Broadband ratings: Please give your feedback!

rpm

rpm

Admin
Staff member
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
66,806
Reaction score
5,057
Location
Johannesburg
Hi folks

As you know we are currently busy processing the testing results. Your feedback is again needed to ensure that we assign suitable weights to each component of the broadband rating formula.

Can you please assign weights to each of the following components (give a numerical indication of how important it is to you…higher = more important). Please Note: you only have 100 points to play with! The sum of all your weights must therefore add up to 100.

Basic monthly cost:
Cost per extra Gig:
Download Speed:
Upload Speed:
Uptime/Reliability:
Latency:
Cap size:
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility):

I know that this is quite a time consuming exercise, but it will be of great value if as many of you as possible can complete this survey. If you would not like to post your results here you are welcome to mail them to [email protected] (non members welcome!).

Thanks and regards,

RPM
 
I just know I'm gonna get laughed at, but this is what I think ATM :-)

Basic monthly cost: 30%
Cost per extra Gig: 5%
Download Speed: 6%
Upload Speed: 6%
Uptime/Reliability: 35%
Latency: 10% (for VoIP, i.e. Skype)
Cap size: 4%
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 4%

<added>
This is mostly for business, i.e.
  • VoIP: reliability & latency critical here
  • email: reliability critical here
  • browsing: mostly research - important but not time sensitive so can tolerate some downtime, uncapped local very important here, international not critical
  • Own hosting: upload speed important here
</added>
 
Last edited:
Basic monthly cost: 15%
Cost per extra Gig: 5%
Download Speed: 10%
Upload Speed: 10%
Uptime/Reliability: 20%
Latency:30%
Cap size: 5%
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5%

Typical Gamer :D
 
You're included in the survey too RPM, post your feedback here mate :) (unless you feel you shouldnt for some other reason of course)
 
Hi Razor0

Thanks for the invite :D

Basic monthly cost: 18%
Cost per extra Gig: 6%
Download Speed: 20%
Upload Speed: 10%
Uptime/Reliability: 25%
Latency:8%
Cap size: 3%
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 10%
 
Basic monthly cost: 20%
Cost per extra Gig: 5%
Download Speed: 20%
Upload Speed: 10%
Uptime/Reliability: 20%
Latency:15%
Cap size: 5%
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5%
 
Basic monthly cost: 25
Cost per extra Gig: 10
Download Speed: 10
Upload Speed: 5
Uptime/Reliability: 25
Latency: 10
Cap size: 10
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5
 
Basic monthly cost:25
Cost per extra Gig:15
Download Speed:15
Upload Speed:5
Uptime/Reliability:15
Latency:10
Cap size:10
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility):5
 
Basic monthly cost: 15%
Cost per extra Gig: 10%
Download Speed: 15%
Upload Speed: 5%
Uptime/Reliability: 10%
Latency: 20% (International gaming like WoW + Local Gaming like Quake 3)
Cap size: 20%
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5%
 
Basic monthly cost: 25
Cost per extra Gig: 5
Download Speed: 15
Upload Speed: 5
Uptime/Reliability: 15
Latency: 5
Cap size: 20
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 10
 
Basic monthly cost: 25
Cost per extra Gig: 7
Download Speed: 10
Upload Speed: 5
Uptime/Reliability: 20
Latency: 8
Cap size: 20
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5
 
Hi RPM

Just a quick comment here...would it not be worthwhile maybe taking the Broadband ratings a step further - i.e. rank services in which is best for:

1.) Overall
2.) Gaming/Online Trading
3.) Residential Browsing and Downloading
4.) Business Use and Reliablity

The reason I say this, is that it is obvious that different kinds of users will weight latency and download speed differently according to their needs.

For example, I'm looking to primarily game with my ADSL, thus:

Basic monthly cost: 25
Cost per extra Gig: 10
Download Speed: 10
Upload Speed: 5
Uptime/Reliability: 15
Latency: 20
Cap size: 10
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5
 
Basic monthly cost: 20
Cost per extra Gig: 10
Download Speed: 10
Upload Speed: 5
Uptime/Reliability: 10
Latency: 20
Cap size: 20
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5
 
I agree with what lewstherin said...

But first we would need to find out all the different usage types - there are probably several more that could be added to the list, in particular I think a Skype and/or Other VoIP usage type would be useful for both home & business users.
 
Maybe "Intended Usage" should be a separate list, also with percentages. My reasons for low latency is work related (i.e. vpn, ssh) although I wouldn't mind trying out a few local racing games :D
 
Basic monthly cost: 25%
Cost per extra Gig: 5%
Download Speed: 30%
Upload Speed: 5%
Uptime/Reliability: 15%
Latency: 5%
Cap size: 10%
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5%
 
Hi guys

Thanks for all the feedback so far...please keep it coming! Your feedback will directly influence the final outcome of the results, so please give your views/weights if you have not done so already.

Regards,

RPM
 
Basic monthly cost: 30
Cost per extra Gig: 25
Download Speed: 10
Upload Speed: 5
Uptime/Reliability: 10
Latency: 5
Cap size: 10
General Service (helpdesk, support, mobility): 5
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X