Youth gets suspended sentence for raping girl

Random717

Expert Member
Joined
May 30, 2006
Messages
2,121
Reaction score
24
:mad:

This is now the third reported lenient sentence handed down to a youth member. WTF?
 
hmmm how are they going to stop crime if they cannot hand out the correct sentences for caught criminals

i would not be scared if i was a criminal
 
Judge Hlophe said he was satisfied that a sentence of three years, wholly suspended for five years, was appropriate in this case.
The victim might disagree with the honourable judge Hlophe.
Slap in the face of womans rights.

I'm surprised Hlophe is still on the bench quite frankly after recent revelations about his income.
 
:eek: OMG WTF:confused: ......I cant believe it!! GRRR!! he knew waht he was doing in the 1st place!!! This government is starting to really P*** me off!!! Things will NEVER come right in SA with the way we seem to be dealing with crime!! Pffffts!!:mad:
 
Just goes to show, black judges aint no better than white judges, and that the justice system isn't about justice, they should name it somethings else...
 
Just goes to show, black judges aint no better than white judges, and that the justice system isn't about justice, they should name it somethings else...

Indeed, this is not the way forward...

He said that while the community was crying out for protection from rapists, the court should not lose sight of the object of punishment.

That objective is clearly not to actually punish :p :mad:
 
Maybe life in prison would be excessive, but what he's getting instead is a slap on the wrist. It's like deciding the death penalty is a bit too severe for a particular crime so instead you're going to let the perpetrator walk. Why does it have to be severe punishment or no punishment?
 
Opposition concerned as Hlophe returns to work?

Cape Judge President John Hlophe's return from long leave despite persisting conflict of interest charges against him bodes ill for public confidence in the judiciary, the Democratic Alliance said on Tuesday.

The two months of Hlophe's break should have been used to conclude a probe into claims that he had received money from a private entity, it said in a statement.

A failure to do so, the party said, "means that Justice Hlophe, who returned to work yesterday [Monday], cannot properly carry out his duties".

It is untenable that the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) and the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development have failed to take appropriate action to date, the DA said.

"Both have failed to take decisive action and the result is a situation in which ... the judge president, the public and the judiciary [do not know] what precisely is happening."

Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development Brigitte Mabandla has previously said her department was unaware of Hlophe having received permission to accept private payments.

Accused of failing to disclose business interests, Hlophe has reportedly claimed to have had permission from former minister Dullah Omar to receive money from a private company.

He is alleged to have received R10 000 a month from April 2002 to March 2003 from Cape Town-based Oasis Group Holdings in the form of a "consultation tariff".

Hlophe reportedly said he was given "expense payments" for providing his expertise, but denied having received a retainer. He was granted long leave while the JSC investigated the matter.

http://www.mg.co.za/articlePage.aspx?articleid=278677&area=/breaking_news/breaking_news__national/
 
And how about this

A KwaZulu-Natal man was jailed for 18 years for killing a three-year-old girl and eating parts of her body, South African Broadcasting Corporation radio news reported on Monday.

Eric Delani Chala (29) was sentenced by the high court sitting at Ramsgate on the South Coast.

He killed the child on a farm in the Harding area in July last year. He had been asked to watch over her and her sibling but attacked them with a bush knife.

One child escaped.

Chala caught the three-year-old, killed her, roasted and ate some of her flesh, then cut up her body and stored the pieces in a mealie bag.

After his arrest, Chala was assessed by psychiatrists and found fit to stand trial and not mentally disturbed. -- Sapa

http://www.mg.co.za/articlepage.aspx?area=/breaking_news/breaking_news__national/&articleid=280771
 
WTF so this guy just walks free. My mate got a R4000 fine and 100hrs comunity service for DRUNK DRIVEING!! If this judge realy thinks the guy doesn't deserve jail he could have at least given him comunity service or something(allthough as far as im conserned underage or not the guy should have got the maximun sentance)
 
18 years for murdering a 3 year old child, roasting and eating part of her body
only 18 years!?!?!? WTF!?!?
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X