My plan now:
1)Get an external antenna/antennas from Poynting
2)Get a second B593 the B593s-22 and test out the other 3 service providers.
Questions I have for you if you have time (feel free to skip any questions):
1)Which should I get from Poynting?
I don’t want to buy two sets of antennas to test out the 4 service providers.. but buying the LPDA-0092 which will work with all 4 seems over kill (all towers are maximum 1.5km from me). The XPOL-0001 just does not seem like it’s got enough behind it (could be my ignorance to antenna’s though )… and buying one XPOL-0002 and XPOL-0006 just seems like I’m taking the experiment too far. I do also want to have redundancy for if one of the service providers go down.
1)Where did you find the B593s-22 in South Africa – everywhere is out of stock.
2)Will the B593u-12 work with Cell C, MTN, and Vodacom -
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/HUAWEI-B5...omputing_Wireless_Routers&hash=item1c3bfcb0ff
3)From what I can tell and all my speed tests it seems that Telkoms up speed is not as good as the other service providers but their data is cheaper which is a plus… but im more interested in speed. Have you found this?
4)Have you seen a reduction in speed with the Telkom package becoming more popular?
Thanks for all your posts.
Poynting have purpose-specific antennas from omni to directional, from 3G to LTE. For LTE one must look at the supported frequencies which align to the LTE bands:
Band 1 = FDD 2100MHz (Cell C)
Band 3 = FDD 1800MHz (MTN and Vodacom)
Band 40 = TDD 2300MHz (Telkom Mobile)
I've found that the XPOL-0002, which covers bands 1 and 3 above, works just fine on Telkom Mobile too. I posted about this
here.
Edit: the first version of the XPOL-0002 does *not* support Telkom Mobile LTE.
If you're a purist I suppose you'll really want the XPOL-0006 for band 40. However, note that this product has no gain in the frequencies used by LTE bands 1 and 3.
Edit: info updated.
So, if you want just one (directional) antenna then get the XPOL-0002-v2, or the LPDA-0020, or the LPDA-0092. The LPDA-0092 is the King Kong of LTE antennas and also comes with 7m cable as opposed to 5m for the XPOL range. (I believe you can order these products with 10m integrated cable from Poynting)
Edit: corrected my information.
The LPDA is really nice high up on a mast but requires extra precaution for wind and lightning. This is the ultimate no doubt. The XPOL-0002 and -0006 have the advantage of being mountable under an eve. They can of course be pole mounted as well. The signal cable is only 5m though. One sometimes needs to be creative to make the link between antenna and LTE router. Else get extension cables from Poynting, I found the loss to only be 0.8dBm per metre. Hardly made a difference. On my 7m LPDA signal cable, an additional 5m dropped the signal from -69dBM to -73dBm.
Note the XPOLs have two signal cables coming out of the antenna housing for MIMO. The B593 of course supports two antenna feeds. With the LPDA, you need to get two to get MIMO. The installation is also more technical and frustrating.
I don't have a B593-22 but a Vodafone B593, basically a rebranded B593-12. MTN have the Sharelink branded B593. These two are equivalent and interchangeable but won't work with a Telkom Mobile SIM. You can use it for MTN, Vodacom and Cell C. You'll just need to create multiple APN profiles and switch them as you switch SIM cards.
The latest MTN Yello Trader has the Sharelink B593 on p13 for as little as R169pm. Quite frankly I'd take the bundled SIM and put it away, especially if it's an open contract. Get an Afrihost SIM in its stead. I can't find the Vodafone B593 any more. It seems Vodacom has switched to ZTE instead of using Huawei LTE routers.
Telkom Mobile's upload speed is very good but doesn't really go higher than 7Mbps. It seems to be limited most of the time. MTN has triple the upload speed. I've found Telkom Mobile to be far faster on downloads though. So it's six of one and half a dozen of the other. For everyday use the higher upload is academic. I'm sure it benefits my iCloud and Dropbox but that is a small benefit. For an initial sync it would be really fast of course. For my VoIP service it didn't help though. More on this just now.
Telkom Mobile's PSB Data Promo has excellent value with the 25GB+25GB and 60GB+60GB prepaid packages. No contracts and the data is valid for a year. Afrihost comes very close with their 10GB+10GB double-up special. There isn't rollover though. Vodacom data is completely unfeasible (until MyGig 20 makes a return) and there also isn't a reliable way to monitor data usage. Cell C's Giga packages offer the best value of all. I just can't vouch for their LTE, yet.
As for speed reduction on the LTE network, I haven't witnessed this yet. I've had some ups and downs on my tower but things have really smoothed out over time. My speeds are really consistent. I'm not seeing my record 73Mbps I saw with my LPDAs. However I am happier overall with my XPOL though due to a neater installation and protection from the weather. I don't get much higher than 50Mbps.
Edit: done right now -
I normally get higher speeds on a laptop or desktop.
Azimuth said:
For my VoIP service it didn't help though. More on this just now.
Oddly for my VoIP service my LTE doesn't provide as good an experience as expected. The pings reported to me by my service provider don't match my Speedtest pings at all and this is the issue. Supposedly this is due to UDP traffic which LTE doesn't seem to be optimised for. I'd be interested to hear how your video conferencing fares. You must let us know when you're up and running.