Cybersmart Why Grow-for-life is a good idea gone very bad.

Totempole

Executive Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2011
Messages
5,163
Reaction score
1,534
Location
Cape Town
Cybersmart Why Grow-for-life is a good idea gone very bad:

Some time ago, I was looking at Cybersmart's most unique offering:
Grow-for-Life, which gives you extra data for every day you stay
on with them, and the amount your cap increases by is dependent on
how long you've been a member. The cost for this service is R19 per
month.

While this is a great concept, it wasn't thought out very well in terms
of value (Due to the relatively high monthly fee and unfair T's & C's).

Let's use the best case "Worked Example" to show you what I mean:

You have been with Cybersmart for at least two years and you decide you are
going to subscribe to Grow For Life and you have subscribed to a 1 GIG One
Price service.

Your cap will Grow by 3 Mb per day for life. This means that after 1 month,
you cap will have grown to roughly 1.1 Gigs and after a year your cap will
have Grown to 2 Gigs i.e. double your initial cap.

Now for the worked example: for simplicity's sake let's assume there are
30-days in a month.

You sign up for the Grow-for-Life service for 3 years:

Month 1, you get 90MB at R19
Month 2, you get 180MB at R19
Month 3, you get 270MB at R19
Month 4, you get 360MB at R19
Month 5, you get 450MB at R19
Month 6, you get 540MB at R19
Month 7, you get 630MB at R19
Month 8, you get 720MB at R19
Month 9, you get 810MB at R19
Month 10, you get 900MB at R19
Month 11, you get 990MB at R19
Month 12, you get 1080MB at R19
--------------------------------
After 1 Year, you've "earned a total
of 7020MB/6.85GB and it's actually
cost you R228 or R33.28 per GB

--------------------------------
Month 13, you get 1170MB at R19
Month 14, you get 1260MB at R19
Month 15, you get 1350MB at R19
Month 16, you get 1440MB at R19
Month 17, you get 1530MB at R19
Month 18, you get 1620MB at R19
Month 19, you get 1710MB at R19
Month 20, you get 1800MB at R19
Month 21, you get 1890MB at R19
Month 22, you get 1980MB at R19
Month 23, you get 2070MB at R19
Month 24, you get 2160MB at R19
--------------------------------
After 2 Years, you've "earned a total
of 27000MB/26.36GB and it's actually
cost you R456 or R17.29 per GB

--------------------------------
Now on paper, it's starting to look
worthwhile, but remember, it's Feb
2014, and broadband prices have
dropped substantially. (Speculation
of course but pretty darn accurate
I'm sure) Another thing to note is
you've only progressed from a 1GB
monthly cap up to about 3GB. :D
--------------------------------
Month 25, you get 2250MB at R19
Month 26, you get 2340MB at R19
Month 27, you get 2430MB at R19
Month 28, you get 2520MB at R19
Month 29, you get 2610MB at R19
Month 30, you get 2700MB at R19
Month 31, you get 2790MB at R19
Month 32, you get 2880MB at R19
Month 33, you get 2970MB at R19
Month 34, you get 3060MB at R19
Month 35, you get 3150MB at R19
Month 36, you get 3240MB at R19
--------------------------------
After 3 Years, you've "earned a total
of 59940MB/58.54GB and it's actually
cost you R684 or R11.68 per GB

--------------------------------

It's now February 2015, and all that's happened is, you've bought 58.54GB for R684,
and you've increased your monthly cap to just over 4GB :D.

In summary, if you need more data, just buy a damn Topup instead of trying to be clever.

;)

I hope I haven't bored you guys to tears, I just felt that Cybersmart users should
be aware of how Cybersmart is trying to rip them of. I'm not even going to go into
the concept of the Giggy bank, but essentially, the same applies. :mad:

Night Rider is the only thing that actually makes any sense! :wtf:
 
...or get Cybersmart bandwidth @ R 9 / GB (=/> 50 GB) - http://www.btweb.co.za/?page=product_BasicADSL

Traceroute Results For: www.btweb.co.za

traceroute to www.btweb.co.za (196.41.123.155), 20 hops max, 40 byte packets
1 143.160.35.253 (143.160.35.253) 0.781 ms 0.761 ms 0.766 ms
2 143.160.0.18 (143.160.0.18) 3.125 ms 3.156 ms 3.158 ms
3 pcm-fwg-veth-to-bb.p.nwu.ac.za (143.160.129.245) 0.283 ms 0.302 ms 0.390 ms
4 mk1-igs01-eth0.p.nwu.ac.za (143.160.4.1) 0.582 ms 0.970 ms 1.051 ms
5 unknown.uni.net.za (155.232.6.125) 1.199 ms 1.322 ms 1.454 ms
6 unknown.uni.net.za (155.232.6.121) 3.522 ms 3.449 ms 3.481 ms
7 unknown.uni.net.za (155.232.6.170) 3.400 ms 2.768 ms 2.805 ms
8 unknown.uni.net.za (155.232.6.114) 27.948 ms 28.127 ms 27.956 ms
9 cybersmart.cinx.net.za (196.223.22.39) 29.317 ms 29.148 ms 29.093 ms
10 colocation.cybersmart.co.za (196.41.124.60) 28.485 ms 28.384 ms 28.237 ms
11 196.41.123.155-colocation.cybersmart.co.za (196.41.123.155) 106.573 ms 107.232 ms 106.821 ms

Maybe it is time for Cybersmart, (like most other ISP's) to revisit their product offerings.
 
Last edited:
Maybe it is time for Cybersmart, (like most other ISP's) to revisit their product offerings.

My thoughts exactly. The idea behind this thread is to try and give Cybersmart some constructive criticism. With the huge drop in ADSL data prices, Grow-For-Life would only be worthwhile again if:
1. Your ADSL Cap is increased by at least 6MB per day instead of 3MB.
2. Your ADSL Circuit doesn't have to be with Cybersmart to qualify for Grow-for-Life.

Like I said in the beginning, Grow-For-Life is a great concept, it's just that it's an old product which has become severely overpriced over the years.

Night-Rider will never age, because it's value increases as the price of ADSL Data decreases (More for your money).

The Giggy Bank has also aged, since a 1GB Giggy Bank costs R21pm (More than what it costs to just buy an extra GB from most ISP's) Even the "Unlimited Giggy Bank" seems overpriced. Maybe R9 for the 1GB Giggy and R29 for the Unlimited Giggy would be more fair?

Cybersmart has phoned to offer me 10GB Data for R99pm on numerous occasions. To me this is a good price, so why are they still charging exorbitant prices for the addons?

It's also ridiculous to withhold services from clients who would rather not move their ADSL lines away from Telkom.
 
Last edited:
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X