'Boere' station wins appeal

xtermin8or

Expert Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2006
Messages
1,815
Reaction score
0
The Independent Communication Authority of SA (Icasa) must reconsider Radio Pretoria's application for a broadcasting licence, the Supreme Court of Appeal ruled on Friday.

The station is a community radio station catering for "boere-Afrikaners".

News 24

Radio Pretoria - Die Stasie met Grense
 
Johannesburg - Radio Pretoria "for Boere-Afrikaners" will take legal advice on the loss of its four-year licence to broadcast, the station said on Friday.

The station said the Independent Communications Authority of SA had taken more than a year to provide reasons for its refusal.

According to Radio Pretoria, Icasa's reasons were the same as those for the refusal of its one-year licence:

# that the directors of the section 21 (not-for-profit) company running the station were not democratically chosen; and

# that the station employed no "volksvreemdes" (aliens), by which they presumably meant people of colour.


The station said Icasa had added three new reasons:

# that the directors were not representative of the "Boere-Afrikaner" community in the Bronkhorstspruit-Cullinan area;

# that decision-making positions were not about equally held by men and women; and

# that there was no need for a station such as Radio Pretoria, as it did not add anything extra to the offerings of Radio Sonder Grense, the Afrikaans language service of the SABC.

In rebuttal, Radio Pretoria said:

# it had broadcast legally for 10 years into a much-larger area than just Bronkhorstspruit-Cullinan;

# no institution in South Africa had yet achieved a 50% representation of women; and

# anyone listening to its broadcasts and those of RSG would easily notice the difference between them.
\
http://www.news24.com/News24/South_Africa/News/0,,2-7-1442_1527304,00.html
 
This is the problem with ICASA, strange regulations that cannot be met (a democratically elected governing body (not just the section 21 company) which must also be representative of the population covered in the area as well as include women and disadvantaged individuals), which they turn against radio stations (or turn a blind eye to) as they wish.

LPFM is the only real hope for radio in this country, however we can expect that to be regulated into obscurity as well.
 
It's a situation where individuals in certain positions of authority run their affairs like a feifdom, imposing their own cultural/religious/political views on the entire community over which they preside.
 
Are there any other races, except for blacks, working at Thobela FM? :confused:
 
According to my Nephew who works for a Radio Station claims that the fact that they won The Appeal is not news as just about in every case similar to this the Parties have won against ICASA with costs.

However ICASA will now grant a licence and all, but with conditions. The devil is in the detail.
The thing with Community Radio Stations is they have to represent the geographics of the area it is in, which according to my Nephew is almost always impracticable as if they did the "Boere Station" would have to cater for 9 black people for every one white person, which would defeat the object of a Boere Station in the first place.
A bit of a vicious circle.

The other thing with these Appeals.
ICASA is perhaps quick to deny a licence, but who pays for the legal fees in the end, which in this case I hear is R600K which is likely just the one sides costs. I suppose us, the taxpayer, the community in other words. Seems ironic that the community in the end pays for legal bills for an inept system for someone that is applying for a community radio licence targeted at a certain market.
 
Last edited:
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X