Africa-succumbs-to-colonial-style-land-grab

darkevil

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2008
Messages
818
Reaction score
139
Location
Hell
It is being dubbed the second scramble for Africa: millions of acres of land are being snapped up by companies from Asia and the Middle East, our foreign Affairs Correspondent Jonathan Rugman reports.

Nations like Ethiopia are desperate for the investment. But critics claim it's at the expense of smallholder farmers - many of whom say they're being thrown off their land to make way for the large multi-nationals.

Think of drought-stricken Ethiopia and you might not expect to see modern machinery owned by a foreign multinational, cultivating vast farms in one of the poorest countries in the world.

The goal here is simple: to double Ethiopia's agricultural production and to make it self-sufficient. So that handouts from Britain, America and others are no longer required.

Agrarian revolution

Vinay Shekar is on the front line of this agrarian revolution. He's a farm manager from India running an estate in Ethiopia.

His company is called Karuturi and these 29,000 acres are a small slice of its empire - with the Ethiopians pledging almost 800,000 acres to the Indian firm so far.

Ethiopia's land is owned by its post-Communist government - and that land can't feed its people. Farming methods are medieval, with the land parcelled up among millions of small scale tenant farmers. So now the country's Agriculture Minister, Ato Wondirad Mande, is giving foreign companies like Karuturi cheap leases to revolutionise food production.

When they first came they told us an investor was coming and we would develop the land alongside one another. They didn't say the land would be taken away from us entirely. Farmer Gemechu Garbaba

He told Channel 4 News: "We give land because we cannot produce on that land. Because of lack of capital and technology, that’s why. They open a big opportunity for employment and of course generation of taxes and other financial gain."

But farmer Gemechu Garbaba talks of loss, not gain. He’s pointing to Karuturi farmland, which he says the government took from him to give to the Indians instead.

"When they first came they told us an investor was coming and we would develop the land alongside one another,"Mr Garbaba told Channel 4 News. "They didn't say the land would be taken away from us entirely. I don't understand why the government took the land."

Mr Garbaba now grows maize on land nearby which he sublets each year from a neighbour. It is precarious, he says. He could lose his tenancy at any moment.

And at the family home his wife complains that the cattle have almost nowhere to graze because their old fields have gone.

"Since the land was taken away from us we are impoverished. Nothing has gone right for us, since these investors came," she added.

Next door Karuturi is beginning to work agricultural wonders. It runs the farm under a 50 year lease, and says it will sell most of its produce inside Ethiopia itself.
African land grab: farmers in Ethiopia (Image: Getty)

Who profits?

With their Indian manager watching them, these women say they are grateful to have a job earning just under fifty pence each per day.

Karuturi can see such good profits that it's investing nearly a billion dollars in Ethiopia. Though in an interview in 2010 the company's founder said it was shameful to accuse the firm of "land grabs" when the country's being transformed.

Sai Ramakrishna Karuturi, Managing Director at Karuturi Global, said: "Why do they need to import food? It’s a shame, I sometimes feel like it's a conspiracy - that people want Africa to remain with a begging bowl.

"Here we are creating employment, food, wealth – isn't that what Adam Smith spoke about - isn't that the reason the West is self sufficient? I don't think creating wealth is a crime."

Here we are creating employment, food, wealth – isn't that what Adam Smith spoke about - isn't that the reason the West is self sufficient? I don't think creating wealth is a crime. Karuturi MD, Sai Ramakrishna

Yet in this village hut everyone complains they have less food than before because Karuturi now farms where they once did.

Taresa Agasa helped put together a petition to change the government’s mind. But when that didn't work, he took a job as a security guard for Karuturi for 45 pence a day.

He said: "We wish we could eat three times a day. I know my children want this. But I cannot provide that. We live and survive only if we have land. And we would rather have our land back."

Ethiopia's agriculture minister claims there is no conflict with local communities and no need to provide compensation.

Yet people here speak bitterly of forced evictions, and this is just a snapshot of a story now playing out all over Africa - as multinationals strike land deals with governments desperate for investment.

The risk is colonial style plantations – with local people swept aside. In a world badly in need of more food, costing less.

http://www.channel4.com/news/africa-succumbs-to-colonial-style-land-grab

Who stands to benefit?

Investment companies or the local populace?
Time will tell.
 
Ethiopia's land is owned by its post-Communist government - and that land can't feed its people. Farming methods are medieval, with the land parcelled up among millions of small scale tenant farmers.
Sounds like our future
 
I would have thought that Africa would have learned their lesson. This time around we can only blame the parties we voted for and ourselves.
 
The chinese are your new masters. But expect them to actually have productive farms compared to these subsistence farms with a few mielies and cattle eating away at the vegetation causing erosion.
 
I for one welcome our new Chinese Baases.

On a lighter note, I don't see this as a bad thing, I would rather have a colonial administrate the land - it will help towards our own prosperity as well.
 
Last edited:
The original farm owners must be properly compensated in some way, government can't just evict them and take away their land and give/sell it to Indian and Chinese investors. It's a good thing though that land will be used by the Chinese or Indians for agriculture or industry so that government will benefit through taxes, job creation will increase too which can only be a good thing.
 
Slavery upon Africans has been practised by fellow Africans for centuries. Europeans only came in for a brief time. But Africans will continue this practise even long after the white man has forgotten about this notion.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sad part is that contrary to was is promised most of the food will go back to India/China to feed their over populated cities and the work generated is minimal as they bring in machines to work the land.

New Zealand And Australia is seeing the same crap
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2011-...buy-crafar-farms-in-new-zealand-update1-.html
http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/far...talks-with-Chinese-bidder-to-run-Crafar-farms
http://www.news.com.au/business/foreign-farm-raiders-buy-9bn-of-aussie/story-e6frfm1i-1225953501132
 
Last edited:
The original farm owners must be properly compensated in some way, government can't just evict them and take away their land and give/sell it to Indian and Chinese investors. It's a good thing though that land will be used by the Chinese or Indians for agriculture or industry so that government will benefit through taxes, job creation will increase too which can only be a good thing.

Bwahahaha, you still fall for that crap?
 
The dumb F$%^%$ks cant do it themselves, somebody else will.
 
I for one welcome our new Chinese Baases.

On a lighter note, I don't see this as a bad thing, I would rather have a colonial administrate the land - it will help towards our own prosperity as well.

Lol. Yeah they have your prosperity in mind. Hehe. You ain't Chinese mate :) pretty soon you and your black brothers will be treated equally by your your new masters :)
 
Lol. Yeah they have your prosperity in mind. Hehe. You ain't Chinese mate :) pretty soon you and your black brothers will be treated equally by your your new masters :)

If these guys are here, we will need to trade with them, it is not as if I want to be a farmer, sure it will be China first Africa 2nd. However if it is in government's hands then it is usually everyone 2nd.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X