Who is the best IS/Telkom

mirco30za

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2005
Messages
109
Reaction score
0
Location
Randburg
We want to change our current network from Telkom frame-relay to a adsl/mpls/diginet solution we have got quotes from both parties involved and as you know it took Telkom 4 tries to get a quote that was even close to IS but "The powers that be" have asked me to come up with a few reason why we should move our network to IS and not stay with Telkom
this ia what I have :

Telkom are known for not being a service driven organization . This is qualified in that almost every person you come into contact with has had a bad experience with Telkom and the only reason they ( Telkom ) own the market is based on their monopolistic status . Their latter bullying of the communications sector has left a bad taste in most entities mouths .

Would you consider placing your mission critical business needs / functions / applications , in the hands of an organization that is known for not coming back to a client when support and administrative issues are raised .

Telkom have undergone massive change ( 3000 retrenchments ) , despite a 1 billion net profit report on their last annual financials – this has created a cloud over the Telkom Staff, further impacting on their already shaky service levels .

Telkom will only be able to offer Telkom Services which up and until a 8 months ago was all that was on offer , however VOIP is now legal and the SNO ( Second Network Operator ) has been confirmed and the latter ( including other SP’s eg. Sentech ) will now offer network infrastructure . This means , SDK will want an organization who’s interest is providing a service based on best of breed infrastructure and not limited to one carrier . The latter is a very successful model predominantly used in the USA and Europe .

Telkom , based on it’s past and quasi governmental mindset is known to (1) have accounts issues that never seem to get resolved ; (2) terrible at providing utilization reports ( and any other reports for that matter ) on a clients links and VPN’s ; (3) slow to resolve technical issues ; (4) not proactive in finding Solutions to innovate and improve a clients communications , ie. Telkom bring in ADSL as a medium and IS are the pioneers in introducing uncapped ADSL with static IP’s , ADSL in a VPN format etc. Obviously Telkom introduced uncapped ADSL and an ADSL VPN Offering after IS had .

The primary issue is around the fact that Telkom have not had the SA Corporate and Consumer Market’s best interest at heart , in that inflated infrastructural and call costs have been allowed to prevail for so long . Economists and business analysts have been baying for deregulation within the SA Communications Sector for many years , not to mention the sentiment of the entire corporate market .


I was hoping I could get other reasons from the people here:rolleyes:
 
SAIX ADSL users connecting to IS servers will suffer big time. The delay is intolerable at times.

Other than that, IS is a good company.
 
Telkom in my personal opinion is quite good, just look at the prices of the shares now and when they started, must be an indication of how well they are ripping the f@cking public off.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X