iPhone 5 is the best smartphone ever: Stuff

Do you think the iPhone 5 is the best smartphone ever?

  • Yes

    Votes: 48 20.6%
  • No

    Votes: 185 79.4%

  • Total voters
    233
Dude, look at video, and tell me you not like :)

[video=youtube;V8_Z7_kJ3_g]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V8_Z7_kJ3_g[/video]

Without a doubt this is my next phone.

Reminds me of that Siri promo video.
 
I truly do believe that it's the best smartphone in the world and ever.

That's bold considering it does the least of any smartphone out there :/

I guess your answer is best user experience or something? I'm genuinely interested why it's the best

PS I'll give it credit where it's due, such as build quality and OS stability ... But I do feel it's only caught up (not surpassed) on some features and still lacks others. Off the top of my head, I can't think of a feature where it is number one?
 
Last edited:
I don't see why it is hard to believe? The Geekbench and browser tests that have shown up show it to be faster than any Android device (phone, phablet or tablet)
No sure which iSheep website you read, but according to geekbench website:
http://browser.primatelabs.com/geekbench2/1033461
Samsung Galaxy S III (the one that's available in ZA) Geekbench Score 1854

http://browser.primatelabs.com/geekbench2/1030202
iPhone5,2 Geekbench Score 1601

*Higher is better
 
I truly do believe that it's the best smartphone in the world and ever. But there is definitely also a narrowing of the gap between it and the competitors. They exceeded my expectations though, and then some.
Is your your opinion based on you owning/using an iPhone 5 or just reading Stuff magazine?
 
That's bold considering it does the least of any smartphone out there :/

I guess your answer is best user experience or something? I'm genuinely interested why it's the best

PS I'll give it credit where it's due, such as build quality and OS stability ... But I do feel it's only caught up (not surpassed) on some features and still lacks others. Off the top of my head, I can't think of a feature where it is number one?

The OS stablity is becoming less and less with every version. Youtube app is unstable as hell on ios5.
 
That's bold considering it does the least of any smartphone out there :/

I guess your answer is best user experience or something? I'm genuinely interested why it's the best

PS I'll give it credit where it's due, such as build quality and OS stability ... But I do feel it's only caught up (not surpassed) on some features and still lacks others. Off the top of my head, I can't think of a feature where it is number one?

It is a rather bold statement I agree. But I'm entitled to it, no? It's an opinion poll and I give my opinion freely.

Basically... yes, it has all the features that anybody else has now (with the notable exception of NFC which we'll agree is controversial). What sets it apart for me is the implementation of those features, the unwillingness to compromise on any single aspect.

1) The chassis is just leagues ahead of anything else. Look at the care they put into it - micron-level measurements in the fitment. That's not Jony Ive being blustery and bs'y, it's the facts - that's the care they were willing to put into it. Everything in the design side was rethought and refined endlessly. Nobody else cares that much - not HTC, not Nokia, and certainly not Samsung. It's also just incredibly aesthetically beautiful - playing off the iPhone4 concepts but far classier.

2) The screen is smaller than other competitive smartphones, granted, so if you're explicitly after a big screen experience, you'll be better off with the OneX, the 920 or the SGS3. But a bigger screen doesn't equal a better phone - I even found my 4.3" sgs2 when I had it to be unwieldy. And there will be phones with higher PPI's - Xperia S already does have that, and that Oopo 5" 1080p phone will rain showers of pixely poop on anything else.

But the screen on iPhone5 still looks like the best QUALITY display on the market. It's got what, 50% higher contrast over the 4S? That was already a superbly high contrast screen. The videos I've seen show it to be immediately brighter, warmer and more vivid. It displays the full sRGB gamut which means it displays colours that your pitiful simian eyeballs can't even see. And they brought the sensors as close as possible to the surface which will increase touch sensitivity and thinness. PPI is only a part of what makes a screen excellent - once you've passed the threshold of retina level, other factors become more important. (Although I'm also keen to see whether that 1080p 5" display is noticeably improved to the naked eye; I'll bet it is).

