking it if you are using Android.
 
I have a Motorola XT720, not the best but certainly not the worst Android phone. My phone before this was the HTC Diamond with WinMobile 6. something, horrible in comparison!
The XT720 is very smooth, on the original ROM and the new Dexter ROM (Android 2.2). What is also a huge plus is that you can overclock the XT720 to 1100Mhz, and suddenly you have a beast on your hands!
 
I have a Motorola XT720, not the best but certainly not the worst Android phone. My phone before this was the HTC Diamond with WinMobile 6. something, horrible in comparison!
The XT720 is very smooth, on the original ROM and the new Dexter ROM (Android 2.2). What is also a huge plus is that you can overclock the XT720 to 1100Mhz, and suddenly you have a beast on your hands!

Glad you got your new phone! Oh.....I remember you posted somewhere and the sig read "sent from my XT720 using My Broadband app".

How is the Motoblur UI, or did you wipe it completely with the Dexter ROM?

*Damn, your phone's CPU is faster than mine! :(
 
Since this is my first Android I'm not sure exactly what is Motorola's doing and what is just standard Android.

What totally blew my mind was when I synced my contacts from gmail and ALL info were pulled in from other social networking sites, birthdays, telephone numbers I did not have, screen names/nicks, homepage, etc.

Some Motorola features are still present on the the Dexter rom, very happy with the flash so far!
 
My Nexus One has been faster and smoother than iPhone 3GS or iPhone 4 since Froyo. Now that the Gingerbread update has come through there's just no comparison. Super smooth!
 
No problems in terms of smoothness here. I think its kinda unfair to match the Xoom against the iPad at this time since the software is not 100% optimized yet. However I think once that is sorted it will kick some serious but. On my Desire i have run 2.2 stock, 2.2 rooted as well as CM 2.3, all of which run great. I don't like the CM 2.3 browser that much though.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X