Ok I will read the review now

but before that..
That quote you just gave me is exactly where people are misunderstanding.
Its doesn't really matter whether it beats WoW are not, that wasn't Mythic's objective,they have publicly stated that and besides its irrelevant.What they did with Warhammer was create a game that caters for a different segment of the MMORPG market entirely(a segment that no one else caters for and in all fairness WoW falls short in).
The group PvP/World PvP Market,focusing heavily on integrating the World Pve and Pvp seamlessly.Where it actually means something to attack the other realms City,where you can obtain the highest tier items through taking the enemy city and ransacking it.You can literally interfere with the enemies day to day playing and make life hard for them!
So its fine if War Doesn't even get past 1million subsribers...who needs them, cause I dunno about you all I need is
1) full server averaging about 5000 people ready and willing to try their best to pwn me.
2)An experienced and Dedicated Developer who listens to its player base and communicates
3)A guild of like minded people ready to give the enemy Hell
Ask yourself a question, can you really say that you prefer
Group Based Teamwork Vs a Pathetic AI
over
Group Based Teamwork Vs Humans
With that sad, I think about 90% of the reviews you've read confirm one thing WAR is lackluster in many area's To WoW,possibly light years behind,but one thing they all agree on,its Superior with Regards to PvP in Every Aspect.
Thats it
Edit* oh yea and that review is an older outdated one for older Beta Version,which was 6 months ago.....LOL.....check out the latest one here
http://www.mmogamer.com/08/27/2008/warhammer-online-third-impressions