3) It is really really fast. I know all smartphones are fast now but iPhone5 is the fastest in real benchmarks. And on iOS that translates to crazy loading speeds and overall perceptibly better user experience. And they managed to increase the speed twofold while bringing the thermal envelope down, which is a hell of an achievement. Not only that, they integrated LTE that also doesn't chow the battery (I know LTE is useless here, it's still cool).

Not only is the CPU fast, the GPU looks crazy insane. The flyover 3d mapped demo was pure madness, and the Real Racing 3 screenshots are easily xbox level. I actually would love to be able to use my phone as a gaming device and on this count not only is iPhone5 ahead of anyone else, so is iOS's game selection.

4) I actually like iOS. I agree that it's getting a bit long in the tooth from the UI side but I still like it. I use this Sony tablet every day and I just prefer iOS. The experience is better. I'm not trying to be a fanboy, I'm actually trying very hard not to be - but there it is, what can you do?

Is your your opinion based on you owning/using an iPhone 5 or just reading Stuff magazine?
Yes I own an iPhone5 because Tim Cook personally flew to my house to deliver one to me. :erm:

It's just from reading all the reviews I could find and checking out the Youtube videos of it being used. I haven't read the Stuff article but I have read Engadget, Gizmodo, Anandtech, Arstechnica, Daring Fireball, and a bunch of others.
 
Last edited:
Why does it feel that so many of these sites are biased towards Apple?

Apple sells phones for the masses for whom image is pretty much the overriding factor in everything they do. Sadly its much bigger market than the intelligent / self-directed. As magazines are in the business of making profit this is the market they target.
 
I do not even, know how to respond to this junk.

Your reply is perfect example of how iSheep eat up what Apple serve em and even worse they believe this **** as fact.

But lapping up the 920 hype is okay?
 
I do not even, know how to respond to this junk.

Your reply is perfect example of how iSheep eat up what Apple serve em and even worse they believe this **** as fact.

Your contemptible arrogance appalls me.
 
I do not even, know how to respond to this junk.

Your reply is perfect example of how iSheep eat up what Apple serve em and even worse they believe this **** as fact.

Actually, no. His reply is perfectly thought out and contains factual information. He even acknowledges that iOS is getting a bit stale and that other phones have higher PPI screens.

Your post is just another example of the entire counter movement that is happening at the moment. Hating on Apple products is becoming 'cool'. Honestly the entire thing is getting tiresome.
 
It is a rather bold statement I agree. But I'm entitled to it, no? It's an opinion poll and I give my opinion freely.

<snip>
But the screen on iPhone5 still looks like the best QUALITY display on the market. It's got what, 50% higher contrast over the 4S? That was already a superbly high contrast screen. The videos I've seen show it to be immediately brighter, warmer and more vivid. It displays the full sRGB gamut which means it displays colours that your pitiful simian eyeballs can't even see. And they brought the sensors as close as possible to the surface which will increase touch sensitivity and thinness. PPI is only a part of what makes a screen excellent - once you've passed the threshold of retina level, other factors become more important. (Although I'm also keen to see whether that 1080p 5" display is noticeably improved to the naked eye; I'll bet it is).

<snip>.

Hey Hey.... gushing aside...

Your source for that 100% sRGB gamut? I can find no reference to it and tablet google is a bit meh.
 
But lapping up the 920 hype is okay?

rofl we are hyped about the 920 because it brings new functionality like wireless charging, nfc, Pureview Carl Zeis optics with image stabilising, free music, sensitive glove friendly touch screen, windows 8, usb host etc.

It's not just a 900 with a bigger screen.

It's really true innovation, only Nokia.

rofl
 
Last edited:
rofl we are hyped about the 920 because it brings new functionality like wireless charging, nfc, Pureview Carl Zeis optics, free music, sensitive glove friendly touch screen, windows 8 etc.

It's not just a 900 with a bigger screen.

It's really true innovation, only Nokia.

rofl

Wireless charging? Heard of the PowerMat?

I'll give Nokia PureView, they certainly are making much better cameras than phones these days.

And how often do you have gloves on while typing? If I was in Serbia this would be the phone for me.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X