Marius Fransman Jewish Comments Row

LazyLion

King of de Jungle
Joined
Mar 17, 2005
Messages
107,590
Reaction score
10,235
Location
District 9
Issued by: SAJBD

Attention: News Editors

For immediate release:

12 March 2013

JEWISH BOARD OF DEPUTIES APPROACHES SA HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION OVER DEPUTY MINISTER'S DIVISIVE RHETORIC

The SA Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) has requested the SA Human Rights Commission to intervene in a matter concerning certain inflammatory remarks made by Deputy Minister Marius Fransman. The SAJBD decided to approach the SAHRC after several requests to Mr Fransman's offices for a meeting to discuss and clarify his statements received no response.

In a radio interview broadcast by Voice of the Cape on 27 February Mr Fransman, speaking in his other capacity as ANC leader in the Western Cape, condemned the Democratic Alliance for allegedly giving building contracts that had previously been held by Muslims to Jewish businessmen.

The substance and context of these remarks clearly intimated that in the view of Mr Fransman and his party, the Jewish community in Cape Town was unfairly benefiting economically at the expense of the Muslim community.

Specifically, Mr Fransman stated the following:

We saw that the DA had given over building contracts .. as well as lots of contracts in Woodstock and Observatory that historically were in the hands of Muslim participants and now they have given it to people from the Jewish community; so that we've picked up and so that is not right. We must not divide our people.

The religious affiliations of the individuals allegedly concerned should have been regarded as entirely irrelevant. Instead, Mr Fransman made a point of drawing attention to them, and did so, moreover, in terms suggesting that Muslims were being unfairly disadvantaged in order to benefit the Jewish community. It can only be inferred that his purpose in doing so was to solicit Muslim support for his party by suggesting that a rival political party was promoting Jewish economic interests at the expense of Muslims.

Mary Kluk, National Chairman of the SAJBD, said that pitting one religious community against another for vote-catching purposes was deplorable under any circumstances, and was particularly unacceptable when coming from a high-ranking member of government.

"The SAJBD unequivocally condemns attempts to pursue political goals through resorting to such inflammatory practices. Doing so diametrically contradict the ethos of tolerance and inter-group harmony on which our society is proud to base itself" she said.

Mrs Kluk further emphasized that in the lead-up to next year's national elections, it was all the more imperative that political leaders refrain from rhetoric that generated resentment and mistrust between different groups, whether these are defined along racial, religious, ethnic, linguistic or any other lines.

For more information please contact Mary Kluk on 083 77 586 18 or Zev Krengel on 082 557 9681

Issued by Wendy Kahn

National Director: SAJBD

Charisse Zeifert

Head: Communications

South African Jewish Board of Deputies

' 011 645 2547 (direct) or 082 427-2788 (mobile)

6 086 614 6789

* [email protected]

+ PO Box 87557, Houghton 2041

<www.jewishsa.co.za/> www.jewishsa.co.za


Source : Ends /avb
Date : 12 Mar 2013 13:05
 
ANC Western Cape chairman Marius Fransman apologised if he had "created the impression" that he pitted Muslims against Jews to attract votes, the Cape Times reported on Thursday.

"The SA Jewish Board of Deputies' (SAJBD) accusation that I am pitting one religious community against another for vote-catching purposes is deplorable under any circumstances, and is particularly unacceptable especially coming from a lobby that remains silent on its support for apartheid Israel's human rights abuses as well as the Democratic Alliance's war on the poor," he said.

"If what I said created this impression, I apologise."

Fransman told the newspaper he was on record as saying all faith communities, all business leaders and all citizens should work together on the country's challenges.

In an interview last month, broadcast by radio station Voice of the Cape, Fransman claimed the DA had handed a Jewish businessman building contracts in Observatory and Woodstock which were previously held by Muslim businesses.

At the time, the newspaper quoted him as saying: "The SA Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) is driving an interest outside of the national interest.

"I am calling on them to be equally vigilant about issues such as substance abuse....

"What we are asking is them to do is to focus on problems such as service delivery. They must also be vocal when small businesses of Muslims are not getting opportunities."

Fransman, who is also deputy international relations and co-operation minister, was speaking as Western Cape ANC leader.

On Tuesday, the SAJBD said it had approached the SA Human Rights Commission about Fransman's remarks.

It said it did so after Fransman did not respond to the board's requests for him to explain his remarks.

National chairwoman Mary Kluk said the substance and context of the remarks intimated that, in Fransman's and his party's view, the Jewish community in Cape Town was unfairly benefiting economically at the expense of the Muslim community.


Source : Sapa /je/fg/clh
Date : 14 Mar 2013 09:18
 
Last edited:
Fransman Misses Rights Meeting

ANC Western Cape chairman Marius Fransman failed to attend a mediation meeting with the SA Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) after a comment he made, the Cape Times reported on Wednesday.

In an interview with the Voice of the Cape radio station in February, Fransman had alleged that the Democratic Alliance handed building contracts in two Cape Town suburbs, previously held by Muslims, to Jewish businessmen.

The SAJBD then reportedly lodged a complaint with the SA Human Rights Commission (SAHRC), which arranged a mediation meeting for last Friday with Fransman's agreement.

The complaint was that he had made demeaning and inflammatory remarks that could create animosity between Muslims and Jews.

Fransman told the newspaper he saw no reason to attend the meeting as he had not said anything in violation of human rights.

"I don't believe what I said is wrong... I'm prepared to meet them [the board] to engage about real human issues in previously disadvantaged communities," he was quoted as saying.

The SAHRC reportedly received a letter from Fransman explaining his absence.

The investigation into the complaint would continue.


Source : Sapa /je/fg/jk
Date : 12 Jun 2013 09:08
 
It would be good to see if Marius Fransman statements is true. Will be a big blow for the DA - If its true then they deserve it....

PS: Thanks to SAJBD for making a hoohaaa about this as I and many other Jobuggers would not have know about these DA tactics (if proven) if it was left at the radio interview.
 
It would be good to see if Marius Fransman statements is true. Will be a big blow for the DA - If its true then they deserve it....

PS: Thanks to SAJBD for making a hoohaaa about this as I and many other Jobuggers would not have know about these DA tactics (if proven) if it was left at the radio interview.

The facts are true, but his interpretation of the facts are nothing more than racist, hateful self-serving rethoric.
 
Fransman told the newspaper he was on record as saying all faith communities, all business leaders and all citizens should work together on the country's challenges.

So when is it a good time to give another community a chance to do something for South Africa? At what point do we say, "ok, you had your turn now let's give someone else the job"?

Must we assume that there were no tenders issued for all building contractors in Cape Town or that ONLY Muslim building contractors were consulted and used?
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X